2 fractures and which drug best to start.
2 recent fragility fractures 77 years and in researching seems Tymlos or Forteo best to start. Or what about Evenity?
Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Osteoporosis & Bone Health Support Group.
All good. Tymlos is supposed to be a little better for the spine; Forteo for the hip. Some people start with Tymlos/Forteo, then move to Evenity if they still need more bone-building.
This video was made by someone who occasionally posts here. It's a nice overview of medication options presented in a way that you don't need to be a medical student to understand. 🙂
@brendammc Welcome to Mayo Clinic Connect.
What does your doctor recommend? Are you seeing your primary care physician or endocrinologist or rheumatologist for osteoporosis? I see an endocrinologist who prescribed 12 months of Evenity injections (monthly) and then a Reclast infusion. The Evenity was to build bone density and my bone density scan showed significant gains in my hip and lower back. I had no side effects other than a little soreness at the injection site. The Reclast infusion was meant to "lock in" the gains in bone density. I did not have any side effects from the Reclast infusion.
So far primary doctor who has prescribed Auro-Alendrondate. Have been referred re seeing an Osteoporosis specialist of some kind. Until then I will go ahead with the prescription and see how I react. I know guidelines say I should go to Anabolic therapy. So had wondered if either drugs were better for the spine.
I’ve done a lot of research and know that a knowledgeable specialist is important re testing etc.
Very happy to have found this wonderful community. Thanks to all.
Update to my last reply.
Can you tell me why you went on Evenity cp to an anabolic? Evenity had not been mentioned in the latest Canadian Osteo update. I’ll have to look into that more.
@brendammc An anabolic promotes muscle tissue although over time too much anabolic in the form of steroids increases the risk of osteoporosis. The objective for me was to build bone density not muscle tissue. I was and am building and maintaining muscle through weightlifting.
I had taken alendronate sodium (Fosomax) for 5 years. While I was on alendronate I did not have any fractures and was no longer in the osteoporosis range at that 5 years mark. Then, I had pelvic radiation in 2021 for a recurrence of endometrial cancer and my radiation oncologist told me that pelvic radiation can affect bone density. In early 2023 when I had a CT as a part of my routine cancer surveillance appointment a sacral fracture was discovered. So then that started the path to endocrinology. The endocrinologist told me I was already doing everything possible on my own for osteoporosis through diet and exercise. That sacral fracture meant that it was now time to consider medication along with all the other things I was doing. Because of my cancer history Prolia was not indicated (one of the warnings of Prolia is history of cancer) so Evenity was the next best choice. I followed my endocrinologist's recommendation and took the monthly Evenity injections to build bone density.
Does that answer your question "Can you tell me why you went on Evenity cp to an anabolic?"
I am not sure if the video above discusses the different classes of medication used in osteoporosis but to summarize, there are basically three:
1. Bisphosphonates which slow or suppress bone metabolism. This includes both bone breakdown and bone building. If you have already fractured, taking a bisphosphonate may help prevent additional fractures but it's clear that your bones are already fragile. Bisphosphonates include alendronate (Fosamax), zolendronate (Reclast), risendronate (Actonel), and ibandronate (Boniva). These can be taken orally or intravenously.
2. Parathyroid hormone replacement drugs which encourage bone metabolism, including both bone breakdown and bone building. This class of medication may help you replace the fragile, degraded bone that you have and provide additional protection against fractures. There are two currently in use: teriparatide (Forteo) and abaloparatide (Tymlos). Both require daily injections over a two-year period.
3. Monoclonal antibodies which also work on bone metabolism. These also impact bone breakdown and building. The two that are used are denosumab (Prolia) and romosozumab (Evenity). These are injections that are given every 6 months (Prolia) or every month (Evenity).
The last two are considered anabolic in nature because they encourage the production of new bone.
With two fractures, you would be considered as having severe osteoporosis and that makes you a candidate for an anabolic medication (#2 or #3).
Taking a bisphosphonate first may reduce the effectiveness of an anabolic medication taken later. This is why the expert consensus recommends using an anabolic medication first.
I was on Fosamax for over five years and had a fracture just after the five-year mark. I've been on a series of anabolic medications (Tymlos, then Forteo, and now Evenity) for just over a year. It's unknown at this point how effective this will be for me since my bone metabolism was suppressed by the Fosamax for so long. I will find out next year after my Evenity treatments are finished.
A specialist can guide you best in which anabolic is best. Evenity does carry a risk for people with cardiac issues while the PTH replacement drugs have side effects that can be untenable.
Thank you for the info.
I agree that i need more than bisphosphonates because I have had severe osteoporosis diagnosis since menopause (25 years ago). I chose to go with nutrition and exercise and LIV as long as I could. So now after the fractures I’ll do the meds. Just want to take the right one and that’s where I’d like a specialist involved. (I’ll try the pill while waiting)
Thanks for your info.
That's a nice breakdown, oopsiedaisy. One small tweak: denosomab (Prolia) is classed as anti-resorptive, since it boosts BMD by preserving existing bone and allowing secondary mineralization, rather than truly building new bone.
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3549483/#:~:text=Almost%20all%20pharmacological%20agents%20for,increases%20(11%E2%80%9313).
Thank you for the clarification. Denosumab is not anabolic; I thought it was. Good to know.