Trying to choose between radiation and surgery

Posted by ginger38314 @ginger38314, 4 days ago

Diagnosed 7/15/26, 2 of 12 cores 3+4 on both 20% and 30%involvement t1c, have oncologist appointment on 8/20 and Urology surgeon on 9/28, asked my main urologist for a decipher test hopefully it reaches the oncologist before the appointment. If it comes in lower considering optional treatments without adt but if not probably will proceed to nerve sparing surgery also if that was the case I was hoping I could get a lower groin hernia fixed at the same time.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Prostate Cancer Support Group.

There's definitely arguments on both sides, but I will see how my decipher score turns out and go from there.

REPLY

I have an appointment at ohsu on 8/20. Ideally would like to do radiation without adt.

REPLY
Profile picture for rickdent @rickdent

77y/o
Diagnosed 5-1-26
Some Gleason 8/8, Decipher .93
In good overall health.
Have had Lupron injection just over a month ago in preparation for radiation. I am equivocating now between surgery and radiation.
Any help from those who have been there would be much appreciated.

Jump to this post

@rickdent I have been there. At 77 I don't think you'll have a surgery. Gleason 8+8 is high and your medical team, I guess, will try to block the testosterone to slow down the cancer. Lupron has some side effects but it is is the most efficient known to block the levels of testosterone.
If this helps you, I have the surgery 9/19/2015. The cancer came back on 8/17.
Since then, I have been with cancer; stage 4 since 6/2019. I am 80 now.
Good luck

REPLY

That's not me 2 out 12 cores Gleason 3+4 t1c psa 5 , .156 psa density waiting for decipher score on up coming oncologist app excellent health otherwise age 69.

REPLY
Profile picture for Jeff Marchi @jeffmarc

@rickdent
At 77 surgery is not the greatest idea. Radiation would take care of this for you and would be just as effective, and last a long time. If you had surgery, it might come back soon and you’d have to have radiation then.

I’m 78 and had my diagnosis at 62. Had surgery because my father died of prostate cancer and had radiation, It came back after 3 1/2 years and I had to have radiation. It has come back three more times, but the drugs they have today work very well And keep me undetectable.

My brother at 77 had five sessions of SBRT radiation. He’s 80 now and doing just fine.

I know people that had Gleason nine and had radiation and it didn’t come back for 15 or 20 years. Rick, The guy who runs the ancan.org Advanced prostate cancer meetings had Gleason eight and had SBRT radiation 17 years ago and is Having no reoccurrences.

I don’t think there’s really a lot of decisions to make, Radiation will work just fine And give you plenty of years.

Jump to this post

@jeffmarc
Thank you so much for your generous and rapid response.
Have you been on ADT continually?

REPLY
Profile picture for amota @amota

@rickdent I have been there. At 77 I don't think you'll have a surgery. Gleason 8+8 is high and your medical team, I guess, will try to block the testosterone to slow down the cancer. Lupron has some side effects but it is is the most efficient known to block the levels of testosterone.
If this helps you, I have the surgery 9/19/2015. The cancer came back on 8/17.
Since then, I have been with cancer; stage 4 since 6/2019. I am 80 now.
Good luck

Jump to this post

@amota
Thank you so much for your response. May I ask if you have been on Lupron continually since your recurrence?

REPLY
Profile picture for rickdent @rickdent

@jeffmarc
Thank you so much for your generous and rapid response.
Have you been on ADT continually?

Jump to this post

@rickdent
I have been on ADT since 04/2017. I did stop in 2024 for eight months, My oncologist and I both figured my Testosterone would never come back. In eight months, it hit 50. My oncologist had me go right back on so I’ve essentially been on it for almost 9 years now.

REPLY
Profile picture for rickdent @rickdent

@amota
Thank you so much for your response. May I ask if you have been on Lupron continually since your recurrence?

Jump to this post

I was just diagnosed with 3+4 2 out if 12 cores haven't started treatment
yet see oncologist on 8/20

REPLY
Profile picture for rickdent @rickdent

77y/o
Diagnosed 5-1-26
Some Gleason 8/8, Decipher .93
In good overall health.
Have had Lupron injection just over a month ago in preparation for radiation. I am equivocating now between surgery and radiation.
Any help from those who have been there would be much appreciated.

Jump to this post

@rickdent Similar situation at 76 YO. Doctors do not recommend and really didn't want to discuss. I spent way too much time researching the surgical option because articles, including those from leading sources, rarely mention age related treatment limitations.

REPLY
Profile picture for rickdent @rickdent

77y/o
Diagnosed 5-1-26
Some Gleason 8/8, Decipher .93
In good overall health.
Have had Lupron injection just over a month ago in preparation for radiation. I am equivocating now between surgery and radiation.
Any help from those who have been there would be much appreciated.

Jump to this post

@rickdent Did you have a PSMA PET scan? At a Gleason 8 there is a high probability of micro metastasis in the prostate bed which would give you a recurrence after surgery. The Decipher is also not good. Recovery is also worse from surgery the older you get. Many surgeons will not even consider a patient at 77. For all those reasons radiation with ADT was probably recommended. If there are no metastasis on the PSMA PET the ADT should be 6-12 months. If Orgovyx is covered it is usually easier than Lupron on the body. Has an ARSI been discussed in addition to Lupron? All of this depends on what was found in the biopsy. How many cores were positive? What percentage of these cores? were there other aggressive conditions found?

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.