Fear of radiation after lumpectomy
I was seriously thinking of refusing radiation after lumpectomy because I had complete removal of tumor with wide negative margins. I was convinced that there would be no lung, rib, or heart radiation by using the prone(lying on stomach) with breast hanging down. They have been very careful with treatments & very accommodating so after 4 treatments I am feeling more secure by my decision to do this to ensure all cancer was caught.
Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Breast Cancer Support Group.
Connect

Hi, I too am awaiting OncoType test to determine treatment options. I am concerned with the standard prescribed radiation/inhibitor for 5year plan protocols.
I took HRT for over 30years, so am currently experiencing the dreaded menopause symptoms. At 73years of age, will I benefit from years of AI or will it reduce considerably my quality of life. I have a family history of Osterporosis and Leukemia.
Let me know how your journey proceeds, I’ll be watching and hoping all goes well for you!
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
5 ReactionsWow, I can’t believe how similar our stories seem. I, too was recently diagnosed w/IDC stage 1. I had surgery at Mayo and am awaiting the OncoType test. My preliminary meeting with the oncologist seemed very prescribed protocols, including radiation and hormone inhibitors. I am 73, small frame and concerned with Osteoporosis. My father, his brother, and a first cousin died of leukemia as well.
Please let me know how you fare gaining any info or insight to your current status on future treatments.
Your friend, Elliej
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
5 Reactions@anjalima thank you so much for your input and I hope you are doing well in your journey! I think that sounds like a good idea trying out an AI just to see if I have any reactions. I also tend to have strong reactions to meds (and allergic reactions). I am 61 and am post-menopausal. I was originally taking HRT meds before being diagnosed with breast cancer (due to extreme hot flashes and feeling sick from menopause symptoms). I am leaning toward trying an AI (my surgeon mentioned letrozole) and foregoing the radiation, unless I can find some more definite data showing risk/benefit. I also need to evaluate based on my Oncotype results, which I have not yet received.
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
4 ReactionsI have not seen any studies. I had a mastectomy so my situation is quite different as no breast tissue remains ( theoretically). I can say that I am one of those who has very strong reactions to medications. That said, I am taking an AROMATASE inhibitor ( Anastrozole) and in month 6 and I am not experiencing any noticeable symptoms ( possible slight hair thinning which has lessened so may be a response to the surgery/anesthesia). So my gut response, with ER positive, is to try it and see if it is in fact a problem for you. Age and menopause status may also play a factor.
I’m truly sympathetic to your concerns and one would hope for more research to address these questions and concerns on a more targeted and individualized basis.
I hope you find a peaceful path on this journey. 🌸
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
6 ReactionsI am dealing with a similar situation. I just had lumpectomy for Grade I invasive ductal carcinoma, ER/PR positive and HER-2 negative. Spot removed was only 0 .6 cm (smaller than pea size). Surgeon rec is radiation plus AI. I have suffered for my nearly my entire life with chronic fatigue, fibromyalgia, autoimmune thyroid, depression, irritable bowel syndrome, anxiety, vertigo, dizziness, swelling, severe allergies, etc. Three lymph nodes were removed and none of them tested positive. My BARC genetic test came back negative also. Surgery report says all margins are clean. I have struggled my entire life to overcome the overwhelming amount of symptoms I already have. In addition, my father died of leukemia and also my cousin on his side. My cousin on my mom's side has lupus and thyroid issues as does the entire side of mom's family. My aunt had lung cancer. With my history, I do not want to risk making my already awful quality of life even worse. So I am waiting on my Oncotype results. I too have read horrible things about AI and radiation. Radiation can bring on leukemia and lung cancer later on. I've had to cut back on work already due to my existing issues, so I can't afford to quit. I need to still work to pay bills. So far, I have not found that the benefits of radiation or AI's outweigh the risks or decreased quality of life. Unless there is some indication that you are at higher risk of recurrence. I'd like to see some studies on this topic but haven't found much out there yet. Has anyone out there found any studies on this?
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
5 ReactionsSorry tried to delete not post above. It was going to say that everyone's personal preference list is legitimate for that person. We have to live our lives, in and around and despite, health conditions and treatments and cannot even hope for perfect decisions, just those that seem the most right.
I think everyone's preference list is l
The Fungi Perfecti series with renowned mycologist Paul Stamets on Netflix was fascinating to watch the other night. The truth is that nature holds legions of answers to so many conditions we face. It's just a matter of time and money spent on looking for them. And keeping the knowledge freely available in the public domain and not owned by corporations and hedge funds like some genetics codes!
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
2 ReactionsThe actress Elizabeth Taylor refused to cover-up her tracheotomy scar for movie shoots. She called it her badge of courage and a reminder of personal strength. And a reminder to other women of theirs. And that human strength is the only example of real beauty in her eyes. I like the notion while fully endorsing anything that helps any of us move forward more comfortably.
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
3 ReactionsI should add my left breast, nodes were also radiated. Lots of radiation.....yuk.
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
2 Reactions