Should I have the Spinal Cord Stimulator? Looking for reviews on this

Posted by denman55 @denman55, Jun 5, 2023

I have had chronic lower back pain due to lumbar spinal stenosis for over 10-years. I have had multiple therapies and procedures done - including RFA, Epidural steroid injections, a MILD procedure, acupuncture, OT/PT and Chiropractics, as well as an Interspinous spacer and nothing has helped my pain. After all of that, the physician I saw in March's only recommendation was for me to have the Spinal cord stimulator, but I am actually afraid of this and have read that there have been numerous injuries as a result of this implant, and after reviewing the booklet and watching the video I initially felt that it was just to restrictive in terms of how you could move your body. If you have had this procedure please let me know your results. Many thanks.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Spine Health Support Group.

Profile picture for painsurvivor @painsurvivor

@joebeth Hi! I know it's hard to quantify pain. I wonder if you can venture to say how much pain diminution you get with the scs for your back.
I'm presently undergoing an scs trial, in my 4th day. I see my dr tomorrow. I feel some decrease in pain but not enough to change my ability to function except it hurts a bit less when I walk. I thought there would be a more dramatic lessening. Do you remember what the results were for you when you first got it? Thanks for any information!!

Jump to this post

@painsurvivor
My wife had one. Same story as most works for a while then fades. Hers came out with her next fusion surgery.
My theory is your body compensates for the stimulation and adjusts itself against it as it sees it as foreign piece messing with its nerves.
If you are not getting a ton of relief from trial I would not bother as the trial is usually set at a high level to get it to work for people in a short period of time. Most people get max relief during trial.

There is a ton of profit in these things so the motivation is to get you to 50% relief (I think thats the number for insurance to pay for it) Bing, Bang, Boom another 50K sale out the door.

REPLY
Profile picture for painsurvivor @painsurvivor

@joebeth Hi! I know it's hard to quantify pain. I wonder if you can venture to say how much pain diminution you get with the scs for your back.
I'm presently undergoing an scs trial, in my 4th day. I see my dr tomorrow. I feel some decrease in pain but not enough to change my ability to function except it hurts a bit less when I walk. I thought there would be a more dramatic lessening. Do you remember what the results were for you when you first got it? Thanks for any information!!

Jump to this post

@painsurvivor I definitely have benefited from both. With the level of pain I was in a 50% drop was exciting. I know the reps here are very responsive to me if I need anything. Only you can decide what is best for you. But the drop I mentioned help me.

REPLY
Profile picture for evanc @evanc

My pain doc sent me home with info on a new stimulator. “Nevro HFX”. It’s supposed to work on “personalized, complex nerve pain”.

I’d never heard of it and have been reading up on it but have no experience with it other than that.

Jump to this post

@evanc both of my implants are nevro HFX. They have helped me and the reps are wonderful here in north fla

REPLY

@denman55 I had a SCS implanted back in 2018 after a very successful trial. It dropped my pain down to a level that gave me my life back. Unfortunately, it died in 2021 after the paddle lead developed several burned out electrodes. Would I do it again? Yes. In fact I am scheduled for a trial of the new Medtronic SCS. I'll try to keep everyone updated.

REPLY
Profile picture for heisenberg34 @heisenberg34

@denman55 I had a SCS implanted back in 2018 after a very successful trial. It dropped my pain down to a level that gave me my life back. Unfortunately, it died in 2021 after the paddle lead developed several burned out electrodes. Would I do it again? Yes. In fact I am scheduled for a trial of the new Medtronic SCS. I'll try to keep everyone updated.

Jump to this post

@heisenberg34 Please us know how you turn out. I am in the exact same situation as you. I have the Nevro currently and my pain management physician is suggesting switching it all out for the Medtronic SCS. Mine was implanted in 2017 and has several burned out electrodes.

REPLY

Hi. I just finished a trial with a Boston Scientific spinal cord stimulator (scs), which my surgeon felt was best for me from his research. It gave me some decrease in pain, which I'd score as about 20%. Unfortunately, it didn't relieve it enough to change my ability to function. Yes, I felt a little less pain when walking, but not enough to commit to an scs. The pain reduction was from the stimulator combined with Percoset (which I had already been taking). Yesterday (the leads removed on Monday), I saw a rheumatologist, which I'll write about separately. Thank you all for your kind help, relating your experiences and opinions. I appreciate it greatly!!

REPLY

I had a Boston Scientific spinal stimulator implanted for about 4 years. The battery pack was placed in my rear with the stimulator placed on the spinal cord. The battery pack pinched me from inside every time I sat down. The battery pack was placed then above the hip. Initially the stimulator worked great. After about 3 years, I started getting zapped from the battery pack and the stimulator, sometimes at the same time. The zapping increased to the point I had to get the stimulator removed. While waiting for appointments to get this resolved, I started getting a sensation of a hot burning knife being stabbed repeatedly into my back at the site of the stimulator. My doctor was more than happy to remove the stimulator. After removal of the stimulator, I continue to get the burning stabbing feeling in my thorasic spine anytime I vacuum, mop, garden, clean, grocery shopping, etc. I’ve seen my pain management specialist. I had an epidural steroid injection at the stimulator location. I got about 50% relief for a week, then back to the stabbing pain. I have a referral to see a neurologist (takes forever to get an appointment- over a month) to see if the nerve root was damaged or if the scar tissue is pushing on the spinal cord. If these issues are found, additional risky surgery would be the next step.

In my opinion from my own experience, the risks of a spinal stimulator outweigh the benefits. No one tells you that every time you need a MRI, the stimulator has to be put in MRI mode and you can only be in the MRI for a limited time due to the stimulator getting hot. It can be stressful if your controllers aren’t completely charged. Also, the spine surgeon who did my cervical and lower lumbar fusion doesn’t believe they work, so he doesn’t offer the spinal stimulator to his patients. I trust my spinal surgeon’s opinion. This doctor kept me from being a quadriplegic and then a paraplegic.

My recommendation is not to get the stimulator. The Boston Scientific reps could never figure out why I kept getting zapped.

REPLY
Profile picture for luamiller @luamiller

@heisenberg34 Please us know how you turn out. I am in the exact same situation as you. I have the Nevro currently and my pain management physician is suggesting switching it all out for the Medtronic SCS. Mine was implanted in 2017 and has several burned out electrodes.

Jump to this post

@luamiller I was supposed to have my trial on the 25th. Because they could not schedule a CT scan a week or so out from the procedure, it has been rescheduled for December 16th. Bummer. Plus I am waiting to see if Medicare will approve it. So much red tape! I hope you can find something to give you some decent relief.

REPLY

Thank you! I have had decent relief with the Nevro. I always questioned whether I was or not until the battery would go dead and then I would find out how much relief it was giving me! My physician wants me to switch to the Medtronic device because it is MRI compatible. Crossing my fingers, waiting for the referral now and insurance...

REPLY
Profile picture for joebeth @joebeth

@evanc both of my implants are nevro HFX. They have helped me and the reps are wonderful here in north fla

Jump to this post

@joebeth

What was your diagnosis?

My cervical fusion has worn out the disc above and below and two surgeons are recommending a longer fusion, involving three more vertebrae.

I’ve also been diagnosed with Si joint problems requiring fusion on both sides.

Would the Nevro HFX help?

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.