I'm not an expert on doctors at Mayo Scottsdale, but here's my story. I consulted with Dr. Paul Andrews there in early 05/2024. I was 70 at the time and he did my NS RARP in late 06/2024. I didn't "pick" him, but when he was assigned to me I did some research on him and liked what I saw. During the consult, I felt like like he didn't sugar coat things, nor did he try to sell me on surgery. I had a list of questions and I felt like he tried to give me fact/data based answers so I'd have realistic expectations. I decided on surgery (which was my bias going in) and he did my surgery. I believe he did an excellent job on me. I was released the same day, very easy recovery, and when the catheter came out I was immediately continent. I did have serious ED which slowly went away over 15 months. I did do a penile rehab routine they directed (when I asked them about penile rehab). Click on my profile and you can see my previous comments discussing my journey. Looking back, it all went very well but it was stressful at the time. I have no idea which treatment path is best for you, nor do I know who's "the best" surgeon at Mayo Scottsdale/Phoenix, but I do know Dr. Paul Andrews did a great job on me a little over 2 years ago. Best wishes.