← Return to Any non fracture members?

Discussion
rudysmom avatar

Any non fracture members?

Osteoporosis & Bone Health | Last Active: 4 minutes ago | Replies (146)

Comment receiving replies
Profile picture for jozer @jozer

Question for anyone - is there not a difference between fragility fracture and regular fracture? I have osteoporosis currently but was told in the past a DEXA isn't done until the magic age of 65 (15 years post menopause for me) or if you should fracture. I broke my wrist a few years before age 65; the surgeon who put it together with plate and pins said my bone looked great and healing was basically perfect. I asked him about a DEXA and he didn't think it was necessary. I did not pick up something and spontaneously break a wrist. I was in a car wreck and the airbag broke it; emt and ER doc said they see this type of break all the time. Is there a difference in how fractures are perceived (traumatic vs fragility) or is everyone who breaks anything in any way after a certain age considered osteoporotic? After wrist healed my PC sent me for DEXA scan, and numbers did show osteoporosis, which I am treating. Seems odd to me that all fractures are considered equally. My nephew broke his wrist falling off a scooter (age 27) and did not get a DEXA...

Jump to this post


Replies to "Question for anyone - is there not a difference between fragility fracture and regular fracture? I..."

@jozer, the real difference is a fracture that wouldn't have happened unless you have osteopenic or osteoporotic bones.
The medical definition of a fragility fracture is a fracture resulting from a low energy fall from a standing height or less, or a fracture from some minor stress, like coughing that wouldn't normally cause a fracture.
You have a good PC.