Surgery advice for enlarged prostate (BPH)

Posted by chalesbehm1 @chalesbehm1, Mar 22, 2025

Was wondering, if having a procedure to reduce the size of my prostrate is beneficial?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Prostate Cancer Support Group.

Profile picture for Colleen Young, Connect Director @colleenyoung

@okey33, are you considering surgery for BPH?

Jump to this post

@colleenyoung

Good Morning, Colleen:

I'm new to this group and wanted to say that I find it an immensely helpful resource for understanding and coping with the challenges of my medical diagnoses. I have begun posting and receiving responses from other members. While I appreciate and find great value in the open format, there have been instances where private communication appears more appropriate. Unfortunately, I can't locate the option to do so. Has this feature not yet been enabled for my account or am I missing something? Thank you in advance.

REPLY
Profile picture for samsmydog2 @samsmydog2

@colleenyoung

Good Morning, Colleen:

I'm new to this group and wanted to say that I find it an immensely helpful resource for understanding and coping with the challenges of my medical diagnoses. I have begun posting and receiving responses from other members. While I appreciate and find great value in the open format, there have been instances where private communication appears more appropriate. Unfortunately, I can't locate the option to do so. Has this feature not yet been enabled for my account or am I missing something? Thank you in advance.

Jump to this post

@samsmydog2
The envelope in the upper right is where you can send private messages. You cannot do this right away as a new member, however.

If you had somebody send a private message to you first, you could reply.

REPLY
Profile picture for Jeff Marchi @jeffmarc

@samsmydog2
The envelope in the upper right is where you can send private messages. You cannot do this right away as a new member, however.

If you had somebody send a private message to you first, you could reply.

Jump to this post

@jeffmarc
Thank you, Jeff.

REPLY

Had HoLEP. Best thing ever. No side effects and now I can sleep through the night without waking to urinate. Stream very strong and I empty my bladder everytime
I was on A.S. at the time and they biopsied the tissue. It didn't show cancer, but 3 years later 4+4, 1 lesion

REPLY
Profile picture for heavyphil @heavyphil

I had Green Light Laser for BPH - instant relief, no bleeding, no pain. Urinated like a boy again…
Less invasive than HOLEP which is more like a TURP and physically removes chunks of prostate lining; involves a longer recovery and longer catheter time.
Your pursuit of a remedy is really determined by how much discomfort or inconvenience you have. In my case, I couldn’t urinate or did only partially and was going to the bathroom every half hour…
Phil

Jump to this post

@heavyphil
The only drawback I can see to the green light treatment is that none of the prostate cells can be biopsied. A biopsy can be done, however, following the TURP and HOLEP. I'm still leaning toward the green light treatment. Is there any impact on sexual functioning? The Tamsulosin I take causes some retro-ejaculation into the bladder, and it also delays orgasm. This is a potential side effect I wasn't aware of until I Googled it after taking for a couple of years. Has the green light impacted this aspect of sexual functioning for you?

REPLY
Profile picture for samsmydog2 @samsmydog2

@heavyphil
The only drawback I can see to the green light treatment is that none of the prostate cells can be biopsied. A biopsy can be done, however, following the TURP and HOLEP. I'm still leaning toward the green light treatment. Is there any impact on sexual functioning? The Tamsulosin I take causes some retro-ejaculation into the bladder, and it also delays orgasm. This is a potential side effect I wasn't aware of until I Googled it after taking for a couple of years. Has the green light impacted this aspect of sexual functioning for you?

Jump to this post

@samsmydog2 It did not…however, knowing what I know now, I would go with HoLep for the ability to biopsy.
My Uro Surgeon for my RARP said that I may have had PCa at the time of the Green Light treatment, and from the sheer volume of cancer I had at biopsy 6 yrs later, he could’ve been right.
I’d recommend a PSE test - 94% effective for finding PCa - BEFORE doing anything.
If it’s all good, then Green Light is probably the way to go.
Phil

REPLY

So, are you on medication (FLOWMAX) to help with BPH? Seems like that is the usual first step.

REPLY
Profile picture for marlon @marlon

So, are you on medication (FLOWMAX) to help with BPH? Seems like that is the usual first step.

Jump to this post

@marlon
Yes, I am prescribed both tamsulosin and tadalafil.

REPLY
Profile picture for heavyphil @heavyphil

@samsmydog2 It did not…however, knowing what I know now, I would go with HoLep for the ability to biopsy.
My Uro Surgeon for my RARP said that I may have had PCa at the time of the Green Light treatment, and from the sheer volume of cancer I had at biopsy 6 yrs later, he could’ve been right.
I’d recommend a PSE test - 94% effective for finding PCa - BEFORE doing anything.
If it’s all good, then Green Light is probably the way to go.
Phil

Jump to this post

@heavyphil
Thanks, Phil, hope you landed on your feet, your outlook is good and everything is still operating properly. This is good advice, as determining whether my issue is BPH or cancer has become quite a dilemma, as has finding a doctor I can put my faith in. I'd never have even heard of the options such as green light, HOLEP, or PSE if it weren't for the guys here like you. I have a urology appointment Friday and I'm requesting the PSE as you suggest.
Dennis

REPLY
Profile picture for service1010 @service1010

Had HoLEP. Best thing ever. No side effects and now I can sleep through the night without waking to urinate. Stream very strong and I empty my bladder everytime
I was on A.S. at the time and they biopsied the tissue. It didn't show cancer, but 3 years later 4+4, 1 lesion

Jump to this post

@service1010
No retrograde ejaculation?

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.