Met with dietician today: Some answers to questions the group asked

Posted by TurtBean @turtbean, Jul 29 6:10pm

I met today with a dietitian who specializes in cancer survivorship nutrition. Here’s how that went:

We met for about an hour, just a telephone visit. I had a couple of specific questions, and was happy to hear him provide immediate, detailed responses tailored to prostate cancer - you know how sometimes you’ll talk to an “expert” and you’ll be able to work out pretty quickly that they’re a generalist giving you a general answer with a lot of extra words to pad their response out so they sound like they know more than they do? That wasn’t this guy, he gave very precise answers to my questions. That made me feel confident in talking with him.

Onto the food:

I asked about eggs, because there are a lot of controversy around eggs and prostate cancer.

The dietician talked about the pros and cons about eggs in relation to prostate cancer, then stated the position of the nutritional department at the cancer center is that eggs don’t need to be severely limited, just moderated - no more than two a day. Since I rarely have more than four eggs a week these days, I’m good, but now I feel ok in increasing that a little, maybe up to six eggs a week.

I also asked if there were any foods that were recommended to never consume. I said, “What’s the cigarette of the food world?”

“Two things,” he replied, “Alcohol and deli meats/cured meats. I’m all about moderation in all things, but for those two things, if you don’t have to consume them, then don’t.”

That means hotdogs, bologna, bacon, sausage, salami, even so-called healthy sliced meats, like chicken or turkey from the deli, are an avoid-at-all-costs if possible.

I was surprised by the chicken and turkey stuff, but he said those are processed in such a way to prepare them for deli sales, that it makes them unsuitable for a cancer survivorship diet. That also includes nitrate/nitrite-free stuff and chicken sausages.

Thankfully, he did ok making some of that stuff at home, including roast beef, which would still count against the recommended red meat amounts, but would be better for me than buying the pre-sliced stuff.

That one hurts a little because deli meats and cured meats made up a very large part of my diet. I had some form of that every day, and many times multiple times a day, and have done so since I was old enough to eat solid food (maybe that’s why I developed cancer 😉). I ate obscene amounts of lunchmeats, bacon, and sausages.

So that was the worst of it. With the alcohol, he just said if I don’t feel like I have to drink, then don’t, but recognized that there’s a social component to it that’s hard to fight. I mentioned that I didn’t drink a lot beforehand, and I’m not drinking at all right now, and he simply recommended not starting back again if I could help it.

He then went through the usual things of this much red meat, that much protein, eat a plant-forward diet, eat the rainbow, blah blah blah, but did specifically point out that tomatoes appear to be very effective in curtailing prostate cancer recurrence, so eat tomatoes, fresh, canned, or cooked, as much as possible.

Then he had me tell him typical meals that we eat, three of each of breakfast, lunch, and supper, as well as snacks and desserts, and he graded me very highly on my choices overall, with little tweaks here and there. He said I was eating better than 95% of the people he meets with, and he commended me on my general food/meal knowledge…we even swapped a couple of recipe ideas.

Last thing he left me with was that he was sending me a bunch of dietary info through my patient portal, and that I had access to nutrition services through the care center for the rest of my “very long life,” and “…one more thing: holidays and vacations, throw all that out the window and eat and drink what you want. Life’s too short not to have a little fun.”

All in all, a good meeting, I thought.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Prostate Cancer Support Group.

I agree the research on eggs and prostate cancer is conflicting, so - like many in this discussion thread - I have chosen a middle ground: moderation, limiting myself to about six eggs per month. A 2011 Harvard study by Richman et al. found an 81% higher relative risk of lethal prostate cancer among men eating 2.5 or more eggs weekly compared with those eating fewer than half an egg weekly. A 2015 meta-analysis similarly suggested an association with fatal prostate cancer but found no increased risk of prostate cancer overall. On the other hand, a 2013 meta-analysis found no significant association with either prostate cancer incidence or mortality. More importantly for those of us already diagnosed, a recent systematic review of post-diagnosis dietary studies found inconsistent evidence, with possible risks concentrated at higher egg consumption levels. None of these observational findings proves that eggs cause cancer progression. Given the uncertainty, I chose moderation rather than complete avoidance.

REPLY

I didn't see it mentioned in any posts, so I looked up plant based meat alternatives (please be gentle) and the specific ones I like, Beyond Meat and Morning Star Farms use no added nitrates. I haven't had bacon in decades, or the balogna sandwiches of my youth. My wife had to have her gallbladder removed 32 years ago from injuries in a car accident and can't digest certain protiens very well so I stopped red meats along with her. Solidarity, you know.
Got a couple packs of Morning Star Grillers Prime in the freezer right now. They are pretty good with a nice thick slice of tomato.
We have some backyard chickens, but use the eggs mostly for recipes. I do like to bake.
Also highly recommend homemade bruschetta and toasted Italian bread. Unsolicited recipe: I just dice tomatoes, onions, motzarella cheese and add fresh basil, crushed garlic and olive oil. Mix together in a bowl, salt and pepper to taste. Serve with the bread.

REPLY
Profile picture for timothy57 @timothy57

I didn't see it mentioned in any posts, so I looked up plant based meat alternatives (please be gentle) and the specific ones I like, Beyond Meat and Morning Star Farms use no added nitrates. I haven't had bacon in decades, or the balogna sandwiches of my youth. My wife had to have her gallbladder removed 32 years ago from injuries in a car accident and can't digest certain protiens very well so I stopped red meats along with her. Solidarity, you know.
Got a couple packs of Morning Star Grillers Prime in the freezer right now. They are pretty good with a nice thick slice of tomato.
We have some backyard chickens, but use the eggs mostly for recipes. I do like to bake.
Also highly recommend homemade bruschetta and toasted Italian bread. Unsolicited recipe: I just dice tomatoes, onions, motzarella cheese and add fresh basil, crushed garlic and olive oil. Mix together in a bowl, salt and pepper to taste. Serve with the bread.

Jump to this post

@timothy57

Thanks for sharing ideas and info about meatless meat 👍😎 and yes, bruschetta is very tasty even when just thinly sliced tomato is added on slightly toasted fresh sourdough bread with very thin zip of olive oil (or olive oil infused with garlic or basil) or if in hurry even just a thin zip of vegan mayo with sliced tomato topping - ohhhh... mmmm-mmm ... OK - have to make one now 😋 lol

REPLY
Profile picture for heavyphil @heavyphil

@im62at2024 Sorry to hear about your brother…your family genetics has a lot more to do with your issues than a few tomatoes can solve.
My friend had melanoma and prostate cancer; his wife had adeno CA of the colon age 35.
Their son died from glioblastoma age 35…a very nasty gene sequence is in there somewhere.
Best wishes for your brother’s recovery and yours as well.
Phil

Jump to this post

@heavyphil
Nasty genetics or environmental issues (remember Love Canal in Niagra Falls).

REPLY
Profile picture for soli @soli

After my prostate cancer surgery last year, I made further improvements to my already fairly healthy diet, hoping to at least slow down the progression of any cancer that might recur, even if diet alone may not prevent recurrence.

Based on my research, I compiled the attached list of “Top 20 Anti-Cancer Food Groups,” which largely aligns with what others have shared in this discussion thread.

I did not include a separate list of foods to avoid or minimize, such as the usual suspects: processed meats, red meat, added sugars, and refined grains.

In my case, I had already been avoiding fast food, processed meats, and other unhealthy foods for decades. So, the biggest changes involved making my diet more plant-forward, increasing my consumption of fatty fish and cruciferous vegetables, and adding green tea to my daily routine.

My latest blood work shows substantial improvements in my A1C and other health markers, reinforcing my belief that this type of diet offers benefits beyond any potential impact on cancer, particularly for cardiovascular health, blood sugar control, and weight management.

Jump to this post

@soli Thanks for the list!

REPLY
Profile picture for superjk47 @superjk47

@soli Thanks for the list!

Jump to this post

@superjk47

You are very welcome!

REPLY

Deli meats as in turkey. Those are the sick birds but still alive. They process into deli meats tv dinners and so on . I’m sure chicken is the same but not sure . I come up with this because I live beside a turkey farm. What they produce has a lot to do with the farmer and his cleanliness in his farm, I’ve seen both.The first people very clean the people that bought that farm disgusting dead animals laying around all the time. Birds are treated with antibiotics most of the time and usually die from cellulitis. I have a hard time understanding the health benefits turkey to beef,of course it depends how they are raised. I have raised grass fed beef before and had good marbling and tender meat. When I say grass fed I do mean 99%. Grass fed beef has CLA in the fat same as dairy from grass fed milk cows.

REPLY
Profile picture for wideurt @wideurt

Deli meats as in turkey. Those are the sick birds but still alive. They process into deli meats tv dinners and so on . I’m sure chicken is the same but not sure . I come up with this because I live beside a turkey farm. What they produce has a lot to do with the farmer and his cleanliness in his farm, I’ve seen both.The first people very clean the people that bought that farm disgusting dead animals laying around all the time. Birds are treated with antibiotics most of the time and usually die from cellulitis. I have a hard time understanding the health benefits turkey to beef,of course it depends how they are raised. I have raised grass fed beef before and had good marbling and tender meat. When I say grass fed I do mean 99%. Grass fed beef has CLA in the fat same as dairy from grass fed milk cows.

Jump to this post

@wideurt In fact, after I became allergic to all red meat from a tick bite, I could only eat poultry and fish.
My cholesterol, which had always been low, suddenly rose to the point of needing a statin. I bought all my ‘dark meat’ ground turkey from an ultra clean family run farm near me.
I still don’t know if the lipid rise was a sequella of the tick bite (heart issues often common) or poultry fat, but it does seem contrary to what most health experts recommend.
Before the tick bite I only ate 100% (from cradle to grave) ground bison from a farm in Wisconsin. Best,
Phil

REPLY

This food thing has me questioning things cause I am a meat and potatoes boy. I do understand the problems with our food system. It is so full of chemicals it’s pathetic. I worked in a restaurant for 12 years and 6 years in became allergic to something which an allergist told me I worked in the highest chemical environment and I’m like what’s you talken about I work with the best quality of foods in the world. He laughed and told me there’s more chemicals in our food than anything else and he can’t test for half. Well in time I figured out how to handle the problems. I’ve never ate to many processed foods but admit never enough vegetables. I’m very picky like my salads crisp cooked veg cooked enough but not overly. Plus all the pesticide I mean what is really healthy. Fat on chicken,all crispy and seasoned my favorite.lol Health experts which there are thousands on YouTube’s which I have a few I think I trust ,the other which seem to still like margarine to real butter seed oils to animal fats. I still clarify real butter to cook with plus olive oil .I could go on and on. For your tick bite alpha gal ( if I spelled that right) have you tried a chiropractor for the acupressure points in your ear? Not saying it works but it might. I would definitely try it. Thank all of you for participating in this sight I do find comfort here .

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.