Has anyone improved bone density without meds?

Posted by naomid @naomid, Mar 21, 2023

I have a very problematic dental history and will continue to need additional root canals and implants. I also have Sjogren's Syndrome and want to avoid any drugs that cause rheumatic symptoms. Other issues in my health history make all of the meds risky for me. That said, I work out almost daily, lift weights, maintain a healthy diet, take all the recommended supplements, and get most of my calcium nutritionally. My endocrinologist wants me to take an infusion/injectable drug. I dread the side-effects, yet I'm afraid of fracturing, which hasn't happened over the many years I have had osteoporosis. That said, my numbers are getting worse (-3.2 spine, -3.1 hip). I need to do something more than I've been doing, and am at a loss. I need hope and solutions I can be at peace with. Thanks for any comments or suggestions!

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Osteoporosis & Bone Health Support Group.

@rola

@windyshores, I'm still struggling to find a local Dr that will do more than hand me a sheet of paper with meds, telling me to read up & come back in a year. I did change my lifestyle, yet I don't think I'll ever be able to do enough. I have CLL and I'd like to know if that complicates the issue. This site has given me so much help in understanding this disease! I've recently (3yrs now) moved from NJ to FL so my tried & true lifelong Drs are gone.

I have an appt with an orthopedic tmrw to pick his brain. My rheumatologist appt is in Jan24. I'm pretty much on a journey to find the right Dr. that will do the testing as Dr McCormick recommends. You all have made me stronger, I won't settle for putting something in my body that is recommended by an insurance comp rather than backed by studies/trials. So... sooner or later I'll need to make a decision🥰. Until then I'm learning all I can😉. Ty for asking.

Jump to this post

I improved my bone density street being on Algaecal plus for 2 years. Went from -3.2 to -2.7 in the spine.
Because it's so expensive, I've switched to Bone Restore W/K2 from Life Extension. Will be getting another scan in 1/24. Will update then

REPLY

Yes I have with Vitamin Suppliments.

REPLY
@dulu

I improved my bone density street being on Algaecal plus for 2 years. Went from -3.2 to -2.7 in the spine.
Because it's so expensive, I've switched to Bone Restore W/K2 from Life Extension. Will be getting another scan in 1/24. Will update then

Jump to this post

@dulu I'm not as fearful as I was in the beginning with taking the meds if need be. What I'd like to know, if possible, the underlying cause and if that can be dealt with first. If not, I need to plug the leak, I want to live without being so fearful of everyday activities & a fracture.

From what I understand, be sure to mention you've been taking Algaecal plus to whoever is taking/reading your DEXA. Not sure if you will get an accurate reading😔. There have been many convos in here abt this product. I wish you nothing but the best, take care.

https://americanbonehealth.org/medications-bone-health/why-strontium-is-not-advised-for-bone-health/
REPLY

Hello I am 55yrs and I have been taking Prolia my doctor says that is the best even with the new medication out there.It took me almost 6 months to decide to take Prolia it scared me I understand you want dental work done i f you can try and get that dental work done before taking any osteoporosis medication it will put you at a risk of that osteoporosis of the jaw there is a name for it but forgot what it is called. You are at a higher risk if you have fusion on getting that then the othere meds and thete is no cure of the one you can get in your jaw I decided to get off of Prolia because I thought I wanted some dental work done witch I never did I am 55 and I was of Prolia for 5 months being off it put me at a higher risk of fractures because the bone density reverses itself and a month ago I had L2 L3 L4 L5 Lumbar compression fracture so be aware that you at a higher risk if you get off of it.I am getting back on it.Be carefu

REPLY
@artscaping

Welcome to Connect @naomid. I enjoyed your introduction. This forum is all about sharing and you have a great start. Knowledge is power. Connect will help you become a powerful patient who can advocate for themselves based upon knowledge gained from other members and from their own experience.

I understand your dislike of drugs, injections, and other types of medications that don't sit well with your medical history. I too dislike taking medications of any kind. I prefer being active and busy.

This is your first post so I will make my response brief. To fight off the effects of osteoporosis, at some point we have to face reality. My mother actually never recovered from a fractured hip, created when she opened the door to her apartment to welcome my visit. She never walked again.

I didn't pay attention to reality until I was 75+ years old and realized that I was approaching the time to wise up about bone health. My journey has been difficult with a couple of near disasters. Here is what I learned. Some of us cannot handle injections whether they are once a month or twice a year. They place too much medication in our bodies and we cannot handle it. So..to cut to the chase I had reactions to monthly and semi-annually injections. What I chose to do was begin with a product called Tymlos which is injected daily and builds healthy bone. After two years, my span scores had improved and I was ready to protect the new bone as well as the existing bone.

Then I did succumb to the every six-month injections for bone protection. That was quite the disaster. A sensitive endocrinologist at Mayo Clinic listened, applied his medical knowledge, and changed my medication to a weekly Monday morning tablet which does not overload my body and has no side effects.

So....stay true to yourself and be part of what I call a "shared decision" process in which you work together with your medical professional to meet your special needs. This support group will be very helpful. I am hoping that @windyshores can respond to your greeting. She has encountered fractures, found the appropriate medication, and will be moving on to the protection arena very soon.

May you be free of suffering and the causes of suffering.
Chris

Jump to this post

Can you tell us what was the medication that was a weekly tablet?

REPLY
@windyshores

Insurance companies are an obstacle for physicians. They need to advocate as well. In my experience, most PCP's don't even know that it is better to start with a bone builder. The protocol is dictated by insurance and PCP's don't seem to realize it. SO much info on this optimal sequencing in studies.

Jump to this post

Agree but I also think that most doctors, including specialists, who claim to treat osteoporosis don’t really do anything except read the radiologist’s summary on a patient’s DEXA, meaning the doctors don’t even bother to look at the full DEXA report, and based on T-scores alone push meds. They aren’t treating anything and they don’t bother to understand the disease or the patient’s particular needs.

I wish the government and my insurance would let me order my own labs and meds. Note, I prefer not to take meds so meds would only be ordered, by me, when absolutely necessary.

REPLY
@fearfracture

Agree but I also think that most doctors, including specialists, who claim to treat osteoporosis don’t really do anything except read the radiologist’s summary on a patient’s DEXA, meaning the doctors don’t even bother to look at the full DEXA report, and based on T-scores alone push meds. They aren’t treating anything and they don’t bother to understand the disease or the patient’s particular needs.

I wish the government and my insurance would let me order my own labs and meds. Note, I prefer not to take meds so meds would only be ordered, by me, when absolutely necessary.

Jump to this post

@fearfracture All the doctors I have seen want the actual images from the DEXA, not the report.

That said, I wish I could prescribe and treat myself.

I would prefer not to take meds too but with several spinal fractures I really have no choice.

REPLY
@artscaping

Welcome to Connect @naomid. I enjoyed your introduction. This forum is all about sharing and you have a great start. Knowledge is power. Connect will help you become a powerful patient who can advocate for themselves based upon knowledge gained from other members and from their own experience.

I understand your dislike of drugs, injections, and other types of medications that don't sit well with your medical history. I too dislike taking medications of any kind. I prefer being active and busy.

This is your first post so I will make my response brief. To fight off the effects of osteoporosis, at some point we have to face reality. My mother actually never recovered from a fractured hip, created when she opened the door to her apartment to welcome my visit. She never walked again.

I didn't pay attention to reality until I was 75+ years old and realized that I was approaching the time to wise up about bone health. My journey has been difficult with a couple of near disasters. Here is what I learned. Some of us cannot handle injections whether they are once a month or twice a year. They place too much medication in our bodies and we cannot handle it. So..to cut to the chase I had reactions to monthly and semi-annually injections. What I chose to do was begin with a product called Tymlos which is injected daily and builds healthy bone. After two years, my span scores had improved and I was ready to protect the new bone as well as the existing bone.

Then I did succumb to the every six-month injections for bone protection. That was quite the disaster. A sensitive endocrinologist at Mayo Clinic listened, applied his medical knowledge, and changed my medication to a weekly Monday morning tablet which does not overload my body and has no side effects.

So....stay true to yourself and be part of what I call a "shared decision" process in which you work together with your medical professional to meet your special needs. This support group will be very helpful. I am hoping that @windyshores can respond to your greeting. She has encountered fractures, found the appropriate medication, and will be moving on to the protection arena very soon.

May you be free of suffering and the causes of suffering.
Chris

Jump to this post

Hi Chris Trout, Thanks so much for your openness about alternatives and the realities of pharmaceuticals. You refer to "a sensitive endocrinologis at Mayo Clinic" who gave you a "medication ... weeklyMonday morning tablet" that did not "overload...and has no side effects." Can I ask, what is that medication and, I wonder, if it is possible for me to consult with this doctor f? I am troubled by the recommendation of my endocrinologist to Evenity, have postponed it twice now. I have a number of issues that may conflict with this medicine.

I have also noted the Black Box Warning that goes with it, as well as a refusal on the part of the British organization NICE to endorse Evenity.

Right now I am trying to increase my calcium intake to 1200 units a day, and to use Vitamin K as well.

REPLY
@lashu

Hi Chris Trout, Thanks so much for your openness about alternatives and the realities of pharmaceuticals. You refer to "a sensitive endocrinologis at Mayo Clinic" who gave you a "medication ... weeklyMonday morning tablet" that did not "overload...and has no side effects." Can I ask, what is that medication and, I wonder, if it is possible for me to consult with this doctor f? I am troubled by the recommendation of my endocrinologist to Evenity, have postponed it twice now. I have a number of issues that may conflict with this medicine.

I have also noted the Black Box Warning that goes with it, as well as a refusal on the part of the British organization NICE to endorse Evenity.

Right now I am trying to increase my calcium intake to 1200 units a day, and to use Vitamin K as well.

Jump to this post

@lashu as you may know, @artscaping is referring to the medication journey she and I share. We did Tymlos to build bone and then she did/ I am about to do a bisphosphonate to "lock in" our gains.

The pill that @artscaping mentions is, therefore, a follow-up not the primary initial medication.

Reclast is a bisphosphonate that is infused. (@artscaping did you do Reclast or Prolia?). I am going to have a test dose that is 20% of the usual amount to see how I handle it. My docs are nervous because of some other health issues. If I cannot handle it I will do what @artscaping did: switch to alendronate (Fosamax) or other bisphosphonate pill. (Chris did you do alendronate?) I have GERD so that may be hard.

Our endocrinologists know that it is better to start with a bone builder and then "lock in" gains with bisphosphonates. But insurance likes it the other way around. Unfortunately, as my docs have said, and studies have shown, the bone builders are more effective if taken first!

REPLY
@naomid

Thank you so much, @teb, for all these specifics. I wish I could take HRT. To me that would be the perfect solution, but had breast cancer almost 25 years ago, and from what I understand it is still contraindicated for me. I'm going to dive into the research a little more to see if anything's changed. Your work-out routine is really wonderful. I know I need to up the amount of weights i'm using. I guess it has to be a full-out effort, leaving no stone unturned.

Jump to this post

I found one very safe food that has been proven with randomized, controlled clinical studies to build bone and reduce bone loss in post menopausal women: 50 grams of dried plums (prunes) per day. That’s about 4-5 per day. You can find the studies at National Institutes of Health by just googling prune therapy + pubmed (short for pubmed). If my memory serves me right the studies compared it to fosamax or HRT and said it had comparable benefit. If you can’t find the research let me know and I’ll check my files for the link. If you decide to add prunes, I suggest you start slowly 1/day for a week or so then add another, etc. That way your gastro system has time to adjust. I take my “dose” of prunes in the am with food and I find that works best for me.

You may also want to check out a prescription food called FosteumPlus. The main ingredient is genistein, a type of soy. My sister’s gynecologist recommended it for osteoporosis and I have been on it now for about a year and a half. It too has proven clinical results in randomized controlled studies. Not sure about whether it would work with your breast cancer history though.

One more idea that I don’t know much about as I am just learning about it now. If you decide you must go on an osteoporosis medication for your condition, check into Evista (raloxifene). According to Mayo website on breast health they recommend that drug for women who have osteoporosis and need/want to reduce breast cancer after some precancerous conditions. When I looked it up it seemed to have fewer incidences of jaw necrosis than the other meds. Good luck!

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.