Lupron or Not at 76?

Posted by tbgb50 @tbgb50, Aug 1 10:36am

Background - biopsy in 2022 was completely clean. Biopsy in 2026, Gleason 9. PET shows cancer is localized.

Had first appointment with oncologist yesterday. Recommended 5 weeks of Photon radiation treatments and 2 years of Lupron. I'm fine with the radiation but:

I was told the success rate is 80% for the radiation and another 5% with the Lupron. One problem is the 80% success rate is not based on age groups so it's difficult to decide if the Lupron is worth it because:

I was told at 76 the 'recovery period' for Lupron = the amount of time you get the treatment. So 2 years of treatment + 2 years of recovery = 4 years. I'd be 80 and I was told at this age you often don't see the side effects of Lupron reverse so it seems high risk for not much reward.

Am I thinking about this correctly?

Has anyone roughly my age gone with Lupron and really regretted it? Why

THANKS!

FWIW at this point I need to decided between:

Radiation only
Radiation + 1 year of Lupron (my idea)
Radiation + 2 years of Lupron (recommendation from urologist and oncologist).

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Prostate Cancer Support Group.

Profile picture for carlsbadguy @carlsbadguy

@jeffmarc
No, it says coverage duration is 12 months, which as I read it means they will only cover it for 12 months. Your reading glasses must have a smudge on them. 🙂

Jump to this post

@carlsbadguy
Coverage duration does not mean that they will not cover past that, if the doctor says you need it.

REPLY
Profile picture for Jeff Marchi @jeffmarc

@carlsbadguy
If you check the image you posted the first few letters are cut off.

Coverage and average both have the same 6 letters at the end. I made a guess it said average!

Jump to this post

@jeffmarc
You're correct, the thumbnail in the post has the first 3 letters cut off, however if you click on the thumbnail the full image opens and shows the Coverage Duration 1 year. I always have to click on thumbnails posted in this forum, they're too small for me to read.

I read Coverage Duration 1 year as meaning they will only pay for the drug for one year, and according to Medicare they are allowed to set time and quantity limits. I will call them to clarify before open enrollment. If need be I will find another Part D provider who will cover it starting in January.

REPLY
Profile picture for jime51 @jime51

@tbgb50 Gotcha re: copay. I strongly urge demanding Orgovyx rather than Lupron and evaluating your quality of life after three months with an eye to taking ADT for no more than six to nine months since no meastasis is indicated. I had the full bucket load of side effects that only relaxed a little after a year on Orgovyx. At 75 and not aspiring to live to 90, if my cancer returns I will likely look for spot radiation rather than resuming ADT. Here's one video from a reputable research source, but there are many. https://youtu.be/UFPakxHnkLs

Jump to this post

@jime51
Thanks very much I appreciate the video! While I don't know the options if the cancer does not respond to the treatment or in returns, my mindset is similar. Not looking to several years where the cure is so difficult and uncertain.

REPLY
Profile picture for carlsbadguy @carlsbadguy

@jeffmarc
You're correct, the thumbnail in the post has the first 3 letters cut off, however if you click on the thumbnail the full image opens and shows the Coverage Duration 1 year. I always have to click on thumbnails posted in this forum, they're too small for me to read.

I read Coverage Duration 1 year as meaning they will only pay for the drug for one year, and according to Medicare they are allowed to set time and quantity limits. I will call them to clarify before open enrollment. If need be I will find another Part D provider who will cover it starting in January.

Jump to this post

@carlsbadguy
I expanded it rather than opening it sure enough, next time!

REPLY
Profile picture for carlsbadguy @carlsbadguy

@jeffmarc
You're correct, the thumbnail in the post has the first 3 letters cut off, however if you click on the thumbnail the full image opens and shows the Coverage Duration 1 year. I always have to click on thumbnails posted in this forum, they're too small for me to read.

I read Coverage Duration 1 year as meaning they will only pay for the drug for one year, and according to Medicare they are allowed to set time and quantity limits. I will call them to clarify before open enrollment. If need be I will find another Part D provider who will cover it starting in January.

Jump to this post

@carlsbadguy
So many people with advanced prostate cancer need to stay on ADT for 18 to 24 months, this just doesn’t make sense to me that they would have a limit like that.

If you’ve been on here long, you’ve seen it many times, people with many months.

REPLY
Profile picture for Jeff Marchi @jeffmarc

@carlsbadguy
So many people with advanced prostate cancer need to stay on ADT for 18 to 24 months, this just doesn’t make sense to me that they would have a limit like that.

If you’ve been on here long, you’ve seen it many times, people with many months.

Jump to this post

@jeffmarc
I understand Jeff, I've only been on here since my diagnosis in April and am aware of many people on these drugs for 18 to 24 months and other drugs for years. The Part D plan I was on for 7 years more than doubled in price for 2026, I got upset, shopped around and ended up with a plan than costs peanuts as far as premiums go and with a $615 deductible. I have essential tremors, one of the drugs I have taken for years they refused to fill the full prescription. It took 2 months of going back and forth between the Drs office and insurance provider to get the number of pills I need, they had a "quantity limitation". They finally caved and gave me the additional pills I needed, and it is not an expensive drug. I'm not confident they will continue to pay for a $2000+ a month drug when their coverage formulary states they will only cover it for 12 months. You may be right, I may be totally wrong, time will tell.

REPLY
Profile picture for carlsbadguy @carlsbadguy

@jeffmarc
I understand Jeff, I've only been on here since my diagnosis in April and am aware of many people on these drugs for 18 to 24 months and other drugs for years. The Part D plan I was on for 7 years more than doubled in price for 2026, I got upset, shopped around and ended up with a plan than costs peanuts as far as premiums go and with a $615 deductible. I have essential tremors, one of the drugs I have taken for years they refused to fill the full prescription. It took 2 months of going back and forth between the Drs office and insurance provider to get the number of pills I need, they had a "quantity limitation". They finally caved and gave me the additional pills I needed, and it is not an expensive drug. I'm not confident they will continue to pay for a $2000+ a month drug when their coverage formulary states they will only cover it for 12 months. You may be right, I may be totally wrong, time will tell.

Jump to this post

@carlsbadguy
I sure hope they do pay for it. Good luck.

I didn’t think it was so easy to move around with supplementals they have requirement to take you if you get them with a certain amount of time of dropping your previous one?

REPLY

I have great Supplemental Health Insurance, Part D drug coverage is separate. Open enrollment for both Supplemental and Part D is November 1 through Dec 15th for the following year. There is no underwriting, if need be I will simply find a new Part D provider who has Orgovyx in their formulary. starting Jan 1 2027. All of the injectable drugs are covered by Medicare Part B, or a Medicare Advantage plan because they are done in a clinical environment, either a Drs office or an infusion center. Pills like Orgovyx are covered by Part D. I'll have to pay the 2027 Medicare Part D max out of pocket, ($2200-$2400 they haven't announced it yet) then the rest of the year it will cost me $0.

REPLY
Profile picture for carlsbadguy @carlsbadguy

I have great Supplemental Health Insurance, Part D drug coverage is separate. Open enrollment for both Supplemental and Part D is November 1 through Dec 15th for the following year. There is no underwriting, if need be I will simply find a new Part D provider who has Orgovyx in their formulary. starting Jan 1 2027. All of the injectable drugs are covered by Medicare Part B, or a Medicare Advantage plan because they are done in a clinical environment, either a Drs office or an infusion center. Pills like Orgovyx are covered by Part D. I'll have to pay the 2027 Medicare Part D max out of pocket, ($2200-$2400 they haven't announced it yet) then the rest of the year it will cost me $0.

Jump to this post

@carlsbadguy
I shopped Part D last fall and downloaded the formularies. I did not have PC at the time but the three plans of interest: Wellcare, Humana and Aetna/SilverScript all had Orgovyx. Premiums ranged form $0-$95/month in my state. The wildcard is pre-authorization. Orgovyx is a Tier 5 drug on all of them and no way (that I have found) to see how difficult it is to get approval. I also don't remember if there is a limit on the number of month they will cover and this could change for this year during open enrollment.

REPLY
Profile picture for tbgb50 @tbgb50

@jime51
I'm not planning on ADT for two years but if I did, the RX max resets every Jan. I'd pay $2100 for 2026, $2400 for 2027 (only full year) and I'm guessing $2500+ for 2028 since no one knows yet. I'm planning on one year unless something goes very wrong: 1. my PC is aggressive and 2. the urologist said I will not know for a year whether the ADT and radiation worked.

Jump to this post

@tbgb50 said: "2. the urologist said I will not know for a year whether the ADT and radiation worked."

Well now, maybe you won't know for a year, if that's what he thinks the proper time period is, but if you stopped ADT after six months, you would also find out at one year if THAT worked! IOW the treatment period and the evaluation period do not have to be the same. Just sayin'.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.