← Return to Does the anxiety or fear of this prognosis ever get better?

Discussion
Comment receiving replies
Profile picture for daisy17 @daisy17

@otherside I agree with you. Doctors prescribing Fosamax will say it offers a 50% fracture reduction. What that means as an "absolute risk" is that if 100 women with severe bone loss take Fosamax for three years, instead of two people getting a hip fracture -- only one person will get a fracture, a 50% improvement. So, to prevent one hip fracture, 98 women take the drug with no fracture benefit.

From AI Assist: "Bisphosphonates are estimated to prevent 1 hip fracture for every 100 women treated over three years. However, they are more effective at reducing vertebral fractures, with a higher prevention rate."

Consumer reports article: https://www.consumerreports.org/cro/2012/04/popular-osteoporosis-drugs-come-with-mounting-concerns/index.htm

Jump to this post


Replies to "@otherside I agree with you. Doctors prescribing Fosamax will say it offers a 50% fracture reduction...."

@daisy17 I have always heard from Dr. Greger that Fosamax is the cause of bone fractures. And that calcium pills cause heart attacks in women.

@daisy17 I was a copy editor on a prominent medical journal for 14 years. It was drummed into us that results presented solely as percentages, as in the example you gave above, were meaningless. If doctors recommending osteoporosis medication are presenting the odds to patients in this manner, they're doing so either out of ignorance or deceptiveness.