How to know what spine surgeons and their reviews are honest?

Posted by annie1 @annie1, Jun 6 10:58pm

A friend of mine was helping me look up some surgeons I have had appointments with and one of them had very brief reviews, like "Good" or he is a great surgeon, etc. None of them had any first name with last initial as I have seen in some other review sites. So, how do I know anything about his work?
Another surgeon I am going to see had two or three horrible reviews, like, "he ruined my life." But how do I know that is real? Any knowledge of how these things work please let me know.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Spine Health Support Group.

Profile picture for annie1 @annie1

@sueinmn
I have a counselor/therapist but she doesn't know much about spine issues or actually she doesn't know about spine issues so it doesn't really help. So anyway thanks for your advice.

Jump to this post

@annie1
I have not read any of yout past comments, but it was the title that you posted that caught my attention. That is certainly no small concern, and I can imagine how this is affecting everything that you do and think about constantly because it brings to mind a loved one who also faced a life of paralysis for a different reason. Anyway, I am happy to see that you have a counselor/therapist, however, I do have a thought that might be helpful to you at this stage of your condition. Here is what I learnd from a loved one - The very best thing that they were encouraged to do, by the rehab team was to get therapy - from a therapist who specialized in the spinal condition/recovery/potential paralysis. In fact, the rehab team made a recommendation, and it was a good match - and - more helpful than expected.

@annie1, What do you think about finding a therapist who specializes in a specific condition such as you are facing?

REPLY
Profile picture for Rosemary, Volunteer Mentor @rosemarya

@annie1
I have not read any of yout past comments, but it was the title that you posted that caught my attention. That is certainly no small concern, and I can imagine how this is affecting everything that you do and think about constantly because it brings to mind a loved one who also faced a life of paralysis for a different reason. Anyway, I am happy to see that you have a counselor/therapist, however, I do have a thought that might be helpful to you at this stage of your condition. Here is what I learnd from a loved one - The very best thing that they were encouraged to do, by the rehab team was to get therapy - from a therapist who specialized in the spinal condition/recovery/potential paralysis. In fact, the rehab team made a recommendation, and it was a good match - and - more helpful than expected.

@annie1, What do you think about finding a therapist who specializes in a specific condition such as you are facing?

Jump to this post

@rosemarya: You have a good point - the specialty to which you're referring is known collectively as pain psychologists or behavioral medicine specialists. In my past professional life I have known of individuals who have sought and obtained treatment from such clinically trained professionals. Psychology today does have a site dedicated to finding these therapists: https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/therapists

REPLY
Profile picture for Susan, Volunteer Mentor @grammato3

@rosemarya: You have a good point - the specialty to which you're referring is known collectively as pain psychologists or behavioral medicine specialists. In my past professional life I have known of individuals who have sought and obtained treatment from such clinically trained professionals. Psychology today does have a site dedicated to finding these therapists: https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/therapists

Jump to this post

@grammato3
Thank you I'll look at that link. By the way I really should have not said I was afraid to be paralyzed. I really don't think that's realistic for my symptoms. I think in the middle of the night it's easy to become extreme. I don't think I'll be paralyzed let me just say that again it's not that severe. Is confusing and scary because I've gotten so many different answers some surgeons didn't want to touch me they said I was too high risk. So, that being said I think it's normal to be leery of surgery when surgeons themselves are telling you you are too high risk. Of course those are only a few the others were gung-ho on doing fusion. So it's really hard to sort through.

REPLY
Profile picture for annie1 @annie1

@grammato3
Thank you I'll look at that link. By the way I really should have not said I was afraid to be paralyzed. I really don't think that's realistic for my symptoms. I think in the middle of the night it's easy to become extreme. I don't think I'll be paralyzed let me just say that again it's not that severe. Is confusing and scary because I've gotten so many different answers some surgeons didn't want to touch me they said I was too high risk. So, that being said I think it's normal to be leery of surgery when surgeons themselves are telling you you are too high risk. Of course those are only a few the others were gung-ho on doing fusion. So it's really hard to sort through.

Jump to this post

@annie1: No need to explain - pain and anxiety are very closely related; especially at night there is a tendency for our brains to get carried away with thinking worse case scenarios and this is a safe place to express your concerns without judgment. While we can't offer any direct advice, those professionals trained to do so can be a good first step should those mind games get too intense or the confusion and/or pain start to interfere too much in your daily activities.

Surgery has been one option to try to address this issue but is not, as you've unfortunately found, always completely successful and it appears you've attempted some injections. If these have these been done by a pain management group, perhaps another area to consider would be an implantable spinal cord device. This is not my own area of personal experience so much as having worked with it in some professional capacity so I admit I may be out of bounds here not knowing the particulars of your situation but I'm merely offering the consideration with your medical team. Has this ever been discussed as a possibility?

REPLY

I think going to Mayo Clinic in Phoenix is an excellent suggestion. I had a huge tumor growing on my spine.
Mucho pain 9 or 10 24/7. I would recommend Antony Guanciale at UC Medical in Cincinnati. My opinion: He is simply the best of the best. It's worth going to Cincy to see Dr. G. His work number is (513) 475-8690. I won't gush more. All I can say is 10 years pain free thanks to him. Oh, I'm 81. Good Luck!

REPLY

@annie1 sorry that I accidentally deleted this post. I have another one you can see.

REPLY

@annie1 I look up medical professional reviews on a site called Healthgrades. You enter names, specialties, and facility names. I believe that each review has some sort of name or initials. The reviewers seem to be real people.

REPLY
Profile picture for annie1 @annie1

After 7 years of having stenosis and finally having a laminotomy two and a half years ago I'm back to square one with the pain returning. Laminotomy only works for 3 months. At this point too surgeons have done epidural injections determine which level of my spine is causing the pain. So far the injections aren't helping anything so I am wondering does that mean surgery won't help and if surgery won't help what is my future? I have throbbingg after I walk. I feel my pain is getting worse every year and I was told I should do usually about a year ago but I didn't and now it seems like I might have waited too long and not even fusion will help I'm getting very worried and don't know what the next step should be. And send me any advice / doctors who can work on extremely difficult cases or perhaps hopeless cases.

Jump to this post

@annie1
I am so sorry to hear your discomfort. I have celiac disease and severe osteoporosis. Can't do any injections since my bones will disintegrate more.
I live 24/7 in pain cause no one managed me correctly.
I'll pray for you. Its a horrible invisible disease.

REPLY
Profile picture for marcd2k @marcd2k

@gravity3 Hello, thanks for writing. Yes, it has been a real eye opener for me and my wife seeing how poorly the healthcare system is being run. We have been told on more than one occasion by our insurance carrier that we have a very good plan. It turns out, you can save a lot of money by not having insurance, and then paying cash for visits or procedures.

The main thing is to not give up. Just because someone tells you they know the answer, or that they don't know the answer, until you find out what the actual medical problem is and how to treat it, you keep moving. Keep reading, watching videos, writing to people, ask questions, etc.

This has been my full time job since July of 2023. I read, watch, call, and write to everyone I feel could have an idea for what is wrong, or who to see next. I have been to more than 30 doctors, and this is why.

Several gave up before even seeing me in person, several more gave up after a single visit, or a single procedure, was done, but there was no change to my condition. I've had two doctors that I felt were actually trying, to the point they got upset when something didn't work. And it took me about 2 years to find a Primary doctor that actually listens and returns calls / messages, and cares about what is happening.

Onward we go...

Jump to this post

@marcd2k
Where do you live? Just wondering because we could compare notes about doctors in our area if it's the same area.

REPLY
Profile picture for sean2026 @sean2026

I just had Fusion done - I interviewed a few and selected my surgeon - I trust my surgeon, can recommend, but where are you located?

Jump to this post

@sean2026
I'm in New York / Brooklyn where there are tons of surgeons each one giving me a different procedure they would do. Few of them agreed I need three level fusion others say one level with a laminectomy below it, etc etc hard to know which one would work out and I don't want to do a surgery and then have to have another one within 6 months. So I would travel I have traveled far I went to Mayo and Rochester but the surgeon I spoke to said they wouldn't be able to necessarily give me rehab after I would go to a hotel! Can you imagine going to a hotel after having a fusion? I asked if they were hotels with nurses and they said no.?? Go to a hotel after having spinal fusion with no help

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.