I am seven months postop after a TKR. I need another opinion.

Posted by roxie12 @roxie12, 2 days ago

I am still having debilitating pain, decreased mobility and swelling. I am scheduled for an ablation to decrease the pain in two weeks. This all has taken away the life that I once knew. I can’t do the things I was able to do.
Does anyone know of any joint surgeons you would recommend near Central Pennsylvania. I would be willing to go to Philadelphia or Pittsburgh or Baltimore. Thank you.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Joint Replacements Support Group.

Profile picture for dann399 @dann399

I had a very similar situation. Had initial left TKR done November 2023 by a surgeon who was the Surgical Director For Joint Replacement at a major teaching hospital. Incidently, this surgeon had performed a left TKR and bilateral hip replacements on my wife without post op complications. I expected some discomfort and swelling post op, but after 4-5 months of physical therapy and repeated examinations by the surgeon, who indicated that this was normal and that there was nothing wrong. He did however, recommend a Genicular Nerve Block, but my insurance company said the procedure was experimental and not covered. The out of pocket cost was too expensive. I returned to the surgeon and his comment was "Just live with it". Having worked in healthcare for almost 50 years, that comment was a "red flag" and I immediately sought a second opinion from a surgeon that specialized in TKR revision.
After an initial exam by the revision surgeon, he determined that the implant had not been properly balanced and that was the reason for the persistent pain and swelling. Arrangents were made for the revision for February 2025. The surgeon was going to attempt to balance the implant, but was unable to. We had discussed this scenario and if the balancing was not able to be done, he would explant the initial implant and replace it with a new one from a different manufacturer. Needless to say, that did the trick. No pain or swelling and I am 14 months post op and fully functional.
Definitely seek a second opinion with a surgeon that specializes in TKR revisions. It may take a little research, but well worth it. When a physician tells you to "live with it", seek a second opinion. I live in coastal NJ and am not familiar with revision surgeons in central Pa. Be persistent and good luck.

Jump to this post

@dann399
Thank you for taking the time to do this detailed response.
There are a lot of similarities. My surgeon is also the director of joint replacements in a very large teaching university.
He performed a revision of a hip replacement. I had in 2010 that was not working. The hip is still good 16 years later. So I completely trusted him for my knee. And now it’s “ the x-rays look, good bye-bye”
He did send me to the pain management department, and I am going to have the ablation to the nerves in the knee to alleviate some of the pain. I think it is called a genicular nerve block.
I don’t know if I am up to having another major surgery.
I also have worked in healthcare for 50 years!
Would you be willing to share the name of the surgeon that did your successful surgery?
Thank you so much!

REPLY
Profile picture for roxie12 @roxie12

@dann399
Thank you for taking the time to do this detailed response.
There are a lot of similarities. My surgeon is also the director of joint replacements in a very large teaching university.
He performed a revision of a hip replacement. I had in 2010 that was not working. The hip is still good 16 years later. So I completely trusted him for my knee. And now it’s “ the x-rays look, good bye-bye”
He did send me to the pain management department, and I am going to have the ablation to the nerves in the knee to alleviate some of the pain. I think it is called a genicular nerve block.
I don’t know if I am up to having another major surgery.
I also have worked in healthcare for 50 years!
Would you be willing to share the name of the surgeon that did your successful surgery?
Thank you so much!

Jump to this post

@roxie12
A Genicular Nerve Block is usually done in an attempt to temporarily alleviate the pain but is also usually a preliminary procedure to determine if you are a candidate for the Genicular Nerve Ablation. If there is little or no pain relief, the ablation is not the answer. The ablation is a procedure where the nerves in the affected area are "fried" (for the lack of a better term) to deaden the nerve endings for the pain receptors. As previously mentioned, I reside in coastal central NJ and the revision surgeon I used is part of the Robert Wood Johnson Barnabas Health System. He has offices in Lakewood and Toms River NJ and has over 35 years experience. He also did a fellowship at Mass General Hospital in Boston. Definitely seek out a revision specialist in your area. It may take a bit of research but getting rid of the pain and swelling and getting back to a much better quality of life is definitely worth it. Good luck!

REPLY
Profile picture for dann399 @dann399

@roxie12
A Genicular Nerve Block is usually done in an attempt to temporarily alleviate the pain but is also usually a preliminary procedure to determine if you are a candidate for the Genicular Nerve Ablation. If there is little or no pain relief, the ablation is not the answer. The ablation is a procedure where the nerves in the affected area are "fried" (for the lack of a better term) to deaden the nerve endings for the pain receptors. As previously mentioned, I reside in coastal central NJ and the revision surgeon I used is part of the Robert Wood Johnson Barnabas Health System. He has offices in Lakewood and Toms River NJ and has over 35 years experience. He also did a fellowship at Mass General Hospital in Boston. Definitely seek out a revision specialist in your area. It may take a bit of research but getting rid of the pain and swelling and getting back to a much better quality of life is definitely worth it. Good luck!

Jump to this post

@dann399
Thank you!
I did have the nerve block about six weeks ago and it did give me temporary relief. So I am scheduled for an ablation on the 16th. One step at a time I guess. We will see how this works and move forward. I am so glad you are doing better.

REPLY

I had the best surgeon from Columbia Presbyterian Hospital in NYC! If you are willing to travel as far as White Plains NY.. his office is now at their fairly new ambulatory surgical center connected with Columbia Pres Hospital. Called THE ONE in White Plains, Westchester County His name is Dr. Jeffrey Geller… fantastic. fabulous ortho. surgeon! He only does knees and hips.. and does do reconstructive surgery on both also. He did my full hip replacement 4 months ago and I have had nothing but wonderful days with no more pain and quality of life back! He is by far the best of the best. You could look up his background online. I wish you the best of luck. Definitely take some time to look up his credentials from Columbia Pres.!

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.