Can anyone recommend a calcium supplement?

Posted by leeosteo @leeosteo, Jan 26, 2023

Can anyone recommend a calcium supplement? I just noticed my current supplement includes only calcium & D. From what I've read you really should have other vitamins and/or minerals in a supplement.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Osteoporosis & Bone Health Support Group.

@callalloo

There's so many formulas on the market that I think the most important thing is go with a really reputable manufacturer that has been in business for a long time and ships interstate. The interstate caveat means that Federal guidelines apply so there's an implied higher standard of protection against poor quality or fraudulent products. I take something called Bone Support, which used to be called Bone Formula, which includes what I think of as the bone support trilogy of algae-sourced calcium, vitamin D3, and vitamin K2. I put a friend on it after he suffered a broken neck and his neurosurgeon noticed the bottle on his hospital bedside table and picked it up, read the formula and thought it was a really good supplement that also might help speed up bone healing. [I didn't ask why, if this was so important, no doctor suggested it. I pick my battles :-)]

I recently added silica to my daily regime, in the form of Bio-Sil, because a lot of data that suggests silica is really important and, though I eat more vegetables than I used to, I don't know how many trace minerals vegetables absorb in the growing process nor the quality of soil the vegetables are grown in for that matter though I buy most of the stuff at a local farmers market now. I don't know if the silica is helping my bones but it sure is making my hair grow a lot faster.

I would add one caveat. I never order anything from Amazon that goes in my body. And have also stopped ordering anything that is applied topically. I have twice received products sold via Amazon that were clearly not the brand name I was used to seeing though in the brand name labeled container. I think the Netflix documentary on fraudulent products on Amazon highlights some of the risk. I do read the reviews on Amazon but, when it comes to supplements or skin care products, and many other products, for that matter, I ordered directly from the manufacturer. The distribution chain chaos makes it very easy to sell counterfeit and sometimes outright dangerous goods. Caveat emptor.

Jump to this post

Callalloo, I agree completely re your Amazon comment! I don't trust it.

REPLY
@callalloo

There's so many formulas on the market that I think the most important thing is go with a really reputable manufacturer that has been in business for a long time and ships interstate. The interstate caveat means that Federal guidelines apply so there's an implied higher standard of protection against poor quality or fraudulent products. I take something called Bone Support, which used to be called Bone Formula, which includes what I think of as the bone support trilogy of algae-sourced calcium, vitamin D3, and vitamin K2. I put a friend on it after he suffered a broken neck and his neurosurgeon noticed the bottle on his hospital bedside table and picked it up, read the formula and thought it was a really good supplement that also might help speed up bone healing. [I didn't ask why, if this was so important, no doctor suggested it. I pick my battles :-)]

I recently added silica to my daily regime, in the form of Bio-Sil, because a lot of data that suggests silica is really important and, though I eat more vegetables than I used to, I don't know how many trace minerals vegetables absorb in the growing process nor the quality of soil the vegetables are grown in for that matter though I buy most of the stuff at a local farmers market now. I don't know if the silica is helping my bones but it sure is making my hair grow a lot faster.

I would add one caveat. I never order anything from Amazon that goes in my body. And have also stopped ordering anything that is applied topically. I have twice received products sold via Amazon that were clearly not the brand name I was used to seeing though in the brand name labeled container. I think the Netflix documentary on fraudulent products on Amazon highlights some of the risk. I do read the reviews on Amazon but, when it comes to supplements or skin care products, and many other products, for that matter, I ordered directly from the manufacturer. The distribution chain chaos makes it very easy to sell counterfeit and sometimes outright dangerous goods. Caveat emptor.

Jump to this post

Could I please have the name of the Netflix documentary on fraudulent products on Amazon? I wasn't able to find it.

Thanks,
Cookie

REPLY
@cookierockwell

Could I please have the name of the Netflix documentary on fraudulent products on Amazon? I wasn't able to find it.

Thanks,
Cookie

Jump to this post

It was in one of the shows in the "Broken" series about dangerous and counterfeit products in the marketplace. There was another program that looked at how fraudulent products are sold through Amazon that wasn't on Netflix and I don't remember the show name. And multiple articles in the media on how used or damaged items get sold on Amazon as new. Amazon takes the position, possibly legally defensible, that it is not responsible for the products sold through it. But some instances of fraud or counterfeit goods are so serious that one wonders why Amazon continues to let them be sold. There is a Revlon revolving brush hair styler which had, by my account when I looked at it, over 45 reports of the thing catching fire in the Review Section. And yet Amazon continued to sell it. I purchased a skin care product, before I knew better, which clearly was not the same product I've been using for a few years when I opened it. I called the manufacturer and was told that it's a problem and that they were aware of it. They do not sell, or allow any of their products to be sold, through Amazon because they can't verify the quality. I contacted Amazon and reported the fraud and returned the item for refund. As of over a year later, the same vendor was still selling the same fraudulent product and Amazon had done nothing. Caveat emptor.

REPLY

Has anyone heard that Calcium Carbonate is not absorbed well by women over 60? I've heard that dicalcium malate, calcium citrate, calcium bisglycinate chelate, calcium ascorbate are better and more easily absorbed.

REPLY
@leeosteo

Has anyone heard that Calcium Carbonate is not absorbed well by women over 60? I've heard that dicalcium malate, calcium citrate, calcium bisglycinate chelate, calcium ascorbate are better and more easily absorbed.

Jump to this post

My nutritionist recommends calcium malate.

REPLY
@leeosteo

Has anyone heard that Calcium Carbonate is not absorbed well by women over 60? I've heard that dicalcium malate, calcium citrate, calcium bisglycinate chelate, calcium ascorbate are better and more easily absorbed.

Jump to this post

Calcium citrate can be absorbed with less stomach acid. This may be important if you are on acid reducing meds like Pepcid. Dietary fat is required to absorb vitamin D (and vitamin K2). I take both these vitamins with my calcium.

REPLY
@leeosteo

Has anyone heard that Calcium Carbonate is not absorbed well by women over 60? I've heard that dicalcium malate, calcium citrate, calcium bisglycinate chelate, calcium ascorbate are better and more easily absorbed.

Jump to this post

yes, that's true. It's not as easily absorbed as the others (maybe because much of it comes from rock!). You need to take carbonate with food to aid in absorption. The others can be taken any time of day, with or without food.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.