Choosing a spine surgeon

Posted by annie1 @annie1, Nov 15, 2025

I have a problem in that I have interviewed many surgeons and there are at least two who have very good reviews and I'm having a hard time deciding who to go with. One of the surgeons had one bad review out of all good reviews. The other one had no bad reviews at all. I had a minor surgery/decompression with one of them that was successful only for 4 months and then my symptoms came back. He's very likable guy has great reviews and would do the fusion but I am a little worried since the first time it didn't really stick. It's very hard to decide since I already have a relationship with him and I do like him. Can anyone identify with this kind of dilemma and share a way to choose which surgeon to work on me? I keep getting more recommendations also which you and makes it more complicated.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Spine Health Support Group.

Profile picture for annie1 @annie1

@jenniferhunter
Hi Jennifer yes that was me but two years ago who asked a lot of questions and then had the laminotomy only. You're saying to look up the surgeon's success rate but I don't know how to find that? That's not really public ly available as far as I have been able to see. Do you know a way to find that?

Jump to this post

@annie1 Medicare does publish success rate information for certain procedures (not all) for surgeons who accept Medicare and also similar rates for medical centers and hospitals. You also can check if a doctor has been disciplined by looking up the licensing board for the state. When I asked my surgeon his success rate for the procedure he recommended, he told me. They do know their statistics. Insurance companies also know this information or at least they know who the better surgeons are. You should look for medical publications they have authored. Ask your personal physician how they would look for a good surgeon.

REPLY
Profile picture for Jennifer, Volunteer Mentor @jenniferhunter

@annie1 Medicare does publish success rate information for certain procedures (not all) for surgeons who accept Medicare and also similar rates for medical centers and hospitals. You also can check if a doctor has been disciplined by looking up the licensing board for the state. When I asked my surgeon his success rate for the procedure he recommended, he told me. They do know their statistics. Insurance companies also know this information or at least they know who the better surgeons are. You should look for medical publications they have authored. Ask your personal physician how they would look for a good surgeon.

Jump to this post

@jenniferhunter
Ok, so I can call Medicare and tell them the surgeon's name and they can look up their success rate ? I met with a surgeon today from HSS who told me he has had No cases with complications. Someone else on here didn't think that was quite believable, but I will call Medicare and ask if they have any info on him.

REPLY
Profile picture for annie1 @annie1

@jenniferhunter
Ok, so I can call Medicare and tell them the surgeon's name and they can look up their success rate ? I met with a surgeon today from HSS who told me he has had No cases with complications. Someone else on here didn't think that was quite believable, but I will call Medicare and ask if they have any info on him.

Jump to this post

@annie1 I was referring to published lists from Medicare cases that are online. You’ll have to search for it because I don’t know how to copy a link since I am writing from my phone.

REPLY

Hi Jennifer,

Thanks so much, the only thing is how would I go about getting a list ? Just calling Medicare and telling them the name of the procedure and the Surgeon ? I always ask surgeons what percent of patients get successful results and/or what percent of relief do they think I will get and I have Never gotten a clear answer ! I've gotten everything from "I can't guarantee anything, but since you had temporary relief from the decompression, you should get good relief, " to I can't tell you a percentage. It's very frustrating. So you are saying that your surgeon told you his numbers ? I will have to push harder then.

REPLY

@annie1 my surgeon was Dr. McClendon at the Phoenix Mayo Clinic. I cannot say enough good about what he did to “fix” my back. He is amazing and all of my pre-surgery pain is gone. He is meticulous and takes such pride in helping us regain our lives and lessen the pain. He really cares.

REPLY

Thanks. I have osteoporosis which is a complicating factor for fusion. What did you have and what were your symptoms?

REPLY
Profile picture for sherrym25 @sherrym25

@annie1 my surgeon was Dr. McClendon at the Phoenix Mayo Clinic. I cannot say enough good about what he did to “fix” my back. He is amazing and all of my pre-surgery pain is gone. He is meticulous and takes such pride in helping us regain our lives and lessen the pain. He really cares.

Jump to this post

@sherrym25 Hi Sherry. Just to be certain, you went to Dr. Jamal McClendon at Phoenix Mayo Clinic?

REPLY
Profile picture for cori @ccchang

@sherrym25 Hi Sherry. Just to be certain, you went to Dr. Jamal McClendon at Phoenix Mayo Clinic?

Jump to this post

@ccchang
Hello everyone on this thread. So I have read that having osteoporosis can be a complicating factor with fusions. And I have osteoporosis. I've interviewed many surgeons and most of them say they can do it anyway but one guy was very cautious and he said to me I might have a bigger pain if I did fusion. Have anyone on this thread have osteoporosis and still have fusion including the person who saw Dr McClellan? I'm on osteoporosis medication but it's unclear how long I would have to be on it for my bones to be strong enough to hold any hardware. Thanks for any help

REPLY
Profile picture for cori @ccchang

@sherrym25 Hi Sherry. Just to be certain, you went to Dr. Jamal McClendon at Phoenix Mayo Clinic?

Jump to this post

@ccchang Hi Cori, yes that is correct. My surgeon was Dr. Jamal McClendon at the Phoenix Mayo Clinic.
Best, Sherry

REPLY
Profile picture for annie1 @annie1

Thanks. I have osteoporosis which is a complicating factor for fusion. What did you have and what were your symptoms?

Jump to this post

@annie1 I had a T11 to L4 fusion to correct my scoliosis curve. I did not have osteoporosis.
My symptoms were extreme back pain on the right side because my muscles were trying to keep my back straight and sciatica pain. I remember sitting in my surgeon’s office and he told me the surgery would fix my pain….and it did.
Best, Sherry

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.