← Return to Looking for evidence that feeding tubes prevent aspiration pneumonia

Discussion
Comment receiving replies
@jenniferhunter

@ltecato The short answer is no. A feeding tube does not prevent aspiration. I speak from experience with my father who had a feeding tube because of a head injury from a skull fracture in his 60's. That was temporary and after he had relearned how to swallow, the tube was removed. When he was in his 80's, the difficulty swallowing returned and he was choking on his food. We had swallowing studies done and the doctors ordered nothing by mouth which did frustrate him a lot. I helped him make the decision to have the feeding tube that they suggested. With the various ER visits with an elderly man, I had a chance to ask the doctors, and they told me what happens is that the stomach shrinks because of not having solid food. With the feeding tube, we had to do a slow drip with an IV bag connection. If my dad started coughing, he could cough up his stomach contents into his mouth and start choking on it. There were times this happened, and I opened the tube connection into his stomach to drain it to stop him from coughing it up. That is why the feeding needed to be a slow drip. The doctors told me that is eventually what happens causing aspiration. They were right and this is how he died by coughing up stomach contents and then aspirating it into his lungs causing a heart attack. He was an end stage heart patient with heart failure.

Jump to this post


Replies to "@ltecato The short answer is no. A feeding tube does not prevent aspiration. I speak from..."

@ltecato I wanted to add a bit more here. While my dad did die of aspiration, he also had several instances of aspiration because of not using the feeding tube. Before the feeding tube at the end of his life, he was thickening liquids with Thickit and we were using a blender to make his meal easy to swallow. He also worked with a speech pathologist on swallowing and exercises to strengthen that process. When my mom gave him a cookie that he was not supposed to have, he choked on it, and then developed aspiration pneumonia requiring medical attention. that probably would have happened more without the feeding tube, so it did help. His swallowing problems stemmed from a brain injury years earlier, so tat may not be an equal comparison as to what will happen in a different case. It is worth doing the therapy work to try to strengthen swallowing.