I’m scheduled for knee replacement but read so many negatives ?

Posted by andoman @andoman, Jul 9 3:03pm

Im having full knee replacement very soon and researching I read so many negatives so for all of you who have had it, is it worth it ? I’m definitely concerned that I’ll be worse off by reading so many problems with pain, swelling and movement with knee replacements and maybe one should just put up with what we deal with now than adding pain and swelling into the mix.
Any advice would be much appreciated.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Joint Replacements Support Group.

Profile picture for janrose123 @janrose123

@andoman, I’m in NJ, USA. We have excellent health insurance and everything is expensive here. Wishing you well in your TKR journey and knowing how to prepare yourself to fully engage in your healing process will help push you forward. Diligence and persistence on those two fronts are key.

Jump to this post

@janrose123
Thank you very much

REPLY
Profile picture for rebeccarsg2007 @rebeccarsg2007

@andoman
My thoughts go out to you during the days ahead. I hope for your full recovery & relief from the awful pain you have suffered.

Jump to this post

@rebeccarsg2007

Thank you so much, very much appreciated and I’ll let everybody on here know how it all turns out. Fingers crossed 🤞

REPLY
Profile picture for heyjoe415 @heyjoe415

Hi there friend.

Not sure if this has been covered. I had both knees replaced (four months apart) in 2022 when I was 67.

One of the best decisions I've ever made. Like many, my knees were bone-on-bone and pain was daily. Following surgery, no more pain.

Do research on a good surgeon, and most of all, follow the rehab rules and exercises from your physical therapist.

Joe

Jump to this post

@heyjoe415
Well that’s fantastic to hear, some positive good news. Very happy yours went so well. I don’t know where you are but here in Australia you need Top Tier Health Cover to pick your own surgeon and Hospital for joint replacements and it’s expensive so my level of Health Cover does not cover joints therefore I’m getting it done in the Australian Public Hospital System, it doesn’t cost you anything but you can’t pick the surgeon.
The hospital they picked for my surgery is at least a top one, lucky there, and my surgeon seems quite good at it as his reviews are all 5 star so hopefully I’ll be sweet . . . still it worries me though.

REPLY
Profile picture for momma2lucy @momma2lucy

@andoman look for the small positive changes everyday in your knee. Today is two weeks post op for me and I am glad I went through with the surgery. Remember most people don’t come on here or post on FB joint groups praising their successful surgery but are looking for solutions and we don’t know their full background story or where or who did their surgery. Let us know how you are doing post op.

Jump to this post

@momma2lucy
Yes that’s true so hopefully I’ll be one of the very lucky ones but I’ll definitely respond on here to let all the nice people who have replied to me know how it all goes.

REPLY
Profile picture for roddy0959 @roddy0959

@andoman I’m that same person very active which can be a good thing. You will go through PT and get rich back on your feet. It may take a minute but you will continue to be active as I am but I have my limitations. I had 5 major surgeries on the same knee and I just will not let it stop me from doing what I enjoy doing. Sure I can’t run are play basketball but I still do a lot of the things I’ve always done. I’m very thankful that I’ve come through this it could have been a lot worse. You should be fine just do what you are told in PT you will see improvement in time

Jump to this post

@roddy0959
Thank you for your comment. Yes I’ll definitely be giving it my best shot and getting back to living fast as possible.
I just hope I’m not one of the 3-5% they say that get infections somehow

REPLY
Profile picture for andoman @andoman

@laurabamford4015
Thank you for your reply, yes I’ll face it head on and probably wish I hadn’t of done it when I’m in so much pain and stress but if it gives me peace and my life back, I’ll be smiling with my Hollywood style teeth 🤣

Jump to this post

@andoman
Just be patient, keep the faith and have really kind upbeat helpers. My kids got me through it and kept reminding me of painful and disabled I was before the surgery and how much better I’d be once I recovered. I couldn’t walk more than a 1/2 mile and yesterday I walked 8 miles!

REPLY
Profile picture for andoman @andoman

@roddy0959
Thank you for your comment. Yes I’ll definitely be giving it my best shot and getting back to living fast as possible.
I just hope I’m not one of the 3-5% they say that get infections somehow

Jump to this post

@andoman don’t worry yourself into more stress the first week will be the hardest God speed on your recovery

REPLY
Profile picture for andoman @andoman

@missy4242
Also gives me a sore back as I’m out of balance

Jump to this post

@andoman
Yes! Lower back.
It initially started only left side. I went to Mayo's Spine Center and they offered me physical therapy which I haven't started yet because I have been doing my own at home but they told me my complete spine is full of arthritis.

REPLY
Profile picture for andoman @andoman

@missy4242
Gee that’s not good, I feel for you, this sort of pain is just so horrible.
You probably need surgery as soon as possible.

Jump to this post

@andoman
Yes. Unfortunately. Still awaiting a call back for an appt with the surgeon at Mayo

REPLY

It depends upon your definition of bad. Most studies have said somewhere around 90% of knee replacement recipients are satisfied, not equally numbers. If you mean 50% have pain during recovery, you are probably low in the other direction.

A TKR is a traumatic event. Even if the surgery is minimally invasive, the surgeon is still cutting off parts of two bones and attaching something artificial to them. If the surgery is traditional, as most still are, the surgeon also cut the tendon and muscle to gain access creating even more trauma. Once in there, the surgeon cuts and removes the ACL and often the PCL as well.

So one should expect some pain. But the end result is worth it. I recently had my six month checkup and my surgeon told me I had no limitations. Before the surgery I was in constant if endurable pain in my right knee and extreme pain if I stepped the wrong way from a nerve impingement caused by my severe misalignment. Now I can do things with my grandkids such as walking around the zoo for hours or going to a trampoline center with them.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.