Forteo (teriparatide) followed by HRT: My Experience

Posted by mayblin @mayblin, Sep 29 11:44am

I wanted to start a thread sharing my experience with Forteo → HRT, since this treatment sequence is less discussed but may be very helpful for other women navigating osteoporosis.

I was diagnosed with osteoporosis at age 59. My lowest T-score was –3.4 at the lumbar spine, with hip and femoral neck in the osteopenia/borderline osteoporosis range. My endocrinologist ruled out secondary causes. Without a family history, postmenopausal estrogen deficiency seemed the most likely contributor, though low BMI, protein intake, and activity level/type may have played a role.

Shortly after diagnosis, I improved my diet and added weight-bearing exercise. I started Forteo (teriparatide) within a few months and continued for 22 months. P1NP was 137 µg/L at the end of Forteo.

At age 61 (11 years postmenopausal), I transitioned to HRT: transdermal estradiol 0.025 mg/day patches plus oral micronized progesterone 100 mg/day. It’s now been 15 months on HRT. CTX stayed 110–130 pg/mL after 6mo starting HRT.

Since the start of Forteo to 15 months on HRT, my results have improved as follows:
• Lumbar spine T-score: –3.4 to –1.9
• Total hip T-score: –2.2 to –1.7
• Femoral neck T-score: –2.5 to –1.8
• TBS: 1.264 to 1.34

All DXA scans were performed on the same machine by the same technician. Detailed DXA results, including percent changes from previous scans and baseline, T-scores, and TBS values, are presented in the attached spreadsheet if anyone is interested.

Between my last two DXA scans, I also used three leftover Forteo pens with off-label dosing.

Note: I use the term “HRT” because it’s widely recognized. In medical literature, “MHT” (menopausal hormone therapy) is the standard term. In my case, I used regulated, body-identical estradiol and micronized progesterone, sometimes referred to as bHRT.

Thanks for reading! I would love to hear your thoughts, experiences, and insights. Also please feel free to ask any questions.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Osteoporosis & Bone Health Support Group.

Profile picture for singingbones @singingbones

How did you determine dosage of HRT? I've been on bio-identical HRT for many yrs, but never with bone health in mind...except for now. It causes me think that my dosage may need to be increased with a diagnosis of OP.

Jump to this post

@singingbones

Great question! I’ll chime in with my thoughts but I’m also curious to hear how others figured out their dose.

For me, the main goal was to use estrogen’s antiresorptive effects for maintaining bone density after Forteo. My doctor kept an eye on bone resorption markers to make sure the dose was actually doing its job. I also requested an earlier DXA scan for assurance.

REPLY
Profile picture for mayblin @mayblin

@gravity3 You’re right to wonder about using Fosamax again after 5 years of prior exposure. In my view, Reclast is essentially equivalent to additional years on Fosamax in terms of bisphosphonate exposure at this point, but it’s always best to confirm with your endocrinologist.

In your case, your prior Fosamax use and ongoing HRT both could help lower rebound risk after stopping Prolia. The decision really comes down to balancing total bisphosphonate exposure, residual effect, HRT coverage, dosing flexibility, and practical factors - Reclast works quickly and reliably with a single infusion, while Fosamax takes longer to reach full effect and depends on how well it’s absorbed.

It’s worth bringing up the idea of monitoring CTX, since it can help confirm that the transition is going smoothly. And in case Fosamax alone isn’t enough, Reclast can always be used as a backup.

Jump to this post

@mayblin

Thanks for the information. I dont mind taking reclast. I will talk to him again about ctx monitoring and if he has a problem I will purchase it myself. Thanks again for your help.

REPLY

I just got my bone marker results back after 6 weeks of a 14mcg estradiol patch and 40 mcg Tymlos. On 4/29/25 my CTX was 912 and P1NP was 179 (I had just changed from Forteo to a half dose of Tymlos). Now my CTX is 654 and my P1NP is 147. I am pleased that my CTX has gone down and I think the ratio is better? @mayblin is this a better ratio?

REPLY
Profile picture for drsuefowler @drsuefowler

I just got my bone marker results back after 6 weeks of a 14mcg estradiol patch and 40 mcg Tymlos. On 4/29/25 my CTX was 912 and P1NP was 179 (I had just changed from Forteo to a half dose of Tymlos). Now my CTX is 654 and my P1NP is 147. I am pleased that my CTX has gone down and I think the ratio is better? @mayblin is this a better ratio?

Jump to this post

@drsuefowler

That’s looking really good! Both markers have come down since you started HRT, which makes sense given estrogen’s antiresorptive effect. The greater percentage drop in CTX compared with P1NP suggests less resorption relative to formation - a positive shift toward anabolic activity.

It’ll be interesting to see whether the markers stay stable or continue to trend down as HRT reaches its full effect over the next few months.

How long are you planning to stay on Tymlos?

REPLY
Profile picture for mayblin @mayblin

@drsuefowler

That’s looking really good! Both markers have come down since you started HRT, which makes sense given estrogen’s antiresorptive effect. The greater percentage drop in CTX compared with P1NP suggests less resorption relative to formation - a positive shift toward anabolic activity.

It’ll be interesting to see whether the markers stay stable or continue to trend down as HRT reaches its full effect over the next few months.

How long are you planning to stay on Tymlos?

Jump to this post

@mayblin, thanks for your response. I have enough Tymlos to probably take half a dose until the end of February. I have appointments with my 2 endocrinologists this month. They will not be happy with me going my own way, but I am interested in their opinions. I hope I don't get fired!

REPLY

I had similar positive results with Teriparatide. After Teriparatide I went on Raloxifene (Evista) for 2 years. I’m post menopause 13 years. My gyno had me stay on the birth control pill until 55years old.
I just convinced her to prescribe HRT for me based on the positive data for bones. I didn’t have any issues with Raloxifene and it is an estrogen receptor drug. I just wanted to take something closer to what my body produces naturally. Overall I’m in great health. Plus there are other positive benefits to HRT.
However, the controversial dementia studies do have me pause at times. Raloxifene doesn’t state dementia as a risk.
Any thoughts?

REPLY
Profile picture for hansens @hansens

I had similar positive results with Teriparatide. After Teriparatide I went on Raloxifene (Evista) for 2 years. I’m post menopause 13 years. My gyno had me stay on the birth control pill until 55years old.
I just convinced her to prescribe HRT for me based on the positive data for bones. I didn’t have any issues with Raloxifene and it is an estrogen receptor drug. I just wanted to take something closer to what my body produces naturally. Overall I’m in great health. Plus there are other positive benefits to HRT.
However, the controversial dementia studies do have me pause at times. Raloxifene doesn’t state dementia as a risk.
Any thoughts?

Jump to this post

The dementia risk with HRT really depends on formulation, route, dose, age at start, and duration of use, among other factors. The WHI Memory Study - the largest randomized clinical trial (RCT) - linked oral conjugated equine estrogens (CEE) plus synthetic progestins (MPA, medroxyprogesterone acetate) to higher dementia risk, but that’s a very different regimen from the preferred transdermal estradiol with micronized progesterone used nowadays. The only RCT I’ve come across on that combo, KEEPS-Cog, found no cognitive harm, though it only studied early starters and short-term use (about 4 years). I think it’s fair to say the exact dementia risk with this bioidentical regimen remains unknown. I’m personally choosing to take that small, unquantified risk and keep reassessing as new data emerge, since osteoporosis is 100% my reality now.

REPLY
Profile picture for mayblin @mayblin

The dementia risk with HRT really depends on formulation, route, dose, age at start, and duration of use, among other factors. The WHI Memory Study - the largest randomized clinical trial (RCT) - linked oral conjugated equine estrogens (CEE) plus synthetic progestins (MPA, medroxyprogesterone acetate) to higher dementia risk, but that’s a very different regimen from the preferred transdermal estradiol with micronized progesterone used nowadays. The only RCT I’ve come across on that combo, KEEPS-Cog, found no cognitive harm, though it only studied early starters and short-term use (about 4 years). I think it’s fair to say the exact dementia risk with this bioidentical regimen remains unknown. I’m personally choosing to take that small, unquantified risk and keep reassessing as new data emerge, since osteoporosis is 100% my reality now.

Jump to this post

@mayblin Thank you! This is such a tough decision and it is keeping me up at night…. Do I continue the HRT course or go back to Raloxifene….

REPLY
Profile picture for hansens @hansens

@mayblin Thank you! This is such a tough decision and it is keeping me up at night…. Do I continue the HRT course or go back to Raloxifene….

Jump to this post

@hansens

I understand and share your concern. While there are no solid RCT data to assess absolute dementia risk for women starting transdermal estradiol + progesterone later in life, a recent large observational study published in Menopause (2024) provides some useful insight:
https://journals.lww.com/menopausejournal/fulltext/2024/05000/use_of_menopausal_hormone_therapy_beyond_age_65.3.aspx
This study examined various menopausal hormone therapy (MHT) formulations in women over 65 and found that transdermal estradiol combined with progesterone was not associated with an increased risk of dementia. Low-dose, non-oral formulations generally showed the most favorable outcomes (Table 4).

While this is observational data, not a randomized trial, it’s somewhat reassuring that this formulation did not show an increased signal for dementia.

REPLY
Profile picture for hansens @hansens

I had similar positive results with Teriparatide. After Teriparatide I went on Raloxifene (Evista) for 2 years. I’m post menopause 13 years. My gyno had me stay on the birth control pill until 55years old.
I just convinced her to prescribe HRT for me based on the positive data for bones. I didn’t have any issues with Raloxifene and it is an estrogen receptor drug. I just wanted to take something closer to what my body produces naturally. Overall I’m in great health. Plus there are other positive benefits to HRT.
However, the controversial dementia studies do have me pause at times. Raloxifene doesn’t state dementia as a risk.
Any thoughts?

Jump to this post

@hansens Are you monitoring your progress with bone density scans? I stayed on Raloxifene for 5 years with no problem and hope to return to it again after this course of Teriparatide.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.