Anyone had Proton Beam Therapy for Meningioma?

Posted by deblee @deblee, May 10, 2020

Has anyone received Proton Therapy for their meningioma? If so, was it successful in reducing the size without surgery? Thank you.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Brain Tumor Support Group.

@xsk8er

I had it four years ago on my tumor which rests on my optic nerve. I had 28 treatments and all I can say is it was non evasive and so far my tumor has not changed and that's the best I can hope for. It is unoperable and it's really my only hope. I had MRI's every 6 months until this year. Now going forward once a year unless there is some change. It has definitely helped me to return to a normal life, will it last for the rest of my life I have no idea. Just grateful to have the chance to move forward with my life for whatever time is possible.

Jump to this post

Thank you for your post. Mayo also recommended 28 Proton treatments on my cavernous sinus meningioma also. Did you have any cognitive deficits? Pituitary problems? I’m checking with MD Anderson to see if they recommend the same. But I feel confident that Mayo’s program is great. Where did you go for your Proton treatments?

REPLY
@bevpac

Thank you for your post. Mayo also recommended 28 Proton treatments on my cavernous sinus meningioma also. Did you have any cognitive deficits? Pituitary problems? I’m checking with MD Anderson to see if they recommend the same. But I feel confident that Mayo’s program is great. Where did you go for your Proton treatments?

Jump to this post

As an update- I’m having treatment #8 today of Proton Radiation at Mayo in Rochester MN. The treatments are going well and no significant side effects as of yet. There are two Meningiomas they are treating & one just watching. They believe mine to be grade 1.
I find this site encouraging - and I appreciate all comments- esp Pat22. Best to all as we travel and maneuver our same and yet different roads.

REPLY
@colom22

I'm currently having proton bean radiation for my meningioma tumor grade 2. After a second opinion and my own research, I decided to go with this option. Can't tell about results as I just have done 3 sessions/30 total and all is going great. I'm a health care provider so have access to the Pubmed library through my work. The more educated you are about this, the better you can make decisions. To address your question, proton beam does not "eradicate" the tumor. The purpose of its to put the tumor in remission for some years, hopefully several. This radiation stops the tumor from growing but it doesn't eliminate it. By disrupting the growth, hopefully patients will enjoy some years with quality of life but still being followed periodically depending on each person's protocol. If is very localized, so the risk of damaging surrounding tissue is likely less than that of conventional radiation, however, more research is being done to see if there is significant difference between proton beam and conventional radiation. What my doctors explained to me, is very in line with what I have read in some studies. Every case and tumor are different, so no one treatment fits all. Treatments are personalized for each patient depending on their condition, grade of tumor, location, age of the patient, general health condition, and availability of this equipment. I found many useful comments in this support group, so I'm absolutely committed to reciprocate as I navigate my own experience. Best of luck in your journey!

Jump to this post

This is to Pat 22. I would love to know how you are as you are now finished with your treatments.

REPLY
@bevpac

As an update- I’m having treatment #8 today of Proton Radiation at Mayo in Rochester MN. The treatments are going well and no significant side effects as of yet. There are two Meningiomas they are treating & one just watching. They believe mine to be grade 1.
I find this site encouraging - and I appreciate all comments- esp Pat22. Best to all as we travel and maneuver our same and yet different roads.

Jump to this post

I have been told that proton treatment will stop the tumor from growing and does not remove it. My surgeon has told me that mine Meningioma has to come out. I am scheduled for 2-14-24. Can anyone enlighten me? Thank you.

REPLY
@jimmye

I have been told that proton treatment will stop the tumor from growing and does not remove it. My surgeon has told me that mine Meningioma has to come out. I am scheduled for 2-14-24. Can anyone enlighten me? Thank you.

Jump to this post

I think if it’s possible, surgery is the better option. Mine was in an area non-operable and therefore only thing to try was traditional radiation or Proton radiation. Best of luck & prayers to you!

REPLY
@bevpac

This is to Pat 22. I would love to know how you are as you are now finished with your treatments.

Jump to this post

I finished my treatments 2 months ago. I had 30 sessions ( keep in mind everyone dosage per treatment is different depending on area). Mine is sphenoid wing meningioma grade 2. I did really well. Some side effects I'm having: left ear plugged, pulsatile intermittent tinnitus ( noises in ear), and some pain on the radiation side. All normal as the brain recovers. I can work as before. I needed to saty home 2 weeks after I was done at Mayo because I did get some fatigue. I have cognitive fatigue (but not delay, which is different). I'll have my first follow up with MRI in February, so 3 months after completion of treatments. Overall, really grateful. Mayo is a great place to be for this treatment. I pray for the tumor to be in remission and no regrowth.

REPLY
@jimmye

I have been told that proton treatment will stop the tumor from growing and does not remove it. My surgeon has told me that mine Meningioma has to come out. I am scheduled for 2-14-24. Can anyone enlighten me? Thank you.

Jump to this post

Proton Beam disrupts the DNA activity, so the goal of this radiation is to put the tumor in remission. It does not remove it and it does not shrink it is what I understand. I have read that for most meningiomas the first line of treatment is surgery followed by radiation, but that also depends on the location of the tumor. I had surgery twice and then radiation. Hope you do well with whatever option is the best for you.

REPLY
@colom22

I finished my treatments 2 months ago. I had 30 sessions ( keep in mind everyone dosage per treatment is different depending on area). Mine is sphenoid wing meningioma grade 2. I did really well. Some side effects I'm having: left ear plugged, pulsatile intermittent tinnitus ( noises in ear), and some pain on the radiation side. All normal as the brain recovers. I can work as before. I needed to saty home 2 weeks after I was done at Mayo because I did get some fatigue. I have cognitive fatigue (but not delay, which is different). I'll have my first follow up with MRI in February, so 3 months after completion of treatments. Overall, really grateful. Mayo is a great place to be for this treatment. I pray for the tumor to be in remission and no regrowth.

Jump to this post

Thank you for your reply. I also hope & pray there is no growth or regrowth of your tumor. I also hope your side effects will eventually all resolve as well!! Sounds very good that you feel you’re back to work as before. Like you said we have different tumors in different places but overall encouraging. Thank you for responding to my questions. Best to you as you continue to recover!

REPLY

I had it. It worked good shrunk and zapped what was left of the tumor from my surgery.

REPLY

Has anyone had experience with carbon ion therapy for tumors? No centers in the US as yet, but one being built at Mayo in Jacksonville, FL to open next year, according to news reports. Japan, Germany, Austria, Italy, France and a few other global locations offer this treatment. It is ostensibly cutting edge therapy for tumors.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.