Portable water filters for travel

Posted by kathyhg @kathyhg, Oct 28, 2024

I have a number of Lifestraw products and I feel pretty confident in them filtering out the mac from drinking water. One of the things that lifestraw doesn’t do is filter out minerals; I tried using a Lifestraw gravity filter to filter water before boiling my equipment and everything was covered with a fine white film, almost like powder. I emailed Lifestraw to see if any of their filter systems filter out minerals and they’ve said that they do not.

I’ve just heard about Sawyer water filter products and I read that they filter to 0.1 microns. Wondering is anyone has tried Sawyer filters? The benefit of filtering out the minerals is that the water is better for boiling equipment so that there is no film on everything, as a result of minerals in the water.

Thanks in advance to anyone who has experience with this (or other filtration) systems,

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the MAC & Bronchiectasis Support Group.

Profile picture for laureltn @laureltn

@kate2025 Here's a link to it. I've not personally used it in my kitchen because it doesn't work with my faucet.
https://www.sawyer.com/product/tap-water-filtration-system
Safe Water makes one for kitchens as well, but again, I haven't tried it because I have a kitchen faucet that has the larger head on it. (for this one, use the code NTM-25 if you purchase it).
https://waterfiltrationproducts.com/products/tap-safe-legionella-tap-filter

Jump to this post

@laureltn thank you!

REPLY

I live in a hard water area and use the Lifestraw pitcher for water which I use to boil/disinfect my Aerobika. I have not had trouble with a film. My hospital handout that came with the Aerobika suggested soaking it in 50/50 vinegar and water once a month to remove hard minerals. Sorry, don't know about the Sawyer filters.

REPLY
Profile picture for ana323 @ana323

@sueinmn yes, thank you Sue. I've reached out to Lifestraw and got an email that someone will get back to me in 5 to 7 business days.

Jump to this post

@ana323 I've never had it take that long honestly.

REPLY

Response from Lifestraw regarding their products.

Thank you for your thoughtful question.

LifeStraw Filter uses two types of filtration (apart from carbon) depending on the product:
Membrane microfilters (0.2 micron pore size) are used in products like the Home Pitcher, GO Bottle, and Collapsible Squeeze Bottle. These effectively remove bacteria, parasites, and microplastics. However, nontuberculous mycobacteria (NTM), including MAC, are smaller and not guaranteed to be removed by these filters.
Ultrafilters (0.02 micron) are used in some of our emergency and medical-grade products, offering additional protection down to virus-sized contaminants.
While third-party testing on the GO Bottle has shown potential NTM removal, this is not something we currently claim across all products.
The Home Pitcher microfilter should be replaced every year or 264 gallons, whichever comes first. Replacing more often will not increase removal of NTM if it isn’t already filtered by design.
You can view our lab reports and testing data on our Testing page under each product. If a contaminant is not listed, the filter has either not been tested for it or is not designed to remove it.
I hope this helps clarify things.

Kind Regards,

REPLY
Profile picture for ana323 @ana323

Response from Lifestraw regarding their products.

Thank you for your thoughtful question.

LifeStraw Filter uses two types of filtration (apart from carbon) depending on the product:
Membrane microfilters (0.2 micron pore size) are used in products like the Home Pitcher, GO Bottle, and Collapsible Squeeze Bottle. These effectively remove bacteria, parasites, and microplastics. However, nontuberculous mycobacteria (NTM), including MAC, are smaller and not guaranteed to be removed by these filters.
Ultrafilters (0.02 micron) are used in some of our emergency and medical-grade products, offering additional protection down to virus-sized contaminants.
While third-party testing on the GO Bottle has shown potential NTM removal, this is not something we currently claim across all products.
The Home Pitcher microfilter should be replaced every year or 264 gallons, whichever comes first. Replacing more often will not increase removal of NTM if it isn’t already filtered by design.
You can view our lab reports and testing data on our Testing page under each product. If a contaminant is not listed, the filter has either not been tested for it or is not designed to remove it.
I hope this helps clarify things.

Kind Regards,

Jump to this post

@ana323 Ana - This statement "...Membrane microfilters (0.2 micron pore size) are used in products like the Home Pitcher, GO Bottle, and Collapsible Squeeze Bottle. These effectively remove bacteria, parasites, and microplastics. However, nontuberculous mycobacteria (NTM), including MAC, are smaller and not guaranteed to be removed by these filters..." contradicts statements by our experts like Dr Joe Falkinham.
According to all of the testing, a .2 micron filter DOES remove NTM from water. That is why Pall brand filters and others are recommended.

My guess is that LifeStraw not making a statement about NTM removal probably a corporate liability decision driven by attorneys fearing lawsuits. This would be because once their product is in the hands of consumers, they have no idea how it will be used. Even the product warranty on their website has a variety of clauses limiting their liability - such is life in our world today.

REPLY
Profile picture for Sue, Volunteer Mentor @sueinmn

@ana323 - Did you see this post?

Jump to this post

@sueinmn and this is why I use lifestraw products!

REPLY
Profile picture for coffcoff @coffcoff

@sueinmn Awesome, but sounds complicated. Thanks for the reply.

Jump to this post

@coffcoff it's not really complicated - just have to maintain cleaning to keep filters in tip top shape.
Lots of cleaning no matter what we do with this disease for sure. Easy to add to my weekly and monthly chores. 😜

REPLY
Profile picture for laureltn @laureltn

Hi, there! As a long-distance hiker, we carried Sawyer Squeeze filters long before I ever found out I had bronchiectasis and MAC. They do require a little hand strength to squeeze the water from the catch bag to through the filter, but they work beautifully.

They do make a filter for attachment to a tap, which would be probably what you would want. We've not personally used it, but I can attest to Sawyer being quality stuff, at least the versions we've used for years on trails.

Laurel

Jump to this post

@laureltn I inquired to saeyer regarding the tap filter. They no longer make the tap filter unfortunately. They said it was due to lack of sales rather than not being effective. This makes me sad

REPLY
Profile picture for kate2025 @kate2025

@laureltn I inquired to saeyer regarding the tap filter. They no longer make the tap filter unfortunately. They said it was due to lack of sales rather than not being effective. This makes me sad

Jump to this post

@kate2025 Aw, I'm sorry to hear that as well. I will say that I've had very good luck working with Chris, the founder of Safe Water Products, on filters for my shower at home and in our travel trailer. You may want to give their kitchen faucet filter a try.

Good luck!
Laurel

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.