Cardio/resistance training (but not weights) for health

Posted by antz123 @antz123, Feb 14, 2023

When I was younger, I was a sharp toothed gym rat. That was in my 20's and somehow all those constantly aching muscles didn't make me ask 'why am I doing this?'
Anyhoo now at 51 I don't want to lift weights and be all sore.
But don't they say our muscles start to atrophy at around 30 years of age?
My question is - instead of doing resistance training in the form of weight training, is it beneficial to do cardio which incorporates a degree of resistance? Such as the rower? The crosstrainer? Is it enough to use the handles on the crosstrainer to really push/pull with our arms?
Or do we really need weights to help offset this muscle atrophy we will all face?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Aging Well Support Group.

I meant to add - would swimming be enough?

REPLY

I'm 71 years old. From everything I've read and been advised I think adding some kind of resistance routine is good practice. That could be weightlifting. But it could also be resistance bands. Some of the weightlifting I do is to be in the shape I want for the activities I enjoy. For instance, I enjoy and perform better in x-country skiing (classic) when I've been weightlifting during the off-season. Hiking is a good aerobic exercise and anything that involves walking at a good pace with your own body weight is considered good. Rowing is another good example. If you're referring to a rowing machine then that's a full body workout that includes aerobic and resistance. I've read that swimming isn't enough for resistance although it could be a good aerobic workout.

I used to row in a rowing club. I enjoyed rowing in 6 person or 4 person shell however I quit when I became concerned about the lack of safety practices in the club. I'm thinking of rejoining this summer as they now have sculls - a one person boat - and then I'm my own safety practice.

I've seen people bounding up and down ski hills in summer with poles. Now that's hill walking!

REPLY

@antz123
I used to swim 5 miles a day and I didn't use them but there are various things you can wear or drag to create resistance.
Jake

REPLY

Hey Jake,
If you're swimming 5 miles a day I imagine you don't need anything else!
How did you ever get time btw 😅

REPLY

It’s Important to stay in the zone of living. You must if you want to survive to stay proactive on life
I’m working on , my 90 th year and look forward to every new day
iI had a few bumps in the road but that is part of Life’s Territory 2014 treated for Prostrate cancer with radiation and cured

I’m over 25 years a diabetic #2?but icontrol diabetes by diet and exercise
I have CAD and had a quadruple by pass in 2016 and very fortunate i did not have a heat sttack and i excercise everyday getting my heart rate up to 85% twice a week i’m very functioning the other day i walked 2 miles on the barrier beach that i’m fortunate to live on with my wife of over 64 years
Last but not least i contracted Deadly Melonoma about a year ago and was treated on a clinic trial at MassGeneral hospital Boston and today i’m in remission
i telling all this not too brag but too show being proactive in your Health really works
Thanks for reading

REPLY
@omta

It’s Important to stay in the zone of living. You must if you want to survive to stay proactive on life
I’m working on , my 90 th year and look forward to every new day
iI had a few bumps in the road but that is part of Life’s Territory 2014 treated for Prostrate cancer with radiation and cured

I’m over 25 years a diabetic #2?but icontrol diabetes by diet and exercise
I have CAD and had a quadruple by pass in 2016 and very fortunate i did not have a heat sttack and i excercise everyday getting my heart rate up to 85% twice a week i’m very functioning the other day i walked 2 miles on the barrier beach that i’m fortunate to live on with my wife of over 64 years
Last but not least i contracted Deadly Melonoma about a year ago and was treated on a clinic trial at MassGeneral hospital Boston and today i’m in remission
i telling all this not too brag but too show being proactive in your Health really works
Thanks for reading

Jump to this post

Remarkable testament to both proactive intentional living, and reactive response to maladies that surface.

REPLY

My formula is something every day. Cardio, yoga, some resistance like bands or small weights on the treadmill. High heart rate, endorphins, promotes higher quality sleep. Yoga generates calming and present moment awareness. Cardio with low knee stress; swimming, XC skiing, fast walking, cycling all are easy on knees and even promote healthier knees. Even shoveling snow…

REPLY

Love the video @randywhite! I thought I would share another discussion with more helpful videos sadly not as uplifting as Randy's though...

--- Strength training: How-to video collection:
https://connect.mayoclinic.org/discussion/strength-training-how-to-video-collection/

REPLY
@randywhite

My formula is something every day. Cardio, yoga, some resistance like bands or small weights on the treadmill. High heart rate, endorphins, promotes higher quality sleep. Yoga generates calming and present moment awareness. Cardio with low knee stress; swimming, XC skiing, fast walking, cycling all are easy on knees and even promote healthier knees. Even shoveling snow…

Jump to this post

Great formula for living your life
i have found Elliptical is also good for upper and lower combo work out with less stress on the knees. Good luck

REPLY

I'm a 71 woman and I found 2 things very helpful. One, is my recumbent bike. I do 5 miles a day and it cured my knee pain and makes my heart doctor happy that I'm getting some cardio in. Second, I do a series of exercises using 5 lb. weights. This just gives me some upper body strength to do household chores and I think it improves my posture. My point is you need cardio and strength training, no matter what your age, to stay healthy...good Luck !

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.