Bone Coach - How do you know it works?

Posted by sheilad1 @sheilad1, Dec 13, 2022

I have seen several people here joined Bone Coach. How do you know your osteoperosis is better. The testimonials talk about general health improving which adherence to any healthy diet may have done the same.
There is no science shown. It's pricey but worth it if it works.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Osteoporosis & Bone Health Support Group.

I noticed that the label states that it is formulated and distributed by OsteoNatural. Sounds to me that it is manufactured by another company and sold under the OsteoNatural name. There is a major toilet paper company that recently filed for bankruptcy that makes many products that are sold under many different brand names. Very common practice.

REPLY
Profile picture for dooshie @dooshie

He is an integrative cardiologist but has extensive training in hormone therapy and nutrition. He’s a bit quirky but my first appt he sat with me for 45 minutes just getting to know me. Follow up appts are pretty regular and he’ll sit with me for 20-30 minutes going over bloodwork and just seeing how I’m doing. He did extensive tests on my heart and does all my bloodwork every year. I really like him.

Jump to this post

@dooshie you are very lucky. Most drs in the LA area have such a holistic approach! I wish I could find someone like him in Mich...

REPLY
Profile picture for Helen, Volunteer Mentor @naturegirl5

@sueinmn This is good advice and information.

If one wants to search the scientific literature try Google Scholar. Using the key words Bone Coach you can see if there is peer-reviewed scientific evidence. That way one can locate valid and reliable evidence if it there is any that has been published in a scientific journal.

Does this help?

Jump to this post

@naturegirl5 Peer reviewed scientific evidence is hard to come by. Also few years ago,, there were reports of sort of "scam" scientific journals---authors of the research paid to publish and were not really peer reviewed---real peer reviewed articles don't pay the journal to be reviewed and published...............

REPLY

I can't seem to "get out" of this columnwithout commeting--so thisis the comment

REPLY
Profile picture for cleveland30 @cleveland30

@naturegirl5 Peer reviewed scientific evidence is hard to come by. Also few years ago,, there were reports of sort of "scam" scientific journals---authors of the research paid to publish and were not really peer reviewed---real peer reviewed articles don't pay the journal to be reviewed and published...............

Jump to this post

@cleveland30 This is an interesting perspective. It has not been my experience that peer-reviewed scientific evidence is hard to come by. It's all in how one searches and vets what one is reading.

I am retired faculty from a university so I use the university library services to do my research for peer-reviewed articles. I feel assured that in using this university website for my searches that I pull up reliable scientific journal references. I never use Google for these searches. If a person wishes to use Google I suggest Google Scholar.

It's always good to make sure that any research one uses is from a reliable source.

REPLY

Do your own research and see what makes sense is my suggestion. I am on the bone meds myself. After researching, I don't believe anything they are trying to sell you makes sense unless you are unable to google search yourself. Use Google Scholar and the NHI (National Health Institute) and ask your doctor for sources. The problem is that supplements don't go directly to building bones. I don't feel that anything I've read helps. If you need to pay someone so you will exercise, then maybe... Grifters and snake oil salesmen take advantage of people.

REPLY
Profile picture for cleveland30 @cleveland30

@naturegirl5 Peer reviewed scientific evidence is hard to come by. Also few years ago,, there were reports of sort of "scam" scientific journals---authors of the research paid to publish and were not really peer reviewed---real peer reviewed articles don't pay the journal to be reviewed and published...............

Jump to this post

@cleveland30
Alternatives to Google Scholar
https://paperpal.com/blog/news-updates/google-scholar-alternatives-tested-reviewed.
Google Scholar has a few troubles with reliability.
I attach "PubMed" to my searches understanding the heading caution and watching the dates of publication.

REPLY

I’m wondering if anyone has heard of Joanne Friedman Bone Coach? Have you participated in her program? I haven’t been able to find any reviews. Thanks!

REPLY
Profile picture for loriesco @loriesco

Do your own research and see what makes sense is my suggestion. I am on the bone meds myself. After researching, I don't believe anything they are trying to sell you makes sense unless you are unable to google search yourself. Use Google Scholar and the NHI (National Health Institute) and ask your doctor for sources. The problem is that supplements don't go directly to building bones. I don't feel that anything I've read helps. If you need to pay someone so you will exercise, then maybe... Grifters and snake oil salesmen take advantage of people.

Jump to this post

@loriesco, I agree. Ours is a pretty vulnerable population, and there’s so much confusion and so many conflicting opinions that few people feel confident about the best way to address the myriad concerns. It creates the perfect breeding ground for grifters and snake oil salesmen who capitalize on fear. At the same time, there are legitimate professionals and evidence-based approaches out there - but they can be hard to distinguish from the noise.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.