Has anyone treated their osteoporosis without drugs?

Posted by hemigal04 @hemigal04, Sep 20 4:43pm

Hello all … I am a 68 y/o lady, 5’1 and 115lbs. I have always been petite and of small stature. I recently went to a new physician who ran a battery of tests on me, which all came back great, except for my Dexa scan which came back with a T score of -3.8. The physician immediately wanted to write me a script for Fosamax. After reading about it, I am freaked out. Here’s a bit of background on me. I have never smoked, don’t drink and am fairly active. I still work part-time and love being active. Have any of you tried to combat osteoporosis from a “natural” healing angle? I have NEVER taken any meds, gosh I never even have the need for aspirin, as I don’t experience headaches. Looking for some input from actual people. It’s way too easy for a physician to write a script as I truly believe they are in cahoots with the pharmaceutical industry. My apologies if I have upset anyone. Any information, experience or feedback you can offer is greatly appreciated. Thank you for reading my post.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Osteoporosis & Bone Health Support Group.

Profile picture for nycmusic @nycmusic

So many of us, like you, are not into meds, only taking ones very necessary…my docs all agree that exercise that addresses OP issues,in addition to walking, etc. is key…paying attention to calcium and vitamin D in diet does help…my cancer team, PCP and osteopath all agree that taking a combo supplement can also be helpful … I researched, looking for plant-based, organic and 3rd party tested and found a few. Gave the exact lists of ingredients/amounts to docs to review and approve…I will be taking PT for OP at NYPresbyterian to get maximum benefit from the exercises. And I love my walks and simple, self-created dancercise at home. Yes, it’s effort, and each person needs to find their own best path, and then try to put worries off to the side.

Jump to this post

@nycmusic Hi, I wish you best with your more natural approach. I am doing the same. I’ve been to PT, as well, and am returning again soon for the “next phase” to increase the weights. I eat a whole-food planted based diet, so I’d also like to know what plant-based supplements you’ve found, if you don’t mind sharing that? I agree, it’s best to commit to lifestyle changes, and then try not to worry about it! When I was first diagnosed, I have to admit, I was a royal mess! I’m better now. It takes time to adjust to the “news” of having osteoporosis.

REPLY
Profile picture for lilac2025 @lilac2025

@nycmusic Hi, I wish you best with your more natural approach. I am doing the same. I’ve been to PT, as well, and am returning again soon for the “next phase” to increase the weights. I eat a whole-food planted based diet, so I’d also like to know what plant-based supplements you’ve found, if you don’t mind sharing that? I agree, it’s best to commit to lifestyle changes, and then try not to worry about it! When I was first diagnosed, I have to admit, I was a royal mess! I’m better now. It takes time to adjust to the “news” of having osteoporosis.

Jump to this post

@lilac2025 hello lilac, we share similar feelings and goals…I tried AlgaeCalPlus, but the magnesium in it gave me loose stools, not good for me, as I had CRC last year and must listen closely to my GI system… I have some New Chapter tint tabs, so I can adjust the dosage better… still searching…ConsumerLabs may be of help to you…I’ll let you whatever good things I discover in my continuing research…good luck !

REPLY
Profile picture for gently @gently

rockettgirl,
sure.
Prolia is the strongest of these medications. It can have terrible side effects, but some people have none. It is difficult to stop taking it because of how it works. It stops the cells that breakdown bone, but doesn't destroy them. It stops them just before their release and collects them. When you stop Prolia, this collection of cells come after your bones. You can't stop or even be late for your injections. When you stop you are usually prescribed Reclast.
Reclast stops the cells that breakdown down bone. It prevents them from attaching to the bone and these cells fall away and self destruct. It is usually a yearly injection. Some few people have terrible side effects, but most have achy joints and some people have no side effects. This drug is less strong than Prolia, but stronger than the third medication Fosamax.
Fosamax is the same class of drug as Reclast and works in the same way. They are both bisphosphonates.
Because it is an oral medication it isn't as strong as Reclast. And can cause reflux as it acidic. Many people have mild side effects with Fosamax. It is a daily or weekly oral dose it leaves your body more quickly than Prolia or Reclast, so the side effects are less intense when they occur and you don't suffer as long.
There are medications that you haven't been offered.
One is Evenity. Evenity is the same class drug as Prolia. It has a black box for cardiac issues. It has proven to add bone faster than the other medications. It is the latest and is proving very popular among endocrinologists because of the added bone. It is a double injection every month. Most have arm swelling and many have joint pain. But some don't. The use of Evenity is limited to one year. There are scattered accounts of successful two year administrations.
Finally there are my two favorites Tymlos and Forteo. They work the way our bodies naturally work to increase bone density and quality. They increase the cells that produce bone and they increase the cells that dissolve bone. Now the cells that dissolve bone are important because they are attracted to bone that is weak or fissured. And they remove that bone. They encourage the cells that produce new bone. They work as a unit
The process is slower than laying new bone over fissured bone. Both drugs are self administered as a daily injection. Some people have adverse reactions, but usually only briefly because the drug leaves your system within 24 hours.
Their use is generally for two years, but increasingly endocrinologist are expanding their use. I've been on Forteo without any side effects for over two years and plan on staying on it.
So, I'd recommend that you call the PA and ask for script for Forteo.
If that proves impossible, my choice of the three medications offered would be Reclast with a lower dose than the 5mg, a slower more dilute infusion than the standard 15 minute, and I'd hope that the medication would help for two years ( as it often does) instead of one year.
I would also ask for bone markers--CTX and P1NP to ascertain that the medication I chose was working for me.
I'm happy to field any questions and hope you get more and different opinions from other good people on this site.

Jump to this post

@gently thanks a ton ! I'm so grateful to this community for all the generous sharing of information and guidance .. I discovered my T score of - 3.5 - CTx - 850 & P1NP of 85..now trying to do research and had decided on the combo of forteo first and then fosamax .. after watching dr doug's video and the horrific side effects of fosamax of some people [rare but possible] i'm so scared.. In my city kolkata [India] I'm not sure how well the doctors really understand this disease and it's treatment..pl give ur opinion too as u have researched very thoroughly

REPLY
Profile picture for script72 @script72

I ordered from Amazon. Here are details.
COMFIER Back Massager Seat Cushion w/heat, 10 vibration motors. $53.99.

I turn on power, select upper back, lower back, seat and select high intensity. I do 30-minutes in chair while watching TV!

Google Osteogenic Loading.
My T-scores range from -2.1 to -2.8 in the various regions.

All the best as we navigate this osteoporosis journey.

Jump to this post

@script72 thanks a ton for taking out time to share the complete details

REPLY
Profile picture for nycmusic @nycmusic

@lilac2025 hello lilac, we share similar feelings and goals…I tried AlgaeCalPlus, but the magnesium in it gave me loose stools, not good for me, as I had CRC last year and must listen closely to my GI system… I have some New Chapter tint tabs, so I can adjust the dosage better… still searching…ConsumerLabs may be of help to you…I’ll let you whatever good things I discover in my continuing research…good luck !

Jump to this post

@nycmusic -correction—tiny tabs, not ‘’tint’’ ! There are 6 so that gives a range of dosages…

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.