What is minimum period of Alendronate to minimise Prolia rebound?

Posted by surefire @surefire, Jan 14, 2024

I started on Prolia in July 2022 on advice from my doctor that the treatment would be for only 4-5 years and thereafter I could stop. I have taken 3 Prolia injections, the last one in July 2023.

Before my 4th injection in Jan 2024, I started doing a lot of reading and decided that I do not want to be on any osteoporosis drug at all. So, instead of taking my 4th Prolia injection and to minimise the rebound effect from stopping Prolia, I started on a weekly dose of Alendronate.

However, I am really not comfortable taking Alendronate as well and would like to seek any advice/opinion on whether I am stuck with taking Alendronate for the next 6, 12 or even 24 months.

What is the shortest period I can be on Alendronate? Or should I just risk the rebound effect and stop my Alendronate now (I have taken 3 weekly doses so far)?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Osteoporosis & Bone Health Support Group.

I am fairly new here and I am at the same exact spot where you were when you asked this question. I am curious as to what your decision was and where you are at in this stage. I am in good physical shape and exercise daily for 1 hour or more. I would like to stop as well . I would like to know how you are doing.

REPLY

Also in the same boat, so please let us know your experience and hope.

REPLY
@rjd

Reading your recent post made me feel like it came from my alter-ego. I also need an answer to this question and do not feel I can rely on my primary care doctor.

In May 2023, after only 2 Prolia injections, my DEXA showed astonishing improvement at the hip (had no vertebral OP dx and had been on Fosomax for at least 5 years). My doctor said he would take me off Prolia (and it would no longer be covered by insurance, in any event) and that it was OK to do this cold turkey. I pushed back because of the valuable info I obtained here but he resisted.

I researched the issue and found this summaryhttps://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9081316/. I sent this to my doctor and he agreed to put me on Fosomax for 1 year as a step-down. I do not know whether this is the correct time frame but I do know I do not trust my doctor's judgment and tried to find an endocrinologist, unsuccessfully.

Perhaps it will be of help to you and we can somehow figure this out together.

Jump to this post

what ended up happening ? Did you stay on Fosamax and did it prevent rebound fractures?

REPLY
@jpareti1

what ended up happening ? Did you stay on Fosamax and did it prevent rebound fractures?

Jump to this post

I stayed on Fosamax post-Prolia and am still on it but only half a dose. Expect to stop entirely this May after 2 years, when I will get a Dexa scan also after 2 years of flying almost blind. I have had no fractures. My blood turnover markers are OK....not as great as I might like but OK.

My situation is considerably different from what I understand about yours. I took only 2 Prolia injections before my bone density improved significantly and stopped Prolia. If I had been on Prolia for 5 years, like you, and based on what I have learned the past few years, I would question whether Fosamax is powerful enough to counter rebound. If I had fractured like you, I would look at taking a bone builder.

The very best Connect thread discussing getting off Prolia is called 'Support for those quitting Prolia.' It contains extensive, well-reasoned discussions with supporting info/studies.

And the very best deep-dive info about OP is a book entitled 'Great Bones' by Keith McCormick.

Finally, I hope you will educate yourself about the use of blood tests (blood turnover markers) that might be helpful with trying to figure out your continued risk of rebound fracture and whether the path you choose is actually working.

Best of luck to you and I hope you can prevent any further fractures.

REPLY

I have a similar situation. I started Prolia (2 injections ) on the 2nd shot I developed a rash & infection. I was out in Alendronate ( now on my 8 th week.). I do t like some of the side effects & want to stop as well. Other than osteoporosis , I am healthy and I exercise and walk every day. I see my dr (ra) in 4 more weeks. I know he’s going to tell me to stay on something but I’m stressed out also.

REPLY
@hmbrglr

I have a similar situation. I started Prolia (2 injections ) on the 2nd shot I developed a rash & infection. I was out in Alendronate ( now on my 8 th week.). I do t like some of the side effects & want to stop as well. Other than osteoporosis , I am healthy and I exercise and walk every day. I see my dr (ra) in 4 more weeks. I know he’s going to tell me to stay on something but I’m stressed out also.

Jump to this post

I have been on alendronate and have not mad any gains in 3 years. I’m beyond disappointed. Don’t like taking it. Looking and waiting to get into a new dr who deals with this to learn and try other treatments. However they all freak me out

REPLY
@bocabird

Just read your post from January re: Prolia reactions. I too was talked into Prolia by 3 Doctors-giving me scare tactics that I would have fractures and need my bones cemented back. TERRIBLE!! I am entering my 5 th month of Prolia with tons of side effects-namely flu like symptoms for one week after initial dose, cracking of joints doing yoga, bleeding inflamed gums (Which I NEVER HAD) water retention and the list goes on and on BUT most importantly I was NEVER informed that I could not go off Prolia cold turkey. At least I only have one injection but that too I can have spinal fractures. I am in exceptional physical shape-75 -exercise about 14 hours a week and my readings are not horrible--2.9 is the worst -everything about normal. Shame on the Doctors for not giving full disclosure of the side effects and the rebound effect if not followed up with another shot. My Doc wants me to go on actonel after this. And by he way the Prolia injection is $2,400 a shot. Good money for all involved.

Jump to this post

I can't believe the cost you paid for one injection. It is quite disgusting that the pharmaceutical industry makes billion dollars of profits when we need these medications. A fair price we could cope with. You had better look at Dr Aseem Malhotra movie 'First Do No Pharm' that shows the true picture of the Pharmaceutical companies. Dr Aseem may soon be working in America with Kennedy to reduce Obesity. I think Kennedy will need our Dr Aseem. Good luck to all of us who have been affected by these giant money making Pharmaceutical companies.

REPLY

Did you have a Rebound effect, fractures etc as l am stopping Prolia and going on to alendronate but l am not sure it is powerful enough to prevent the rebound effect of fractures

REPLY
@victor5211

I can't believe the cost you paid for one injection. It is quite disgusting that the pharmaceutical industry makes billion dollars of profits when we need these medications. A fair price we could cope with. You had better look at Dr Aseem Malhotra movie 'First Do No Pharm' that shows the true picture of the Pharmaceutical companies. Dr Aseem may soon be working in America with Kennedy to reduce Obesity. I think Kennedy will need our Dr Aseem. Good luck to all of us who have been affected by these giant money making Pharmaceutical companies.

Jump to this post

The current administration supports policies which support deregulation and increased corporate profit at the expense of consumer protection.

REPLY

I have been on Prolia for severe Osteoporosis for 6 years. The side affects over the last 2 have included increased bone and joint pain, abdominal pain, fatigue, muscle spasms and rashes. The last 2 injections, these side affects lasted on and off for 3 months. My endocrinologist never told me I had to be in it for life. When I told him about them in office with tears, his response was not to let the patients in the waiting room see me cry.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.