Aromatase Inhibitors: Did you decide to go on them or not?

Posted by nanato6 @nanato6, Oct 12, 2018

Nanaloves: I’m about to start arimidex and just feel that the contraindications , bone issues etc. are overwhelming. I’m 70 years old, dodged a bullet I feel with zero stage DCIS but the follow up is pretty much no different then if it was more aggressive. I’ve just done 33 treatments of radiation and now they advise arimidex as a preventative. I’m not sure with the beginnings of arthritis and lower back. sensitivity already that I should take it. Anyone not take it and not have a recurrence within the 5 years.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Breast Cancer Support Group.

I am 69, IDC (4 mm) and DCIS (2.5 inches) with SMX, negative lymph nodes, clear margins, negtive genetics. No Oncotype DX done because size of IDC was less than 5 mm. I am on anastrozole 1 mg for 2 months now. I have a lot of aches and joint pain (esp knees) and extreme fatigue by mid afternoon. The fatigue and joint pain are affecting my quality of life as i like to be busy but really can not go after a certain time of day. i am hesitant to switch drugs because if they all lower estrogen levels, i assume i will feel the same fatigue and muscle aches and joint pain. But i am tempted to cut the pill in half or take 1 mg every other day. I excercise regularly, take tart cherry juice etc. But the lousy feeling (fatigue, pain, aches) are discouraging to me and make me feel as though i am 'sick' when i should be focusing on being healed. What to do??

REPLY
Profile picture for briarrose @briarrose

There is so much information here, it's hard for me to process everything.
I had stage 1 and lla plus 2 areas of ductal hyperplasia all in both breasts. Had a bilateral mastectomy in May 2025. Started Anastrozole 1 mg. in June. Just had my bone density test. At age 68 all was normal, now at age 70 I have osteopenia in my left hip. Is it the AI after only 3 months or a natural occurrence?
I have headaches daily. Very annoying. B/P systolic can not get below 140 despite being on 3 B/P medications and 2 recent dose increases. Oncotype was 14, no chemo indicated, no radiation. I am also a heart patient and this drug surely is potentially dangerous with my heart condition but my cardiologist gave the go ahead for me to go on it. Just some joint aches, nothing major. Some skin itching & redness also. The headaches are my main issue plus watching my blood pressure. I thought Tamoxifen was only for pre-menopausal women. Is this an option for me? My breast oncologist said no 3 months ago. Will be seeing her next week. Lots of thoughts here, but confused as to the way to go. This is my first post-op visit with her since starting the AI. Anything I should focus on during my visit with her? Thanks so much...

Jump to this post

Tamoxifen may not be recommended for postmenopausal women for various health reasons including risks for:
-Uterine cancer, a history of PCOS, possibly the number of years of estrogen including early menarche and HRT, endometriosis, any sign of uterine hyperplasia
-Deep vein thrombosis, a history of any thrombotic events or health issues related to thrombosis
-while tamoxifen can be cardio-protective in some areas, I think there are other heart conditions may be an issue
-it’s affect on the hypothalamus-pituitary-adrenal axis, prior health concerns in this area may increase risk of problems

Research shows tamoxifen induced risk for uterine cancer and DVT is low if health history indicates the original risk (prior to tamoxifen) is low.

AIs do have a little better outcome than tamoxifen for postmenopausal women and are recommended as a first line med by most doctors, but I felt the little higher risk wasn’t enough for me to take an AI with my health history. My oncologist gave me the choice for either.

My two cents on headaches, is that estrogen modulates the quality of our vascular system and very low, or high, estrogen may be a factor in vascular headaches.
I had headaches with the higher dose of Tamoxifen. My theory is it was causing vasodilation in my brain or meninges (tamoxifen can act as an estrogen agonist, promoting action in the brain). Although I do not have daily headaches with the lower dose, I now need to use a nasal spray antihistamine (vasoconstrictor) in the spring and fall when air pressure systems change and allergic inflammation abounds. Again, my theory, is that my vascular system is no longer supple (part age, part tamoxifen messing with estrogen) and I have to counteract the effects of the med.

It’s important to have your doctor evaluate the risks of tamoxifen vs AI. They can compare health history, current risks of developing disease. And then - how does hormone treatment affect your individual health status.

It is very confusing when we try to figure out what is best for us. Some of us have diabetes, autoimmune diseases, heart disease, neuropathy, adrenal insufficiency, polycystic disease, thyroid issues . . . the list goes on. All these factor into how a hormone therapy may affect us.

REPLY

Before I was diagnosed with cancer and started Anastrozole I was switched to Amlodipine Besylate 5mg for my blood pressure and it has been low ever since even with this med. Family history of blood pressure and mine was never normal so it’s been a God sent for me

REPLY
Profile picture for npandolph @npandolph

Before I was diagnosed with cancer and started Anastrozole I was switched to Amlodipine Besylate 5mg for my blood pressure and it has been low ever since even with this med. Family history of blood pressure and mine was never normal so it’s been a God sent for me

Jump to this post

I have been on amlodipine for years, plus candesartan, a diuretic and beta blocker.
Developed hypertension in my late 40s. Cardiac stent age 58 and ischemic heart disease.
My pulse is fine. B/P in the AM is fine...as the day progresses blood pressure goes up and I develop a headache. Every day. Beyond annoying.

REPLY
Profile picture for Rubyslippers @triciaot

@wyowyld I have a similar risk level as you, although some differences in type cancer. I’m 70 and am thinking along the same lines, I want to maximize the next 10 years while I’m still *young* 🙂
My latest beliefs after reading current research is that the radiation should kill the cells it touches, but there may be wayward cells that will continue to grow. It often takes years for a cell to get to a clinically significant size, so I’m going to be extra vigilant at 5 years, and then about every three years after. The hope that it will be seen at an annual scan - but that 3 years may be when it’s grown just large enough to be viewable.

I did not take the option for AIs. I had 100% ER and 95% PR so I decided I’d try tamoxifen. For me, the AIs spelled trouble as I’d already had de Quervain’s tenosynovitis twice in my hand and plantar fasciitis in my foot mutiple times. As well as osteoporosis. I didn’t like the cut-off of estrogen in other organs that AI causes, but just like chemotherapy, if the risk is high enough the side effects might not be pleasant but its doable in order to control the cancer. The choice of taking an AI is definitely right for some of us.

Tamoxifen was a problem at 20 mg but I’m tolerating 5 mg pretty well, I think, I may even stay on beyond 5 years as I see other benefits that the estrogen-as-agonist is providing. But, because of all the scans and issues that have occurred since the cancer showed up there are some things that are now on my radar and I’d want to make sure these aren’t being made worse by tamoxifen. I regularly check new research to see if tamoxifen is driving the adrenal cysts, the mild white matter hypersensitivities in my brain, the large increase in cherry angiomas (which I don’t care how benign they say they are - it is still angiogenesis and something is pushing the growths - never a good thing).

Boy, I *talk* a lot. Sorry for the long read.

Jump to this post

Can you explain the problems you experienced at 20 mg of Tamoxifen? I'm about to start, and the Doc wants me to start at 20 and go down if problems. But I've been down that road before, and am going to be more independent with my little pill cutter if needed. AI's gave me lots of problems.
Thanks,
Patty

REPLY
Profile picture for Rubyslippers @triciaot

I’m on tamoxifen and have high blood pressure, there was no noticeable difference in BP with the tamoxifen. I had labile hypertension before this all started, they like to call it “white coat” syndrome because I’m always high in the doctor’s office. That, I believe, is from low estrogen for some of us - which tracks with the problems you had on AIs.

I started on 20mg, but am now on 5 mg. I cut the pill. I won’t take 10 mg every other day - might work okay, but when trying to lower tamoxifen (before protocols changed to allow 5 mg a day) I was taking 10 mg every day and still had headaches, and I’m afraid the fluctuations of every other day will bring headaches back.

Tamoxifen doesn’t cut well - I’ve tried 3 different pill cutters. The pharmacy refuses to cut it. I now use a single edge razor blade, and put the pill on a small pile of paper, then cut. The blade is very sharp, and the softer surface of the paper seems to give enough so the pill doesn’t crumble as much. I don’t get it precisely in half, but no worries. In two days, I get the full amount, maybe a little less one day, maybe a little more the next. The half life of tamoxifen is 7 days, so there is always a quite high residual amount in my body.

Jump to this post

Thanks, this information is very helpful!

REPLY
Profile picture for lin5 @lin5

I am 69, IDC (4 mm) and DCIS (2.5 inches) with SMX, negative lymph nodes, clear margins, negtive genetics. No Oncotype DX done because size of IDC was less than 5 mm. I am on anastrozole 1 mg for 2 months now. I have a lot of aches and joint pain (esp knees) and extreme fatigue by mid afternoon. The fatigue and joint pain are affecting my quality of life as i like to be busy but really can not go after a certain time of day. i am hesitant to switch drugs because if they all lower estrogen levels, i assume i will feel the same fatigue and muscle aches and joint pain. But i am tempted to cut the pill in half or take 1 mg every other day. I excercise regularly, take tart cherry juice etc. But the lousy feeling (fatigue, pain, aches) are discouraging to me and make me feel as though i am 'sick' when i should be focusing on being healed. What to do??

Jump to this post

Yes, by the 3rd month on Fulvestrant (another hormone blocker) the slight aches & pains in joints & muscles that had been slight turned severe & I just couldn't deal with it. So am switching to Tamoxifen, low dose, & hope that is not a side effect of it.

REPLY

Interesting! I didn't think tamoxifen was given to post menapausal woem but after your post i looked it up and it is when post menapausal women can not tolerate aromatase inhibitors (like anastrozole). if my symptoms get worse, i don't think i will be able to tolerate it. Good luck with the tamoxifen!

REPLY
Profile picture for jardinera25 @jardinera25

Can you explain the problems you experienced at 20 mg of Tamoxifen? I'm about to start, and the Doc wants me to start at 20 and go down if problems. But I've been down that road before, and am going to be more independent with my little pill cutter if needed. AI's gave me lots of problems.
Thanks,
Patty

Jump to this post

On 20 mg Tamoxifen, the first few weeks I had warm flashes and more moody. My eyebrows thought they might want to be a unibrow 🙂 Extra brow hair grew more in between my brows (not a lot) and some above my natural brow. As the body adjusts to the change of hormones, it leans toward a higher level of testosterone - ergo the unibrow. It was easily tweezed away. By 6 weeks, I seemed to settle into difficulty with thermal regulation- no hot flashes, but if I overheated, like in a hot car, or standing in Texas summer heat, my body took a longer time to cool off. My hair thinned some. I was more likely to cry at sad movies. I do have a slight vaginal discharge, a thin milky-like substance. It is caused by an pH imbalance from the tamoxifen, it does not bother me. I have not had any vaginal infections. I do not douche.

Before the cancer, I had vaginal dryness, vaginal atrophy, and osteoporosis. After taking tamoxifen, the vaginal issues were reversed, no atrophy. Tamoxifen can act as an estrogen agonist (promotes estrogen like action) in other parts of the body outside of the breasts. With taking Reclast my DEXA scores at the hips have improved to osteopenia, my spine has improved but is at -2.5.

At 3 months on tamoxifen I started having headaches 24/7. Not migraines. My regular doctor went through every possibility for headaches, found nothing, and I had a brain MRI. The radiology report said they found nothing remarkable (thank you very much!!) But that was good news. I saw the neurologist on staff at the cancer center and the conclusion was that the tamoxifen was causing the headaches. I changed to 5 mg, and the headaches have gone away.
Interestingly, I’ve noticed more head hair growing in. I have this fringe most noticeable in front of my ears, about 5 inches long. That’s about the right length for the time I switched from 20 to 5 mg - when maybe the higher testosterone dropped.
I have not had any bone or joint pain on tamoxifen. I started on tamoxifen at age 68, three years ago.

REPLY
Profile picture for briarrose @briarrose

There is so much information here, it's hard for me to process everything.
I had stage 1 and lla plus 2 areas of ductal hyperplasia all in both breasts. Had a bilateral mastectomy in May 2025. Started Anastrozole 1 mg. in June. Just had my bone density test. At age 68 all was normal, now at age 70 I have osteopenia in my left hip. Is it the AI after only 3 months or a natural occurrence?
I have headaches daily. Very annoying. B/P systolic can not get below 140 despite being on 3 B/P medications and 2 recent dose increases. Oncotype was 14, no chemo indicated, no radiation. I am also a heart patient and this drug surely is potentially dangerous with my heart condition but my cardiologist gave the go ahead for me to go on it. Just some joint aches, nothing major. Some skin itching & redness also. The headaches are my main issue plus watching my blood pressure. I thought Tamoxifen was only for pre-menopausal women. Is this an option for me? My breast oncologist said no 3 months ago. Will be seeing her next week. Lots of thoughts here, but confused as to the way to go. This is my first post-op visit with her since starting the AI. Anything I should focus on during my visit with her? Thanks so much...

Jump to this post

My oncologist encouraged tamoxifen when I made it clear no AIs. She was unhappy I would only agree to 5 mg Took it for 3 weeks. Had BP issues so my BP med was increased. I couldn’t get rid of a low level HA so I stopped it. I think about trying it again but I feel like it is poison for me. I am 70 so if I were younger maybe I would persevere. I had a recurrent IDC of L breast 22 years after mastectomy. Oncotype score was 8. MDs didn’t recommend radiation.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.