← Return to Trying to choose supplements carefully

Discussion

Trying to choose supplements carefully

Osteoporosis & Bone Health | Last Active: Jan 2 11:19am | Replies (53)

Comment receiving replies
@normahorn

A woman I know reported this on a non-medical board and I am still scratching my head over the calcium comments. I have no idea if these are real Canadian doctors on just play ones. Can anyone provide a basis for the calcium claims that may have been misconstrued?

"while watching a video produced by two Canadian doctors on how to strengthen your bones. Recommendations were to wear a weighted vest, because carrying weight builds bone, doing weight bearing exercises like walking, eating healthily, taking vitamin D, taking supplements such as magnesium and zinc (but they considered zinc less necessary. They reiterated that taking calcium can deplete calcium, and said just to eat food with calcium that wasn't dairy."

Jump to this post


Replies to "A woman I know reported this on a non-medical board and I am still scratching my..."

That’s not something I’ve ever heard of and I couldn’t find any research that indicates that taking calcium supplements can decrease your calcium levels.

I aim for 1200 mg per day from food and supplementing if I don’t get there. Most days I am very close, so I take one pill (250 mg of calcium citrate) to ensure I hit 250 mg. I used to take much more but have cut back.

I saw an MD specialist. She had no problems with dairy calcium. In fact, she said she preferred food calcium to supplement calcium, but calcium regardless. My MD specialist thought it dangerous for me to wear weights on my back, as I have osteo in my spine. Vit D is a yes, weight-bearing exercise, various ones, is a yes. Medication is a yes. My understanding is that once on the osteo slope, all you can do is slow, or if lucky stop, the decline. And of course, falling down is out of the question, so activities or weather with that risk needs to be approached with caution. I am on medication too, BTW. Go to the good sources of information rather than random advice.