Cardio/resistance training (but not weights) for health

Posted by antz123 @antz123, Feb 14, 2023

When I was younger, I was a sharp toothed gym rat. That was in my 20's and somehow all those constantly aching muscles didn't make me ask 'why am I doing this?'
Anyhoo now at 51 I don't want to lift weights and be all sore.
But don't they say our muscles start to atrophy at around 30 years of age?
My question is - instead of doing resistance training in the form of weight training, is it beneficial to do cardio which incorporates a degree of resistance? Such as the rower? The crosstrainer? Is it enough to use the handles on the crosstrainer to really push/pull with our arms?
Or do we really need weights to help offset this muscle atrophy we will all face?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Aging Well Support Group.

Hello
I am currently belong to gym that has a program called: Fit Body Forever. It is designed for people over 50 and is split between cardio and strength. The strength training they do is oriented to keep/strengthen the muscles you need for daily life. Legs, core and arms. About 50% is weights/bands. I can feel the difference and my balance is better. I am 72, the oldest one in the class.
There was a recent article about the importance of strength in longevity
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wellness/2023/01/29/strength-training-all-ages

I cant comment on what is enough

REPLY

I started an all inclusive fitness program (online) last year that offers exercise sets you can adapt to your current fitness/age ability. Exercise sets are trainer led. The program also offers yoga, mindfulness exercises and health driven nutrition, recipes, cookbook etc.. Weights are gradually added once you reach a certain level of fitness. The trainer insists you rest and use Epsom salts baths and restorative/ gradual stretching yoga the day or two following exercise to reduce muscle soreness and promote comfort. It has been life changing for me and I love it! I have never felt so good, I was 66 when I started and never exercised most of my life! My strength and flexibility has improved considerably!

REPLY
@naturegirl5

I'm 71 years old. From everything I've read and been advised I think adding some kind of resistance routine is good practice. That could be weightlifting. But it could also be resistance bands. Some of the weightlifting I do is to be in the shape I want for the activities I enjoy. For instance, I enjoy and perform better in x-country skiing (classic) when I've been weightlifting during the off-season. Hiking is a good aerobic exercise and anything that involves walking at a good pace with your own body weight is considered good. Rowing is another good example. If you're referring to a rowing machine then that's a full body workout that includes aerobic and resistance. I've read that swimming isn't enough for resistance although it could be a good aerobic workout.

I used to row in a rowing club. I enjoyed rowing in 6 person or 4 person shell however I quit when I became concerned about the lack of safety practices in the club. I'm thinking of rejoining this summer as they now have sculls - a one person boat - and then I'm my own safety practice.

I've seen people bounding up and down ski hills in summer with poles. Now that's hill walking!

Jump to this post

Hey good on ya Helen. 71 years young!
You are right about the rowing. I use a machine in the gym and it is certainly one of the most challenging cardio pieces there.
I recently went swimming, after years of not swimming. I found that my cardio and (light weight training) from the gym really helped, as it can be a challenge to get the breathing right in the pool, if out of practice.
But generally I believe one thing helps the other. I think the term crosstraining means doing a selection of different exercises. Such as hillwalking or X country skiing.
On that note, for years I have been threatening to fly to mainland Europe and try it! I have a holiday booked in April - bootcamp Marbella- in Spain. But now you mention X country skiing I think I'll try that for a winter holiday too!

In Ireland we are fortunate insofar as we are not obliged to take out health insurance. Although most people agree it is a good idea, especially as we get older. My philosophy is that out best health insurance policy is to get and stay in shape, make it a lifestyle, when we are in shape, it really is not a big deal to maintain that fitness. A little bit often, they say.
And a lot less Guinness, I've decided 🙂

REPLY
@kjschneider6

I started an all inclusive fitness program (online) last year that offers exercise sets you can adapt to your current fitness/age ability. Exercise sets are trainer led. The program also offers yoga, mindfulness exercises and health driven nutrition, recipes, cookbook etc.. Weights are gradually added once you reach a certain level of fitness. The trainer insists you rest and use Epsom salts baths and restorative/ gradual stretching yoga the day or two following exercise to reduce muscle soreness and promote comfort. It has been life changing for me and I love it! I have never felt so good, I was 66 when I started and never exercised most of my life! My strength and flexibility has improved considerably!

Jump to this post

You sold me! What's the name of the online fitness program?

REPLY

Rfhearld- Per your request here is the fitness program that has positively improved my fitness and well being! The additional positive to this program, there are many, is 50% of your membership fees go to worthy charity programs. Enjoy!🙌🏻
https://www.mypeakchallenge.com/pages/join

REPLY

I appreciate all the input and it inspires me to keep being active. I will soon be 85 and am a female with no surgical history, but I know that to be healthy, sleep well and continue to be active that I must exercise. I do some form of cardio or strength training 5 days a week using DVDs. I read that folks over 50 should exercise at least 150 minutes a week.

REPLY
@bets38

I appreciate all the input and it inspires me to keep being active. I will soon be 85 and am a female with no surgical history, but I know that to be healthy, sleep well and continue to be active that I must exercise. I do some form of cardio or strength training 5 days a week using DVDs. I read that folks over 50 should exercise at least 150 minutes a week.

Jump to this post

Yes keep going! I started doing some resistance training with weights as I believe it will stand to me over the years. Plus as you mention, exercise helps with sleep. Between the metcon class on sat morning and a few cardio/weights/hillwalking sessions during the week, it feels great to choose an active, healthy lifestyle with less alcohol consumption and better diet.

REPLY
@antz123

Yes keep going! I started doing some resistance training with weights as I believe it will stand to me over the years. Plus as you mention, exercise helps with sleep. Between the metcon class on sat morning and a few cardio/weights/hillwalking sessions during the week, it feels great to choose an active, healthy lifestyle with less alcohol consumption and better diet.

Jump to this post

Thanks for the encouragement! I use a variety of DVDs and exercise in my basement as I live a few miles out of town and prefer this. I'm not working for muscle, but toning and keeping up my strength for my age. I do this in the morning, at least 30 minutes and have just started to walk (in the basement) in the evenings after dinner for about 30 minutes. Now with warmer weather coming, I will try to walk outdoors to get the fresh air and exercise together. If I lose a few pounds, it won't hurt my feelings a bit. HaHa

REPLY

I'm 74 and have been active and fit most of my life. Moderate exercise of the right kind has helped me weather the inevitable changes that come with aging. I strive for a balance between aerobics, balance, flexibility, strength, core and specific work on problem areas like my torn rotator cuff. Four foundations or anchors have helped me sustain reasonably good health; they are priorities for me: exercise, quality and quantity sleep; good nutrition and stress management. I've worked on each of these for a long time, but am always learning something new. Allow me to mention an online site that has been very helpful for my fitness during the pandemic: Eldergym Academy, which is gearing to older exercisers. http://www.eldergymacademy.com

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.