Hip revision due to metal on metal ions.

Posted by sailaway @sailaway, Dec 10, 2019

My husband has two great Metal on Metal (MoM) hips from 2008 and 2010. He and surgeon chose these types of replacements as being appropriate for an athletic person, and he has been able to downhill ski with them. Now he has rising levels of chromium and cobalt, released from friction between the metal surfaces, and many aches and pains throughout body. There is an "impressive" pocket of inflammatory fluid around one hip joint (where metal ions are being released) and we are being advised to have a revision where one of the metal parts is replaced with ceramic. This is pending another blood test and a MARS MRI in 5 months. Appreciate hearing from any others with this experience. Thank you.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Joint Replacements Support Group.

I had a left hip done in 2017 and was successful. A year later I had the right one done and have had issues since. No recall for me though. Did find out they tore a muscle which can't be repaired and the surgeon tat did it refuses to admit it.

REPLY
@ltsally

He has been putting off the revision surgery for about 2 years now as the surgeon can't be sure he will get back on the tennis court after the surgery. He has his blood tested and he gets an X-ray every 6 months to see if he can continue to wait.

Jump to this post

Hi Itsally, my husband had his 2nd MARS MRI which showed that the large area of inflammation, with debris in it, around his right hip was unchanged from 8 months ago. Dr. says this will not resolve on its own and will perform "minimally invasive" surgery to replace the metal ball with ceramic. The hip itself only gives pain when doing heavy lifting; both parts seem to be solidly implanted and have never given him trouble. Husband is concerned about generalized joint pain and aches throughout rest of his body- usually level 4-5 daily. Wondering if this is related to ion levels: cobalt is trending upward at 21.1 and chromium in 12-14 range. Dr says it is up to husband how long he is willing to put up with this situation. And now there is Covid and continuing to age- 79 in March. Good luck with making our decisions!

REPLY
@sailaway

Hi Itsally, my husband had his 2nd MARS MRI which showed that the large area of inflammation, with debris in it, around his right hip was unchanged from 8 months ago. Dr. says this will not resolve on its own and will perform "minimally invasive" surgery to replace the metal ball with ceramic. The hip itself only gives pain when doing heavy lifting; both parts seem to be solidly implanted and have never given him trouble. Husband is concerned about generalized joint pain and aches throughout rest of his body- usually level 4-5 daily. Wondering if this is related to ion levels: cobalt is trending upward at 21.1 and chromium in 12-14 range. Dr says it is up to husband how long he is willing to put up with this situation. And now there is Covid and continuing to age- 79 in March. Good luck with making our decisions!

Jump to this post

@sailaway - The constant joint pain and aches got better for me when the metal ion levels began to go down after surgery, and were gone within less than a year. The inflammation & "debris field" improved within the first 3 months.
Sue

REPLY

I am a 75 year old woman semi active and have a Stryker hip implanted 10 years ago. It was one of the ones tha It was recalled. I have had two mars mri and have my blood levels checked every 6 months. I am really nervous about having revision done and am looking for a doctor nearby who has preformed these revisions. I am in moderate pain that starts from hip and goes down beyond my knees. I am not sure what the critical levels of chromium and cobalt are. Can you help me with these questions?

REPLY
@pammiep1963

I am a 75 year old woman semi active and have a Stryker hip implanted 10 years ago. It was one of the ones tha It was recalled. I have had two mars mri and have my blood levels checked every 6 months. I am really nervous about having revision done and am looking for a doctor nearby who has preformed these revisions. I am in moderate pain that starts from hip and goes down beyond my knees. I am not sure what the critical levels of chromium and cobalt are. Can you help me with these questions?

Jump to this post

First, no chromium or cobalt levels are completely safe, and the longer you wait, the more soft tissue damage there is. I waited too long and ended up with heart and thyroid issues from the metals.
Second, revisions are about the same as the original surgery or easier if they just replace cup liner and femoral ball, and not the stem and cup.
Third, the phone is your friend. Call ortho practices and ask specifically whether they do Stryker revisions. When you first see the doc ask them how many and complication rate.
Finally, get your metal ion numbers and keep track of them, keep checking after surgery to make sure they go down. .
Good luck, and ask me anytime.
Sue

REPLY

Mine is not that good an outcome. i had hip replacement with a metal on metal Zimmer product. The first year was good. pain started in the 2cd year. my doctor said i had bursitis...and i needed to stretch more. i did so fairly diligently. The pain continued. Shots didn't help long.
when i questioned my doctor, somehow he didn't remember i had a metal on metal hip. after more pain and time...about 9 years worth... i found proof i had a metal on metal hip. he tested for metals, which were through the roof...a revision was scheduled...it was way worse than anticipated with bone damage to the hip socket that had to be removed. he didn't replace the metal head but did replace the metal socket with a plastic coated metal socket...i can walk...up hills is painful...i can play golf...painful afterwards. i fight muscle spasms most every night...which is sleep depriving and very frustrating.
i am stretching nightly that has helped. i'm in the process of requesting more PT to make sure i am doing the best stretches and strengthening exercises possible.
my best advice is do not wait for a hip revision!

REPLY

My wife had a TKR replaced due to titanium allergy, not fun. An alloy joint installed made by Smith & Nephew is probably as successful as possible under the circumstances but it isn't perfect. She also had a hip replaced three yrs ago, no alloy joint was available then and it has been problem free. I feel what you've gone thru.

REPLY

I can’t believe your husband has only had the implants that long, & already has had blood tests. I had a mom in 2004, one day Nov. last year, I woke up & couldn’t walk. I don’t remember much but my husband told me I was in bed for a week. When I came to, we went to orthopedic surgeon, the 1st thing they did (& the only time I ever had 1) was do a blood test. Had plenty of cobalt & something else, it escapes me rite now. So I had a rev., with ceramic is between the ball & head of socket(?) . I haven’t been rite since
😟

REPLY
@sueinmn

First, no chromium or cobalt levels are completely safe, and the longer you wait, the more soft tissue damage there is. I waited too long and ended up with heart and thyroid issues from the metals.
Second, revisions are about the same as the original surgery or easier if they just replace cup liner and femoral ball, and not the stem and cup.
Third, the phone is your friend. Call ortho practices and ask specifically whether they do Stryker revisions. When you first see the doc ask them how many and complication rate.
Finally, get your metal ion numbers and keep track of them, keep checking after surgery to make sure they go down. .
Good luck, and ask me anytime.
Sue

Jump to this post

I have to say…I went back for my 1st follow-up post rev….6 months later. I had found in my release papers (from rev surgery) orders for another blood test (for metal). I didn’t know I had them, when I showed the dr. @ follow-up appt, he said I didn’t need them!!

REPLY

Now I believe that SO many issues I had / have, especially with my gut are due directly to ions…who knows how long I had them or what damage was done…permanent? I guess I’ll never know

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.