Choosing a spine surgeon

Posted by annie1 @annie1, Nov 15, 2025

I have a problem in that I have interviewed many surgeons and there are at least two who have very good reviews and I'm having a hard time deciding who to go with. One of the surgeons had one bad review out of all good reviews. The other one had no bad reviews at all. I had a minor surgery/decompression with one of them that was successful only for 4 months and then my symptoms came back. He's very likable guy has great reviews and would do the fusion but I am a little worried since the first time it didn't really stick. It's very hard to decide since I already have a relationship with him and I do like him. Can anyone identify with this kind of dilemma and share a way to choose which surgeon to work on me? I keep getting more recommendations also which you and makes it more complicated.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Spine Health Support Group.

Profile picture for sherrym25 @sherrym25

@annie1 my surgeon was Dr. McClendon at the Phoenix Mayo Clinic. I cannot say enough good about what he did to “fix” my back. He is amazing and all of my pre-surgery pain is gone. He is meticulous and takes such pride in helping us regain our lives and lessen the pain. He really cares.

Jump to this post

@sherrym25
Well if I went to Arizona I would have to stay out there after the surgery for a while. Do they have any in-house rehab there? Also well I have to make an appointment but I want to make sure that he can work with the osteoporosis. I might have found someone here now in New York after someone messaged me on another site but I have to look into that first. I will see you about the doc in Phoenix also.

REPLY
Profile picture for annie1 @annie1

@sherrym25
Well if I went to Arizona I would have to stay out there after the surgery for a while. Do they have any in-house rehab there? Also well I have to make an appointment but I want to make sure that he can work with the osteoporosis. I might have found someone here now in New York after someone messaged me on another site but I have to look into that first. I will see you about the doc in Phoenix also.

Jump to this post

@annie1 I flew to Arizona for my initial evaluation with Dr McClendon and then I flew there for surgery. I left the hospital 9 days later and flew home. I don’t know if they have in-house rehab but the office staff are so nice if you want to call and ask. I sent my mri, X-rays, and cat scan to them and then they called and said Dr McClendon accepted me as a patient for an evaluation. They also do telehealth sometimes so maybe you could do that to ask your initial questions about having osteoporosis.
Best, Sherry

REPLY

Ok thanks. Do you happen to have the contact number ? I obviously can look it up. I'm just exhausted between pain keep me up, interviewing surgeons and trying to do what I love a few hours a week.

REPLY
Profile picture for sherrym25 @sherrym25

@ccchang Hi Cori, yes that is correct. My surgeon was Dr. Jamal McClendon at the Phoenix Mayo Clinic.
Best, Sherry

Jump to this post

@sherrym25 Thank you!

REPLY
Profile picture for sherrym25 @sherrym25

@annie1 I flew to Arizona for my initial evaluation with Dr McClendon and then I flew there for surgery. I left the hospital 9 days later and flew home. I don’t know if they have in-house rehab but the office staff are so nice if you want to call and ask. I sent my mri, X-rays, and cat scan to them and then they called and said Dr McClendon accepted me as a patient for an evaluation. They also do telehealth sometimes so maybe you could do that to ask your initial questions about having osteoporosis.
Best, Sherry

Jump to this post

@sherrym25

I just read one review that said he was rude and pompous. ?

REPLY

I found him to be extremely kind and patient during my evaluation. As a matter of fact, his normal assistant was out sick, and the covering assistant told me she loved working for him because he took care of so many of the scheduling details. When I told him that I hoped to schedule surgery by the end of the year because my co-pay had been met for the year, he went out himself and grabbed the scheduling book and came in and sat down with me and entered everything in the computer himself.
My surgery was eight hours long and while I was in recovery, he grabbed a candy bar, because he said he was starving. and then ran 5 miles. Then he showed up in my recovery room to tell me how well everything went. Every single nurse and assistant that I dealt with at the hospital with all of my pre-testing all the way through my recovery could not say enough about good about him. They absolutely love him. They would smile and say “oh Dr. McClendon we just love him. He’s the best.” I was certainly happy to hear that since everything was already scheduled!!
I’ve had three zoom follow up appointments with him and each one. He has been kind and spends as much time as I want asking questions.

REPLY

Thank you. I guess there's always going to be one or two people who are negative about any doctor. I'm going to call today.

REPLY
Profile picture for sherrym25 @sherrym25

I found him to be extremely kind and patient during my evaluation. As a matter of fact, his normal assistant was out sick, and the covering assistant told me she loved working for him because he took care of so many of the scheduling details. When I told him that I hoped to schedule surgery by the end of the year because my co-pay had been met for the year, he went out himself and grabbed the scheduling book and came in and sat down with me and entered everything in the computer himself.
My surgery was eight hours long and while I was in recovery, he grabbed a candy bar, because he said he was starving. and then ran 5 miles. Then he showed up in my recovery room to tell me how well everything went. Every single nurse and assistant that I dealt with at the hospital with all of my pre-testing all the way through my recovery could not say enough about good about him. They absolutely love him. They would smile and say “oh Dr. McClendon we just love him. He’s the best.” I was certainly happy to hear that since everything was already scheduled!!
I’ve had three zoom follow up appointments with him and each one. He has been kind and spends as much time as I want asking questions.

Jump to this post

@sherrym25
I asked if he had any expertise with osteoporosis and they said no, so I don't think this will be the best fit. Did you say you have osteoporosis ?

REPLY
Profile picture for annie1 @annie1

@sherrym25
I asked if he had any expertise with osteoporosis and they said no, so I don't think this will be the best fit. Did you say you have osteoporosis ?

Jump to this post

@annie1 they have a team of doctors who work there so when I sent all of my imaging, he was the one that took my case. I would think they would have a good surgeon that has experience with osteoporosis.
Just a thought would be to send them your records and see if they have a doctor that would accept your case.
No, I do not have osteoporosis.

REPLY
Profile picture for annie1 @annie1

Ok thanks. Do you happen to have the contact number ? I obviously can look it up. I'm just exhausted between pain keep me up, interviewing surgeons and trying to do what I love a few hours a week.

Jump to this post

@annie1 I’m so sorry I missed this message! I would’ve sent you his number.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.