1. < Osteoporosis & Bone Health

Transdermal HRT

Posted by vkmov @vkmov, Oct 19, 2023

Many studies have found that transdermal HRT protects and builds bone without all the horrific side effects of many first-line osteoporosis treatments. The patch bypasses the liver and thereby avoids the risks of breast cancer, strokes, etc. Has anyone explored this or discussed it with their doctors?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Osteoporosis & Bone Health Support Group.

pennykj | @pennykj | Sep 19 6:03am
In reply to @mayblin "Hi @pennykj , great to hear that your dxa held stable in the past year. May..." + (show)
@mayblin

Hi @pennykj , great to hear that your dxa held stable in the past year. May I ask the main reason that your obgyn advices against hrt in your case? Your reduction in ctx is remarkable. What do you think is the main contributing factor? Did you have your p1np tested as well? Thanks a lot!

Jump to this post

My gyn pretty much said that I was too old to start (too long past menopause). She thought there was a risk of blood clots. However, she said she would prescribe if I insisted and got clearance in writing from my cardiologist. My p1np was not retested in April 2024, but will be retested in 2025.
I have no idea what was the main contributing factor since I was doing so much (no alcohol, no caffeine, no sugar, Marodyne vibration plate, quality supplements, weight training, yoga, walking, protein powder, collagen, better sleep).

REPLY
1 reply
mayblin | @mayblin | Sep 19 8:41am
In reply to @pennykj "My gyn pretty much said that I was too old to start (too long past menopause)...." + (show)
@pennykj

My gyn pretty much said that I was too old to start (too long past menopause). She thought there was a risk of blood clots. However, she said she would prescribe if I insisted and got clearance in writing from my cardiologist. My p1np was not retested in April 2024, but will be retested in 2025.
I have no idea what was the main contributing factor since I was doing so much (no alcohol, no caffeine, no sugar, Marodyne vibration plate, quality supplements, weight training, yoga, walking, protein powder, collagen, better sleep).

Jump to this post

I see. Thank you for replying and sharing your secrets of success. Whatever you are doing is working great!

REPLY
newenglandtransplant | @newenglandtransplant | Nov 8 1:50pm
In reply to @hopefullibrarian "Hi mayblin, I'm starting on a very small dose of .05/0.14 mg per day with a..." + (show)
@hopefullibrarian

Hi mayblin, I'm starting on a very small dose of .05/0.14 mg per day with a plan to increase it gradually because I have epilepsy. My BTMs were tested in January, and will be done again next month. I'm also on Evenity, so it's being done primarily to monitor that. With the addition of HRT, I'm going to request it again for July. So, I guess, to answer your last question, the BTMs are being done every 3 months.

Jump to this post

Hi, @hopefullibrarian It looks like we have chosen a similar path. I had my first Evenity injections in October, and I started the .05 Estradiol patch the next day. I’m curious if you’ve had any bone marker tests since adding the HRT to the mix. If so, would you mind commenting on your results?

REPLY
1 reply
hopefullibrarian | @hopefullibrarian | 3 hours ago
In reply to @newenglandtransplant "Hi, @hopefullibrarian It looks like we have chosen a similar path. I had my first Evenity..." + (show)
@newenglandtransplant

Hi, @hopefullibrarian It looks like we have chosen a similar path. I had my first Evenity injections in October, and I started the .05 Estradiol patch the next day. I’m curious if you’ve had any bone marker tests since adding the HRT to the mix. If so, would you mind commenting on your results?

Jump to this post

Hi newenglandtransplant, I hope your Evenity treatment is going well and you're adapting well to the HRT. I've had baseline bone markers, and then every three months during the Evenity treatment. I'll put all of the test results here for comparison:

P1NP/CTx 11/115 (Jan 2024) 102/355 (Apr 2024) 119/531 (Jul 2024) 92/496 (Oct 2024)

A lot has happened since the last time I posted anything about my treatment and progress, so, while I'm at it, I'll bring things up-to-date.

On October 31st I had my 10th and last Evenity injections. I'm stopping treatment because my insurance policy is changing on Dec 1 making the treatment unaffordable going forward.

Next week I'm changing the HRT treatment to an estradiol patch, and prometrium (oral micronized progesterone). I changed gynos to one willing to prescribe higher does of HRTs to prevent bone loss.

Also next week, I'll be getting a Reclast infusion, 2.5mg accompanied by intraveneous hydration.
In March, I'll test my BTMs again to determine when to move on to the next step which will be Alendronate.

Because my Evenity treatment is over, I got another DEXA and it included TBS.

Chronology of DEXAs and treatments:
Jan 2023 - First DEXA : Spine = -3.7 ; Left femoral hip = -3.2
May 2023 - Prolia injection
Jan 2024 - First Evenity injections
Mar 2024 - Started HRTs (low dose CombiPatch)
Apr 2024 - DEXA: Results N/A. Unfortunately, the radiologist made a mistake.
Oct 2024 - Last Evenity injections (10th treatment)
Nov 2024 - DEXA: Spine = -2.1 ; Left femoral neck = -2.6
Nov 2024 - TBS = 1.265
TBS reference range
> 1.3 = Normal
1.20-1.29 = Borderline bone quality
1.00-1.19 = Impaired bone quality
< 1.00 = Significantly impaired bone quality

I am over the moon with my results, and my specialists are blown away. It's the best results they've seen in such a short space of time.

REPLY
View MoreView Less
Please sign in or register to post a reply.