Met with dietician today: Some answers to questions the group asked
I met today with a dietitian who specializes in cancer survivorship nutrition. Here’s how that went:
We met for about an hour, just a telephone visit. I had a couple of specific questions, and was happy to hear him provide immediate, detailed responses tailored to prostate cancer - you know how sometimes you’ll talk to an “expert” and you’ll be able to work out pretty quickly that they’re a generalist giving you a general answer with a lot of extra words to pad their response out so they sound like they know more than they do? That wasn’t this guy, he gave very precise answers to my questions. That made me feel confident in talking with him.
Onto the food:
I asked about eggs, because there are a lot of controversy around eggs and prostate cancer.
The dietician talked about the pros and cons about eggs in relation to prostate cancer, then stated the position of the nutritional department at the cancer center is that eggs don’t need to be severely limited, just moderated - no more than two a day. Since I rarely have more than four eggs a week these days, I’m good, but now I feel ok in increasing that a little, maybe up to six eggs a week.
I also asked if there were any foods that were recommended to never consume. I said, “What’s the cigarette of the food world?”
“Two things,” he replied, “Alcohol and deli meats/cured meats. I’m all about moderation in all things, but for those two things, if you don’t have to consume them, then don’t.”
That means hotdogs, bologna, bacon, sausage, salami, even so-called healthy sliced meats, like chicken or turkey from the deli, are an avoid-at-all-costs if possible.
I was surprised by the chicken and turkey stuff, but he said those are processed in such a way to prepare them for deli sales, that it makes them unsuitable for a cancer survivorship diet. That also includes nitrate/nitrite-free stuff and chicken sausages.
Thankfully, he did ok making some of that stuff at home, including roast beef, which would still count against the recommended red meat amounts, but would be better for me than buying the pre-sliced stuff.
That one hurts a little because deli meats and cured meats made up a very large part of my diet. I had some form of that every day, and many times multiple times a day, and have done so since I was old enough to eat solid food (maybe that’s why I developed cancer 😉). I ate obscene amounts of lunchmeats, bacon, and sausages.
So that was the worst of it. With the alcohol, he just said if I don’t feel like I have to drink, then don’t, but recognized that there’s a social component to it that’s hard to fight. I mentioned that I didn’t drink a lot beforehand, and I’m not drinking at all right now, and he simply recommended not starting back again if I could help it.
He then went through the usual things of this much red meat, that much protein, eat a plant-forward diet, eat the rainbow, blah blah blah, but did specifically point out that tomatoes appear to be very effective in curtailing prostate cancer recurrence, so eat tomatoes, fresh, canned, or cooked, as much as possible.
Then he had me tell him typical meals that we eat, three of each of breakfast, lunch, and supper, as well as snacks and desserts, and he graded me very highly on my choices overall, with little tweaks here and there. He said I was eating better than 95% of the people he meets with, and he commended me on my general food/meal knowledge…we even swapped a couple of recipe ideas.
Last thing he left me with was that he was sending me a bunch of dietary info through my patient portal, and that I had access to nutrition services through the care center for the rest of my “very long life,” and “…one more thing: holidays and vacations, throw all that out the window and eat and drink what you want. Life’s too short not to have a little fun.”
All in all, a good meeting, I thought.
Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Prostate Cancer Support Group.
Connect

@carlsbadguy
Same here man! I avoid all "added sugars" whenever possible. But that's a good point about the fruits we eat. Should we limit that? Interesting.
@dpayton
Sucrose (regular sugar) and fructose ( dominates in fruits) effect blood sugar levels directly and fast and that way cause sugar overload in blood which in return causes inflammation WHICH in return promotes cancer growth. Chronic inflammation in body or organs directly and indirectly helps cancer and even causes cancer.
So, as always - if one can not (or better said does not want to) avoid simple sugars, at least try to have them in moderation.
Now, "moderation" is such a BROAD term in general.
If one was eating 10 cookies a day and had 3 grande Starbucks Moka that come with 3 pumps of corn syrup sugar a day tries to "moderate" and have 5 cookies and 1 Moka and thinks that it is moderation LOL - than it is very wrong approach.
Moderation would be one cookie and possibly NO Starbucks Moka ever- choose MUCH healthier version - black coffee with half teaspoon of coconut sugar and 1/2 oz of milk (if you must have some milk).
All in all, one has to know what is recommended amount and try to follow guidelines since what each of us eat every day and in what amount varies tremendously. What is "moderation" for one person would sound very restrictive to another who indulges on regular bases.
I am not a "food person" but even I had some wrong ideas of what is "small amount " of sugar , for example. I had my eyes "opened " when I bought "Libre" device 😱 !!!!! *gulp I would strongly suggest that anybody who worries about glucose spikes buys one of those (there are several brands ) and monitor food effect on their blood sugar for 7 days by trying different groups of food that prevail in ones diet. Also, we are all different in that aspect too - some people have spike for different type of fruit or pasta or rice etc. - it is fascinating indeed. For example, my husband had moderate spike eating oatmeal and almost none eating croissant (???) and HUGE spike eating banana, while I had no spike eating oatmeal etc etc. - we both have normal A1C BTW- around 5.6 but we obviously react differently to the same food. I naively thought that it was better for me to have tiny pop that had 7g of sugar than 3 Lindor truffles _ WRONG !!!!! Truffles caused normal sugar rise and one lollipop cased spike of 180 !!!!! I almost fainted - NO OTHER FOOD cause that ! WHY - lolli had a "HIGH FRUCTOSE corn syrup" as a sweetener !!!
Well , lucky me : ))) - I can eat occasional Lindor chocolate (not the case with other chocolates !!!) " in moderation".
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
4 Reactions@carlsbadguy
@dpayton
This is what’s mentioned about fruit in The Prostate Cancer Foundation’s book (free copies available at their website) “The Science of Living Well, Beyond Cancer:”
“To Eat Fruit or To Not Eat Fruit, That is the Question
“Some of us have a sweet tooth. A 2017 study from the University of Copenhagen found that for some people who have a certain form of the gene FGF21, it might be genetic. For others, it could be just a bad habit or way to cope with stress.
“Fruit contains fructose, a sugar-that’s what makes it sweet! So should you skip the fruit? The answer is, maybe. If you don’t have a sweet tooth, you don’t have to add fruit to your diet, although whole fruit with skin on can be a nice way to add fiber. On the other hand, if you are someone who just has to have that taste of sweetness after dinner, swap your normal cookie, brownie, or ice cream for a piece of fruit with nuts. Most fruit contains less total sugar than most desserts, and the fiber and fat help keep your metabolism regulated. Skip juiced fruit, which has a sweetness profile similar to sugared beverages and sodas.
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
3 Reactions@surftohealth88
@turtbean
You crack me up, Surf! We can all pretty much just hope and pray at this point. haha I mean, some of that just doesn't make any sense whatsoever. I really don't check my A1C much at all, I probably should think about that...
Hey Turtbean(cool name btw) - now I'm even more confused. I asked ChatGPT(I know, I know) if I should eat fruits as a PC survivor. It pretty much said HECK YEAH!!! Listed blueberries as the top choice with strawberries 2nd. I eat some watermelon(7th) and blueberries during the week. So heck, I dunno anymore! 😂😂🤔🤔
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
5 Reactions@dpayton
I’ve been to at least a dozen online meetings with dietitians discussing what to eat with people that have prostate cancer. Fruit is something they say you should eat a lot of, Don’t squeeze it into a juice and drink that, eat the whole fruit, Much more healthy.
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
4 Reactions@dpayton
“Hey Turtbean(cool name btw)”
Thanks - it’s a combination of two of my nicknames, Turtle and Bean. My family called me Turtle from the time I was a baby, because my mom said I had a habit of pulling my head back a lot, and I don’t have much of a chin anyway, so she said I looked like a turtle going into its shell.
Beats me where Bean comes from. 🤷♂️
As for the fruit, I may be a case of some fruits are better/worse than others - fruits with an edible peel, for example, might be higher in fiber compared to something that has no edible peel.
I had a little fun with ChatGPT just now and was able to get it to wholeheartedly recommend eating fresh fruit, to recommend limiting fresh fruit to 2 cups a day, and to limit it to nearly no fruit, just by how I asked my questions! Lol
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
2 Reactions@dpayton
Lol - what is not making sense ??? LMAO BUT, glad I made you laugh 👍😊
BTW- I never implied that fruits are not healthy LOL - god forbid !!!
It is just that eating too much of fruit can cause sugar spike and especially tropical fruit and that is because they have high glycemic index !!! Not all fruits are the same in that regard so YES - berries have low to moderate glycemic index and do not effect glucose levels much AND are full of pigments that are very strong anti oxidants.
Dried fruits on the other hand have very high G index.
What I described is actually well documented phenomenon - we all have different metabolic status and digest things differently.
What causes spike for one person can be ok for another person, and that is why Libre (etc) are so helpful IF somebody wants to know how certain food groups effect their sugar metabolism.
Eating WHOLE fruits (and organic for that matter) is very healthy and PARTICULARLY fruits with low G index IF one has any problems with glucose levels or spikes. (And of course there is no need to have one whole pineapple or whole watermelon in one seating lol )
I hope that now you understood what I was trying to say in my previous post : )))) , if not - ask away <3 !
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
4 ReactionsI drink a glass of orange juice a day, but that is the only fruit juice I do. Do eat strawberries during the summer. Never really think about eating fruit or actually think much about a diet at all. I seen in here about processed meat and got me to thinking. Haven't had a hotdog in years and this week I ate 3 chili dogs. I bet that pizza has processed meat as well as my Subway ham sandwich. Guess I am not much on watching a diet as I just never needed to as I did lots of hard work and now lots of exercising. Never had to worry about weight, so didn't worry about diets. It would be hard to change after 79 years.
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
1 Reaction@turtbean Fructose is a LOT different from high fructose corn syrup; so of course, anything with the ‘f’ word gets vilified😖.
As Surf pointed out, whole fruits are not just fructose, they merely contain it.
My wife and I eat blueberries and nuts daily - ooops! there goes my ‘moderation’ thing out the window! - and our check up and bloodwork profiles are consistently normal…so how can fruit be bad?
I read the other day that raisins are a superfood…but wait, aren’t they really high in sugar? Yes, they are but their fiber content slows down absorption so no glucose spike occurs; they are probably on the higher end of the glycemic index, but some raisins added to salads, cereals, yogurt, etc are not gonna kill you.
I even throw a few into savory dishes when I want a hint of sweetness and that plump morsel every now and then tastes really really good!
Phil
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
3 Reactions@jeffmarc
Thanks for this Jeff. I was wondering. I eat watermelon, and berries for the most part. I think I'm going to add strawberries too. Speaking of eating, I keep hearing how good tomatoes are for us. But you need to cook(heat) them. Now I gotta figure out recipes!!! hahaha
-
Like -
Helpful -
Hug
2 Reactions