Anyone drank black tea for many years, developed mental health issues?

Posted by robertwills @robertwills, Nov 13 7:52pm

Or do you know of anyone who drank black tea, like a cup or two, for decades and developed mental health or any negative health issues as a direct result?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Aging Well Support Group.

@robertwills

That's why I was asking for personal accounts. Many studies are biased and/or funded by others with economic interests. Many studies are pure lies or incompetence or nuts. There is a study contained in the NIH library done by a Chinese research organization I believe that concluded that tea can, or may. prevent and cure Covid-19! Good grief! No wonder the NIH has a disclaimer.

There is one case that I know of where a worldwide industry was propagandized for political purposes - to get the masses to believe something they wanted, true or not. Thankfully I believe the world is getting smarter and smarter, even though it may not seem like it at times.

The English writer I referenced was not, I believe, a doctor, but a famous or prominent observer of mankind. Often these kinds of people get things right, that's why they are famous. I believe there may be something to what was said about tea.

Jump to this post

I'm curious....why do you have this suspicion?

REPLY
@gloaming

I'm curious....why do you have this suspicion?

Jump to this post

For a number of reasons. There are drugs and other substances in tea, one obviously is caffeine but I believe there are others whose effects may not be known well or known at all. The effects of tea are noticeably different from coffee. It's not just stimulating.

From the English writing that I referenced. To me it sounded like there was something there, particularly given my personal experience. Dullness, I believe they may have used the term "dullard" to refer to a habitual tea drinker.

The fact that billions of people daily take tea that means a lot of economic interests are at stake. This can cause propaganda, some very obviously dumb, but some in a very sophisticated way to maintain those economic interests. The Chinese study I referenced is an example of dumb propaganda. There's no way that drinking tea can prevent or cure Covid-19. Did they think people would believe that? The NIH has a disclaimer on this study but still why they have it in their library is a mystery.

I am in no way saying that I believe tea has negative effects. I'm just seeing if anyone has any personal accounts of them.

REPLY

I quit coffee as too acidic for stomach- medications. Have been drinking black tea- hot for a couple years- now iced everyday. Not necessarily for caffeine but not as acidic as coffee. Haven’t noticed and issues.

REPLY

I've always heard of the benefits of black tea. But, I decided to inquire via google AI. Here's what I found: "Drinking large amounts of black tea -- more than four or five cups a day -- may cause health problems. That's mostly because of caffeine-related side effects. Side effects of black tea (most often in high amounts) may include: Anxiety and difficulty sleeping. " Aug 21, 2024

Seems feasible, depending upon one's tolerance. My motto: Everything in moderation is the safest and most sensible way to avoid the possibility of a negative outcome.

REPLY
@equanimous

I've always heard of the benefits of black tea. But, I decided to inquire via google AI. Here's what I found: "Drinking large amounts of black tea -- more than four or five cups a day -- may cause health problems. That's mostly because of caffeine-related side effects. Side effects of black tea (most often in high amounts) may include: Anxiety and difficulty sleeping. " Aug 21, 2024

Seems feasible, depending upon one's tolerance. My motto: Everything in moderation is the safest and most sensible way to avoid the possibility of a negative outcome.

Jump to this post

In my experience not everything should in moderation, like alcohol. I know people who drank in moderation and ended up with major health problems at a relatively young age, like below upper 50's and as low as in the early 40's. as a direct result. Just "a couple of drinks" a night is all it takes. Not to mention all the trouble that alcohol brought on them and theor family, such as accidents, fights, lost jobs, etc..

REPLY

I have been drinking tea for over 60 years. I would say I don't think there is a problem for the illness described.

REPLY
@robertwills

Yes. I read somewhere, I can't find it now, where some famous English writer or observer of mankind, in the 19th century wrote to the effect "Tea drinking causes one to become a dullard". I have not found any other literature or studies on the matter so thought I would start with any personal experiences.

Jump to this post

It is possible that "Tea drinking" isn't referring to the chemical effects of tea but the manner in which it was consumed in English society. As someone who enjoys relaxing with friends around a pot of hot tea, I can say that if I indulged in that activity daily, I'd get little done and could be accused of being a dullard.

REPLY
@diwalker

It is possible that "Tea drinking" isn't referring to the chemical effects of tea but the manner in which it was consumed in English society. As someone who enjoys relaxing with friends around a pot of hot tea, I can say that if I indulged in that activity daily, I'd get little done and could be accused of being a dullard.

Jump to this post

That's an interesting theory but the quote I read seemed to be about the chemical effects. It could be both.

I believe though that tea does in fact have a stimulant AND calming effect. The calming effect in particular may give drinkers a false sense of "everything is all right" and therefore not act as they would without tea. Over time, like a decade or more of daily drinking this permanently makes changes to a persons mental state and behavior. The hallmark is a dulling of the mental state. That's just purely a theory of mine.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.