← Return to Cancer isn't war, it's evolution.

Discussion
fritzo avatar

Cancer isn't war, it's evolution.

Prostate Cancer | Last Active: Jun 18 3:46pm | Replies (34)

Comment receiving replies
Profile picture for Read & learn & live! @readandlearn

Certain types of cancer may be genetically based, but that still wouldn't make them evolutionary. A genetic defect is evolutionary only if it affects the ability to reproduce (by death or sterilization). Since the vast majority of cancers affect one's health far beyond the age to reproduce, they are not evolutionary & don't participate in any kind of "natural selection".

By contrast, any gene that causes people to participate in risky behavior at a young age (eg, racing motorcycles), could be evolutionary. 🙂

A couple years ago I paid four (early teens) boys to do some extensive yard work for me. I thought teenage girls were chatterboxes, but these boys had them beat. They were all discussing their broken bones. I offered that I had never broken a bone in my life. One boy popped up & said, "neither have I", to which another replied, "yes, but you are 13, & he is 80."

So, I have the "cautious gene". 🙂 I suppose it affects my decision to remain on ADT & suffer side effects.

Jump to this post


Replies to "Certain types of cancer may be genetically based, but that still wouldn't make them evolutionary. A..."

@readandlearn A long time ago (preCambrian) cellular DNA repair mechanisms emerged that minimized mutations when the earth's had more radiation exposure. Over the eons minor mutations in these mechanisms ceased to be evolutionary relevant and many of these have accumulated and are now associated with major cancer risk such as BRACA1/2, ATM, etc.

@readandlearn Risky behavior gene-maybe. I always thought it was because young people's brains aren't fully developed yet. Although, I have my moments. But, guess my brain works well enough that I'm in the no broken bones category too. Pure dumb luck in my case.