@california14 - Facing stage 3b colon cancer is tough, and it’s understandable to feel frustrated that your oncologists at an NCI-designated cancer center aren’t using the Signatera ctDNA test, especially given its reported 88% sensitivity for detecting colorectal cancer recurrence. Studies like the GALAXY arm of CIRCULATE-Japan show Signatera’s ability to predict recurrence risk and guide adjuvant chemotherapy, with ctDNA-positive patients at higher risk (HR 10.82). These studies show that the most important test is 30 days post-surgery to check for any residual disease. However, some oncologists hesitate due to rare false positives (1.9% spontaneous clearance) or ongoing trials (e.g., CIRCULATE-US) refining its role.
Your proactive advocacy is powerful—self-education is key. Ask your oncologist why they don’t use Signatera, is it because they consider your CRC is considered low risk? Is CT DNA testing not typically part of the treatment plan? Remember Signatera is not the only CTDNA test available, Oncodetect from Exact Sciences, and Guardant 360 are also utilized by many institutions. Would you like more information about these to discuss with your oncology team?
Request clarity on their surveillance plan (e.g., CEA, CT scans) and if ctDNA could complement it. Cancer care can feel unpredictable, but your voice matters. Consider a second opinion from another NCI center or ask to discuss trials like DYNAMIC-III to explore ctDNA-guided care. You’re not alone—keep asking questions, and lean on support groups for strength.
Thank you very much for all of the information you provided. I guess since the CEA number is a particularly reliable source of cancer/recurrence in colon cancer, that is what this particular NCI-designated cancer center utilizes for post treatment surveillance along with other blood work and annual CT scans.
I know that another, non NCI designated but major medical center in the same city does use the ctdna test. It is disconcerting though, that recommendations vary and I will consider getting another opinion from another NCI-designated cancer center. I think the reason my oncologist does not use the ctdna test at this time is related to the level of research that has been done for its use (that's my recollection of what he said). Thank you again for the resources you provided; I greatly appreciate it.