What are people's experiences with spinal fusion surgery?

Posted by heatherm @heatherm, Oct 27, 2020

After trying pretty much everything, with little pain relief, my surgeon has put me on his priorty elective list for fusion of my L3/4/5, and maybe S1. I've heard both positive and negative experiences with this surgery. What are people's experiences, with this? ,

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Spine Health Support Group.

Profile picture for jcnorman123 @jcnorman123

@jcnorman123 You know back fusions are usually only about 60-70 percent successful. But I know if you’re at Mayo , you are in extremely good hands and they know what they are doing !

Jump to this post

@jcnorman123

Spinal fusion success rates vary between 70-95% Where did you find that success rates are much lower than what is currently found in literature?

REPLY
Profile picture for ruthfm @ruthfm

@jcnorman123 yikes! Sounds scary! I can’t walk because of the severe nerve pain down my legs. Hurts to cough, sneeze, take deep breath so unfortunately I’ve been down for 6 weeks or more and going into surgery weak. Not what I want at all!!

Jump to this post

@ruthfm
My situation was similar to yours, and after I woke up from surgery that severe sciatic pain was gone.

REPLY
Profile picture for anonymous16 @anonymous16

@ruthfm
My situation was similar to yours, and after I woke up from surgery that severe sciatic pain was gone.

Jump to this post

@anonymous16 thank you for saying something encouraging! I’m ready to get my life back!!

REPLY
Profile picture for anonymous16 @anonymous16

@jcnorman123

Spinal fusion success rates vary between 70-95% Where did you find that success rates are much lower than what is currently found in literature?

Jump to this post

@anonymous16 mine was unsuccessful screws not fusing tj the vertebra and a lot of chronic pain a year out

REPLY
Profile picture for ruthfm @ruthfm

@anonymous16 thank you for saying something encouraging! I’m ready to get my life back!!

Jump to this post

@ruthfm I also had a very successful surgery 2 years ago!

REPLY
Profile picture for azhrbek @azhrbek

@anonymous16 mine was unsuccessful screws not fusing tj the vertebra and a lot of chronic pain a year out

Jump to this post

@azhrbek - really sorry to hear about your chronic pain a year out and screws not fusing.

What do you plan to do now with this situation?

REPLY

Nothing can be done visited 2 pain specialists and a new clinic all I can do is manage pain and in a brace full time

REPLY

I have had 4 lumbar procedures to deal with congenital spinal stenosis; 2002, lumbar laminectomy; 2017, 2-level lumbar fusion; 2025; "cleanout" of L4-5; did not help, left me in significant pain ans developing scoliosis. Final surgery, 3-level lumbar fusion, L3-4-5; as recommendation of my surgeon. I am mostly pain free. He told me "you are done now". I' m 6 months out, from surgery being done. Iit has been a roller coaster recovering, but it's hugely better.

When you need to have a fusion, you'll know. Plick the best surgeon you can find. Mine is dual qualified in Neurosurgery and Orthopedics.

Good luck.

REPLY
Profile picture for faz @faz

@elainep thank you. My husband had an accident at work 5 years ago he fell down a few concrete stair to his knees and has tried everything before considering surgery. He required a knee replacement and then a knee repair first before even considering anytihing for his back. He has severe spinal stenosis and spine instability, close to bone on bone in places, and pretty much has been living with a pain of 9 for the last few years. After Friday's surgery he is thrilled not to have the terrible sciatic pain shooting down both legs and has caught up on sleep in the hospital over the weekend waiting for Monday's surgery. I know it is a longer posterior procedure he’s up against on Monday, but with the grace of God I hope he comes out feeling as positive as he does now. I appreciate all the tips and tricks I am keeping notes and getting ready. Did you go home straight from the hospital or did you go into an in patient rehab for any amount of time first? They tell me he’ll spend at least a week in the hospital after the second surgery and then PT will determine what happens after that point..whether it’s home or rehab. We are in NYC..a multi level home with stairs, but have one stair lift between 2 levels that we kept from when my mom needed it. We have a good recliner in the living room and we were given another from a friend that I put in the bedroom on the third level of our home since I’ve heard about many sleeping in recliners at first and I also figured he’d have the option not to go down to our main floor since the full bathroom is near the bedrooms so he’d have the bed and the chair to choose from. He’s realistic and knows this will be hard work. I think it’s great that he’s doing well now, and just hope there is nothing to discourage him after the second surgery. I can’t tell you how invaluable your messages have been. Thank you. Remind me again, how long ago were your surgeries? My husband is 61 years old and has lost about 60lbs over the last year to help with his back and also in anticipation of getting in better shape prior to surgery that he didn’t even know he’d have yet. I’m grateful everyday for the hope this is giving him and I have faith that with hard work after surgery it will yield him relief. I also realize how blessed we are to have found a capable neurosurgeon with orthopedic specialty to do this under workers comp at a very good hospital🙏🏻

Jump to this post

@faz wow! Your husband has been through a lot! That is wonderful that he lost 60 pounds in preparation for these surgeries! I had my ALIF last year on Dec. 30, 2025 & the posterior surgery on Jan. 2, 2026. I was in the hospital for almost 2 weeks. Dr. & PT originally suggested a short stay at rehab, but I refused. It may be a good idea if you think you won’t physically be able to help your husband enough …or safely for both of you. My decision was partly based on knowing my partner was fully capable of physically caring for me, plus as a nurse I have witnessed short-staffing and neglect at rehab facilities yet those facilities charge thousands of dollars. One nurse on the floor for 24-28 residents is not safe. Shortage of CNA’s is just as bad. Do you have to walk up a flight of stairs to get to the floor your husband will be recuperating on? That would be very tough if it is more than 3-4 stairs (PT will make sure he can safely walk with a walker and maneuver up and down 2-3 stair steps before they release him). I slept in my recliner in our living room and used a bedside commode for the 1st 4-7 days. Then I had to walk up and down 6 low steps to get to our main level bathroom and shower. Going up stairs was slow but fairly easy for me. Stepping down was scary because I was so scared of falling (your sense of balance feels very out of sorts due to the immobility of your spine and the effects of pain meds).
Anyway, do what works best to keep both you and your partner safe….if that means some time in a good rehab facility to get him strong enough to go home, then do so. Safety is the priority for both of you. On the other hand, if you have multiple family members or friends who can help you get your husband home & he can fully live and have a bathroom on one level, then he may feel more comfortable at home and with sleeping in his own recliner or bed. Once again, I hope this helps. Sorry if I babbled on too much. My thoughts are with you! Hope the 2nd surgery went well…..it is a tough one!

REPLY
Profile picture for Leeman25 @leeman25

I have had 4 lumbar procedures to deal with congenital spinal stenosis; 2002, lumbar laminectomy; 2017, 2-level lumbar fusion; 2025; "cleanout" of L4-5; did not help, left me in significant pain ans developing scoliosis. Final surgery, 3-level lumbar fusion, L3-4-5; as recommendation of my surgeon. I am mostly pain free. He told me "you are done now". I' m 6 months out, from surgery being done. Iit has been a roller coaster recovering, but it's hugely better.

When you need to have a fusion, you'll know. Plick the best surgeon you can find. Mine is dual qualified in Neurosurgery and Orthopedics.

Good luck.

Jump to this post

@leeman25 Hi! Who is your surgeon and which hospital?

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.