Naturopaths role in treatment of advanced pancreatic cancer care

Posted by masha123 @masha123, Jul 8, 2023

Good afternoon. Had anyone has an experience with the naturopathic oncologist in treatment of advanced stage metastised pancreatic cancer?
1. As a replacement for conventional medicine (I am not planning on doing that, but my girlfriend went with it (not for the pancreatic cancer, but breast cancer, and is trying to get me into their program).

What exactly their treatment of cancer consists of - my understanding is it is IV-dripping into your system extracts of some poisonous plants/materials which are supposed to shrink/kill the tumor?

2. As a concurrent treatment with chemo?

3. As a nutrition and immune system support during chemo? This is the one I am planning to do, but if anyone had a good experience with the first two options, I would be happy to know. I just got diagnosed and did not even start chemo yet, will have my first appt. with oncologist Monday.
Thank you!

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Pancreatic Cancer Support Group.

My husband is getting supplemental support from our Naturopath while he is being treated with Folfironox. We get high dose IV Vitamin C and vitamins / supplements to address his bodies nutritional deficiences.

I don't know what a truly alternative treatment would look like, but I imagine there would be a heavy focus on detox, supplements, nutrition and exercise.

REPLY
@beths77

My husband is getting supplemental support from our Naturopath while he is being treated with Folfironox. We get high dose IV Vitamin C and vitamins / supplements to address his bodies nutritional deficiences.

I don't know what a truly alternative treatment would look like, but I imagine there would be a heavy focus on detox, supplements, nutrition and exercise.

Jump to this post

Thank you! Is he getting it via IV or in capsules (Vitamin C, that is?)

REPLY

He is getting High Dose IV Vitamin C. NOT capsules. High Dose IV Vitamin C creates an oxidative environment in cancer cells and they can't handle the oxygen getting into their cells and it causes cancer cell apoptosis (death) to the cancer cells without negatively impacting normal cells which love oxygen. High Dose oral supplements do not do the same thing - they act as anti-oxidants and this is not good if you already have cancer. You should go to PubMed and do some research on High Dose IV Vitamin C. You will see alot of good information on it.

REPLY

I would recommend that you read the book "How to Starve Cancer" written by Jane McClelland who is now an over 20 year cancer survivor. It is a lot of excellent information in it and can give you additional tools in your tool kit to add to chemotherapy.

REPLY
@beths77

I would recommend that you read the book "How to Starve Cancer" written by Jane McClelland who is now an over 20 year cancer survivor. It is a lot of excellent information in it and can give you additional tools in your tool kit to add to chemotherapy.

Jump to this post

Thank you! I will.

REPLY

I get very confused on this entire issue based on my regular scanning of research reports and books when it comes to diet and cancer. I'm reading "The Metabolic Approach to Cancer" now (given to me as a gift from a cancer survivor [not pancreatic]), one of many nutrition/healing books I've come across.

First, there are research reports that seem to indicate certain vitamins/supplements can interfere with the efficacy of certain chemo products. So, "whatever" your beliefs or philosophy your team "needs to know" what your are eating, your supplements and your honest activity level. Don't obfuscate!

Second, (as an example) in one research project, engineered PDAC mice were starved of glucose (think Keto Diet) and circulating cancers cells pretty much all died (yay!) -- but so did some of the mice that developed a fatal, unrecoverable muscle disease that required steroids to live. Then, there was a recent report that seems to show that diabetic pancreatic cancer patients have statistically better outcomes and respond better to chemo treatments. Since I don't have access to the actual papers (just the summaries, commentaries, etc.) the "specific" tumor types (think KRAS G12?, BRAC1), patient age, stage, location, co-comorbidities, etc. aren't indicated and I don't have access to the underlying data collection specs, I don't know what to think of this conflicting information.

This is just a teeny-tiny drop of all the research done in the last year. There are countless microbiome and bacteria studies being published, like comparing mouth or poop bacteria of PDAC patients to the general public and finding different bacteria for the PDAC crowd. This is a growing field of research, especially at universities around the world.

Researchers are looking at "everything" these days to figure out why some people survive and others do not. With the new customized targeted therapies being developed, they are frantically searching to learn why some respond to immunotherapy and others fail. I recently came across an interesting graphic that showed the amount of money, research grants, etc. that was being poured into pancreatic cancer and KRAS research over the last seven years and it has been nothing less than amazing. We are finally on the map! The last thing I'd like to mention here is that there is a ton of research and research dollars going into nutrition and supplement investigation (yes, Chinese medicine, too. Check out how much of the research is being contributed from Asia -- a lot!).

So, what am I doing? Ha, ha. Eating my veggies as always, getting a ton of exercise, sunlight and attempting to stay positive while I comb through the "cure" books and scientific research. A friend of mine just passed from PDAC. Younger, an amazing athlete (think "walking muscle"), who ate the healthiest foods, had the most positive outlook on life, but had no symptoms until it spread to so many organs they weren't sure where to start. She had the best neoadjuvant chemo, but her cancer did not respond. Why? Would Turkey Tail mushrooms have made a difference? Despite my anger and grief at her passing, I take solace knowing that right now, there are a few thousand people huddled in labs around the world trying to save us and those who will walk our path in the future. So now, I'll finish my oatmeal loaded with bananas to begin my day and follow this thread of ideas, hoping I started today with a beneficial meal and pray I'm not struck with paralysis as to what prepare for the next meal.

Chin up everyone -- there are thousands out there working for us!

REPLY
@patti303

I get very confused on this entire issue based on my regular scanning of research reports and books when it comes to diet and cancer. I'm reading "The Metabolic Approach to Cancer" now (given to me as a gift from a cancer survivor [not pancreatic]), one of many nutrition/healing books I've come across.

First, there are research reports that seem to indicate certain vitamins/supplements can interfere with the efficacy of certain chemo products. So, "whatever" your beliefs or philosophy your team "needs to know" what your are eating, your supplements and your honest activity level. Don't obfuscate!

Second, (as an example) in one research project, engineered PDAC mice were starved of glucose (think Keto Diet) and circulating cancers cells pretty much all died (yay!) -- but so did some of the mice that developed a fatal, unrecoverable muscle disease that required steroids to live. Then, there was a recent report that seems to show that diabetic pancreatic cancer patients have statistically better outcomes and respond better to chemo treatments. Since I don't have access to the actual papers (just the summaries, commentaries, etc.) the "specific" tumor types (think KRAS G12?, BRAC1), patient age, stage, location, co-comorbidities, etc. aren't indicated and I don't have access to the underlying data collection specs, I don't know what to think of this conflicting information.

This is just a teeny-tiny drop of all the research done in the last year. There are countless microbiome and bacteria studies being published, like comparing mouth or poop bacteria of PDAC patients to the general public and finding different bacteria for the PDAC crowd. This is a growing field of research, especially at universities around the world.

Researchers are looking at "everything" these days to figure out why some people survive and others do not. With the new customized targeted therapies being developed, they are frantically searching to learn why some respond to immunotherapy and others fail. I recently came across an interesting graphic that showed the amount of money, research grants, etc. that was being poured into pancreatic cancer and KRAS research over the last seven years and it has been nothing less than amazing. We are finally on the map! The last thing I'd like to mention here is that there is a ton of research and research dollars going into nutrition and supplement investigation (yes, Chinese medicine, too. Check out how much of the research is being contributed from Asia -- a lot!).

So, what am I doing? Ha, ha. Eating my veggies as always, getting a ton of exercise, sunlight and attempting to stay positive while I comb through the "cure" books and scientific research. A friend of mine just passed from PDAC. Younger, an amazing athlete (think "walking muscle"), who ate the healthiest foods, had the most positive outlook on life, but had no symptoms until it spread to so many organs they weren't sure where to start. She had the best neoadjuvant chemo, but her cancer did not respond. Why? Would Turkey Tail mushrooms have made a difference? Despite my anger and grief at her passing, I take solace knowing that right now, there are a few thousand people huddled in labs around the world trying to save us and those who will walk our path in the future. So now, I'll finish my oatmeal loaded with bananas to begin my day and follow this thread of ideas, hoping I started today with a beneficial meal and pray I'm not struck with paralysis as to what prepare for the next meal.

Chin up everyone -- there are thousands out there working for us!

Jump to this post

This is so sad about your friend,,, Did she take Turkey Tail Mushrooms, by the way, during her chemo?
It is confusing, I agree.

REPLY
@patti303

I get very confused on this entire issue based on my regular scanning of research reports and books when it comes to diet and cancer. I'm reading "The Metabolic Approach to Cancer" now (given to me as a gift from a cancer survivor [not pancreatic]), one of many nutrition/healing books I've come across.

First, there are research reports that seem to indicate certain vitamins/supplements can interfere with the efficacy of certain chemo products. So, "whatever" your beliefs or philosophy your team "needs to know" what your are eating, your supplements and your honest activity level. Don't obfuscate!

Second, (as an example) in one research project, engineered PDAC mice were starved of glucose (think Keto Diet) and circulating cancers cells pretty much all died (yay!) -- but so did some of the mice that developed a fatal, unrecoverable muscle disease that required steroids to live. Then, there was a recent report that seems to show that diabetic pancreatic cancer patients have statistically better outcomes and respond better to chemo treatments. Since I don't have access to the actual papers (just the summaries, commentaries, etc.) the "specific" tumor types (think KRAS G12?, BRAC1), patient age, stage, location, co-comorbidities, etc. aren't indicated and I don't have access to the underlying data collection specs, I don't know what to think of this conflicting information.

This is just a teeny-tiny drop of all the research done in the last year. There are countless microbiome and bacteria studies being published, like comparing mouth or poop bacteria of PDAC patients to the general public and finding different bacteria for the PDAC crowd. This is a growing field of research, especially at universities around the world.

Researchers are looking at "everything" these days to figure out why some people survive and others do not. With the new customized targeted therapies being developed, they are frantically searching to learn why some respond to immunotherapy and others fail. I recently came across an interesting graphic that showed the amount of money, research grants, etc. that was being poured into pancreatic cancer and KRAS research over the last seven years and it has been nothing less than amazing. We are finally on the map! The last thing I'd like to mention here is that there is a ton of research and research dollars going into nutrition and supplement investigation (yes, Chinese medicine, too. Check out how much of the research is being contributed from Asia -- a lot!).

So, what am I doing? Ha, ha. Eating my veggies as always, getting a ton of exercise, sunlight and attempting to stay positive while I comb through the "cure" books and scientific research. A friend of mine just passed from PDAC. Younger, an amazing athlete (think "walking muscle"), who ate the healthiest foods, had the most positive outlook on life, but had no symptoms until it spread to so many organs they weren't sure where to start. She had the best neoadjuvant chemo, but her cancer did not respond. Why? Would Turkey Tail mushrooms have made a difference? Despite my anger and grief at her passing, I take solace knowing that right now, there are a few thousand people huddled in labs around the world trying to save us and those who will walk our path in the future. So now, I'll finish my oatmeal loaded with bananas to begin my day and follow this thread of ideas, hoping I started today with a beneficial meal and pray I'm not struck with paralysis as to what prepare for the next meal.

Chin up everyone -- there are thousands out there working for us!

Jump to this post

Thank you so much, Patti....

REPLY
@masha123

This is so sad about your friend,,, Did she take Turkey Tail Mushrooms, by the way, during her chemo?
It is confusing, I agree.

Jump to this post

I just mentioned Turkey Tail mushrooms because....well, when the doctor first spotted my tumor and was quite sure it was cancerous, I had many calls from friends offering support that often came with lots of advice. Maybe some who are reading this had similar experiences? Anyway, I had people who called and said, nope, it's not cancer. They find stupid stuff in corpses all the time. Don't bother with any more tests. Yep, that really happened. Then, I had numerous calls offering info on cancer cures. The most popular one was Turkey Tail mushrooms that they swore cured this woman's cancer. They read all about it on the internet -- even on YouTube! Others, advised me to take lots of Turmeric and I'll be cured. Since my chemo treatment, even had a Keto fan lambast me for my stupidity in causing my own cancer because I haven't lived my life on a Keto Diet; proclaimed that no one on the Keto Diet ever got cancer.

BTW, there are likely beneficial aspects to most of the "cures". Turkey Tail mushrooms have been touted for medicinal ingredients and there is now a new chemo drug incorporating derivatives from Turmeric they think might be more effective battling glioblastoma. Realistically, if eating a particular mushroom or eliminating four or five foods from a diet enabled a person to live a long and healthy cancer-free life, I "think" we would have a found a very simple solution to a very complex issue by now. Anyway, sure hope we make some progress against this disease. I'm not ruling anything out and very interested to hear about what others are doing. Personally, I approach the entire process cautiously and optimistically -- all while trying to keep down my stress level. Have gotten tons of advice to "just relax" too!

REPLY
@patti303

I just mentioned Turkey Tail mushrooms because....well, when the doctor first spotted my tumor and was quite sure it was cancerous, I had many calls from friends offering support that often came with lots of advice. Maybe some who are reading this had similar experiences? Anyway, I had people who called and said, nope, it's not cancer. They find stupid stuff in corpses all the time. Don't bother with any more tests. Yep, that really happened. Then, I had numerous calls offering info on cancer cures. The most popular one was Turkey Tail mushrooms that they swore cured this woman's cancer. They read all about it on the internet -- even on YouTube! Others, advised me to take lots of Turmeric and I'll be cured. Since my chemo treatment, even had a Keto fan lambast me for my stupidity in causing my own cancer because I haven't lived my life on a Keto Diet; proclaimed that no one on the Keto Diet ever got cancer.

BTW, there are likely beneficial aspects to most of the "cures". Turkey Tail mushrooms have been touted for medicinal ingredients and there is now a new chemo drug incorporating derivatives from Turmeric they think might be more effective battling glioblastoma. Realistically, if eating a particular mushroom or eliminating four or five foods from a diet enabled a person to live a long and healthy cancer-free life, I "think" we would have a found a very simple solution to a very complex issue by now. Anyway, sure hope we make some progress against this disease. I'm not ruling anything out and very interested to hear about what others are doing. Personally, I approach the entire process cautiously and optimistically -- all while trying to keep down my stress level. Have gotten tons of advice to "just relax" too!

Jump to this post

You know, I simply cannot process it in my brain that somebody normal can say that "this is not cancer" or "just relax", not being a doctor and not having results of biopsy in front of him. This is kind of ...not irresponsible, since they are not responsible for your life, but slightly insensitive and condescending.

Did you take any supplements of that sort when you were going through chemo?

Fans of Keto Diet should leave the claims "no one on Keto ever had cancer" for themselves. Indeed if it were that simple, there would be no cancer patients around. But it is not that simple.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.