Lobular Breast Cancer: Let's share and support each other

Posted by mjay @mjay, Jul 28, 2022

Since lobular breast cancer is only 10-15% of all breast cancer diagnoses and now understood to be a unique subset of breast cancer as a whole with different characteristics than ductal breast cancer necessitating different treatments and inherently different risks, I would like to see a separate category under the breast cancer forum so that the most appropriate info is being disseminated for this specific subset of BC. Just a thought.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Breast Cancer Support Group.

@ssmab

Hi @poesmom, I am in my 70s too (70) and I also had ILC in one breast stage 1a. I had IDC stage 1a in my other breast. I had a bilateral mastectomy and at my age I chose not to go through extra surgery for implants. I wanted you to know that I did not have chemo or radiation either. I was relieved not to have it but wondered if it would have given me some extra protection. But I went to Mayo Rochester for my surgery and treatment so I figured I was at a place on the forefront of treatment options. My ILC was triple negative and even so the oncologist and tumor board agreed on the no chemo decision. I am on Tamoxifen ( I have osteoporosis so that's why Tamoxifen even tho I am years past menopause) for the IDC which was estrogen positive. In the Breast Cancer Survivorship area of Mayo I was told that eating 7-9 fruits and vegetables a day would help to prevent recurrence and also daily exercise is very important so I am exercising and eating those 7-9 fruits and vegetables every day. Our goal on this site is to be a bc Survivor and I am sending out love and Survivor wishes to you and all on this site.❤️

Jump to this post

That gives me hope! I spoke to the oncologist for the first time today and he said the same thing! He said there's a good chance I won't need chemo and maybe not radiation either. So, don't go buy a wig just yet, he said. My surgeon wants to do the mastectomy within the next 3 weeks and I'm ready to get it overwith. Then they'll study the tumor and decide for sure about chemo. I'm feeling better about it already. I just wonder how long I'll not be able to do anything strenuous. I'm a bowler and found out how much I lost not being able to bowl during the pandemic. Just starting to get back to normal and now this. *sigh*

REPLY
@kimogi57

Thnk you so much! I have not heard of the Ki 67 test so I will ask my oncologis when I meet with him on Wednesday. I was self sedated when I had the MRI's and it worked. Year ago I tried and failed. My Dr gave me a valium. All I did was cry like a baby and left without the MRI. She gave me something different the last 2 times!! I met with my radiologist for the first time today. I will be having the Encotype DX to see if I qualify for the study re: no radiation and only medications for hormone blocking for 5 years. I can stop the study anytime. I am going to as much as I can about this cancer. If my Encotype comes back high, I am seriously considering what you did. Sending love and healing wishes your way also💕

Jump to this post

Sorry you had a real difficult time trying to have the MRIs. Good to hear that your Dr. gave you something that did help you in the MRI. A lot of the journey we are all going though is scary. I try to stay strong and believe that all will be well.

REPLY
@ssmab

Sorry to hear that you have been through a lot. Good news about your 1a result on the occular tumor tho! That was a victory!
I did not have an Oncotype dx test either. The oncologist said because my Ki 67 test number was low at 5%. From what I am reading not all hospitals do Ki 67 tests. Not sure on that tho. Maybe you can ask your Doctor what your Ki 67 test result was. I was told if it's under 14% usually no chemo and better all around.
They told me since I had a bilateral mastectomy no mammograms or Breast MRIs now. I just will have my chest wall and underarms checked every 6 months for 5 years. If they want to do a breast MRI on you once a year and you are very claustrophobic they can give you a medication to relax you. I have heard from people that does help. Maybe that's an option for you? You probably already knew that. My Mom got claustrophobic so I know how how awful that can be. I close my eyes as soon as I get on the table of the MRI machine and never open them until I am out of the machine. That helps me.
Good to hear about your Mom being a survivor at 84! Hooray!
Sending love and healing wishes to you❤️

Jump to this post

Thnk you so much! I have not heard of the Ki 67 test so I will ask my oncologis when I meet with him on Wednesday. I was self sedated when I had the MRI's and it worked. Year ago I tried and failed. My Dr gave me a valium. All I did was cry like a baby and left without the MRI. She gave me something different the last 2 times!! I met with my radiologist for the first time today. I will be having the Encotype DX to see if I qualify for the study re: no radiation and only medications for hormone blocking for 5 years. I can stop the study anytime. I am going to as much as I can about this cancer. If my Encotype comes back high, I am seriously considering what you did. Sending love and healing wishes your way also💕

REPLY
@kimogi57

I am also interested in recurrence. Having a mamogram only is also my biggest fear--I read this cancer is hard to detect with a mamogram until it larger. Have you been given the Oncotype DX test? I am 66yo. had a suspecious area on my right breast in July 2022. Left breast was fine. 8/23/2022 I had an ultrasound and they could see nothing so they ordered a MRI. I am highly clostrophbic and put off the MRI until 5/2023. The MRI with and without contrast showed an area calcifications on the right breast but also showed an enhancing 5 mm mass on my left breast. June 12, 2023 I had a contrast enhanced mamogram and ultrasound which showed a 6mm enhancing mass on the left breast. On 7/10 I had a MRI guided biopsy which which ultimately led to a diagnosis of Invasive Lobular carcenoma, Nottingham grade 1-2 and ER/PR 100% positive and HER ngative. I had a lumpectomy on 8/21. Two lymph nodes were negative and my tumor margins were clear. If I remember correctly, my surgeon told me I would most likely have a mamogram in 6 months and than yearly. At the time that frightened me because I read my cancer isn't detected with a mamogram until it is larger. I see the radiologist for the first time tomorrow and the oncologist on Wednesday. I found out about the Oncotype DX test on this site so I asked the nurse that the encotype DX test be preformed weeks ago. She said something to the effect that my tumor was too small for the test. What does the size have to do with it? It is used to tell me my chances of reoccurance which mentally is helpful. So, she called about a week ago and asked if I would be interested in participating in a study (my surgeon had mentioned it to me saying the radiologist may ask me about it). Before I can participate I have to have the Encotype DX test and I have a score of less than 18--not sure what it means. Funny that now it is not too small!! I am considering the study since I can quit it at any time. The study involves patients 50-70 having no radiation for ILC patients with small tumors. You are required to take the hormone blockers for 5 years. It is phase 2 of the study. I believe they already finished patients 70 and above. My mother had 1 breast removed at 73 and the other at 77. she is now 84 and cancer free. She did not take the recommended 5 years of Tomoxifen due to the side effects. On 1/21 i was diagnosed with Ocular Malignant Melanoma. A very rare tumor behind my left eye. I had brachetherapy and am cancer free. This cancer has a high rate of metastasizing so there is a molecular genetic test that was given to me as part of a study. You get a score of a 1 or a 2. Luckily I was a 1a!!! I have a very low chance of it spreading. If it had been a 2 I would have a 70% chance of it spreading ot my liver or lungs. My testing would have been more frequent and my stress level would have been very high. That is why I want the test for this cancer. If it is high I will consider different treatment. I am sorry this is so long and i wish the best for everyone on this site.

Jump to this post

Sorry to hear that you have been through a lot. Good news about your 1a result on the occular tumor tho! That was a victory!
I did not have an Oncotype dx test either. The oncologist said because my Ki 67 test number was low at 5%. From what I am reading not all hospitals do Ki 67 tests. Not sure on that tho. Maybe you can ask your Doctor what your Ki 67 test result was. I was told if it's under 14% usually no chemo and better all around.
They told me since I had a bilateral mastectomy no mammograms or Breast MRIs now. I just will have my chest wall and underarms checked every 6 months for 5 years. If they want to do a breast MRI on you once a year and you are very claustrophobic they can give you a medication to relax you. I have heard from people that does help. Maybe that's an option for you? You probably already knew that. My Mom got claustrophobic so I know how how awful that can be. I close my eyes as soon as I get on the table of the MRI machine and never open them until I am out of the machine. That helps me.
Good to hear about your Mom being a survivor at 84! Hooray!
Sending love and healing wishes to you❤️

REPLY

I think it would be helpful to have a by-line for each respondent (with permission of course) similar to the Johns Hopkins forum, which outlines type of bc, staging, treatments, etc. Since so much of this seems to be linked to age at diagnosis, might be helpful mentioning that as well.

REPLY

2019: stage IIIc ILC (Left) at age 69: surgery (modified radical mastectomy for 5 tumors, clean margins, but 10/16 nodes diseased): chemo and radiation, lots of it, no side effects). 2 years Tamoxifen then Anastrazole since 2021, Zometa for 3 years after radiation. If I had the Oncotype test, I don't remember it. I just did what I was told at that point. I have my yearly Mammogram in June and yearly MRI in December (so, some kind of screening every 6 months)...Visits with radiation oncologist, breast surgeon, breast oncology and primary care (one of these every 4 months). I also check in with a cancer hospital once a year. They all say "keep doing what you're doing" and for right now, I'll go with that. Please, please, explore all the options for not only acute care, but aftercare, which in some cases might be the most important part.

REPLY
@jlimb

Has anyone beed faced with a recurrence, after diagnosis and treatment for early stage ILC? Having recently heard that invasive lobular cancer can "be sneaky" and hard to detect, I admit to having some potential concerns about what to expect. I had no symptoms with original diagnosis. (Just found on a yearly mammogram). Thanks for sharing any insight/experience.

Jump to this post

I am also interested in recurrence. Having a mamogram only is also my biggest fear--I read this cancer is hard to detect with a mamogram until it larger. Have you been given the Oncotype DX test? I am 66yo. had a suspecious area on my right breast in July 2022. Left breast was fine. 8/23/2022 I had an ultrasound and they could see nothing so they ordered a MRI. I am highly clostrophbic and put off the MRI until 5/2023. The MRI with and without contrast showed an area calcifications on the right breast but also showed an enhancing 5 mm mass on my left breast. June 12, 2023 I had a contrast enhanced mamogram and ultrasound which showed a 6mm enhancing mass on the left breast. On 7/10 I had a MRI guided biopsy which which ultimately led to a diagnosis of Invasive Lobular carcenoma, Nottingham grade 1-2 and ER/PR 100% positive and HER ngative. I had a lumpectomy on 8/21. Two lymph nodes were negative and my tumor margins were clear. If I remember correctly, my surgeon told me I would most likely have a mamogram in 6 months and than yearly. At the time that frightened me because I read my cancer isn't detected with a mamogram until it is larger. I see the radiologist for the first time tomorrow and the oncologist on Wednesday. I found out about the Oncotype DX test on this site so I asked the nurse that the encotype DX test be preformed weeks ago. She said something to the effect that my tumor was too small for the test. What does the size have to do with it? It is used to tell me my chances of reoccurance which mentally is helpful. So, she called about a week ago and asked if I would be interested in participating in a study (my surgeon had mentioned it to me saying the radiologist may ask me about it). Before I can participate I have to have the Encotype DX test and I have a score of less than 18--not sure what it means. Funny that now it is not too small!! I am considering the study since I can quit it at any time. The study involves patients 50-70 having no radiation for ILC patients with small tumors. You are required to take the hormone blockers for 5 years. It is phase 2 of the study. I believe they already finished patients 70 and above. My mother had 1 breast removed at 73 and the other at 77. she is now 84 and cancer free. She did not take the recommended 5 years of Tomoxifen due to the side effects. On 1/21 i was diagnosed with Ocular Malignant Melanoma. A very rare tumor behind my left eye. I had brachetherapy and am cancer free. This cancer has a high rate of metastasizing so there is a molecular genetic test that was given to me as part of a study. You get a score of a 1 or a 2. Luckily I was a 1a!!! I have a very low chance of it spreading. If it had been a 2 I would have a 70% chance of it spreading ot my liver or lungs. My testing would have been more frequent and my stress level would have been very high. That is why I want the test for this cancer. If it is high I will consider different treatment. I am sorry this is so long and i wish the best for everyone on this site.

REPLY
@poesmom

Spoke to surgeon today. Since mass sort of goes half way around and biopsy showed cancer at both ends of it she said mastectomy probably be better than lumpectomy. I'm ok with that. Who needs 2 boobs anyway at my age. All I'm wondering will I require chemo too. NOT !ooking forward to that at all! Been reading and they say they've been overly aggressive using chemo over the years and now they've decided it's not always neccessary. Got my fingers crossed😶.

Jump to this post

Hi @poesmom, I am in my 70s too (70) and I also had ILC in one breast stage 1a. I had IDC stage 1a in my other breast. I had a bilateral mastectomy and at my age I chose not to go through extra surgery for implants. I wanted you to know that I did not have chemo or radiation either. I was relieved not to have it but wondered if it would have given me some extra protection. But I went to Mayo Rochester for my surgery and treatment so I figured I was at a place on the forefront of treatment options. My ILC was triple negative and even so the oncologist and tumor board agreed on the no chemo decision. I am on Tamoxifen ( I have osteoporosis so that's why Tamoxifen even tho I am years past menopause) for the IDC which was estrogen positive. In the Breast Cancer Survivorship area of Mayo I was told that eating 7-9 fruits and vegetables a day would help to prevent recurrence and also daily exercise is very important so I am exercising and eating those 7-9 fruits and vegetables every day. Our goal on this site is to be a bc Survivor and I am sending out love and Survivor wishes to you and all on this site.❤️

REPLY

Thanks. I'll probably pass on reconstriction. I'm 74 and can live with a prosthetic. Nice to know maybe no chemo.😎

REPLY

I totally agree!! I have learned how different ILC is from IDC, and few articles, blogs, etc, differentiate.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.