What should I know before starting Evenity?

Posted by bevlevvancouverbc @bevlevvancouverbc, Sep 4 6:24pm

Sept 4th, 2024
EVENITY
Like many of you, I have started from shock, to fearfulness to being
apprehensive what medication to take for severe osteo.
My numbers are L -5.2 hips -3.6 and -4.0
I hoped to be able to improve the numbers with diet and exercise.
Eventually I realized that it might be possible with osteopenia
but probably not with severe osteoporosis. Dr Beck
Onero program is not available in Vancouver, yet.
I am trying to learn hip hinge and squats
eventually I will find a a physical therapist/kinesiologist
with osteoporosis experience.
I do the stairs as often as I can, increasing how many times:
until hopefully add ankle weights.
My threadmill speed is 2.2mph..the goal is to increase every few weeks:
method: increase, count 24 seconds - go back to starting baseline – several times:
the goal is 2.5mph which is maintenance: and the larger goal is 3.1mph
which is osteogenic.
Diet: aside from the calcium and and Vit D: am looking into natural
sources of Vit K (Natto is not something I could consume regularly).
and have 5-6 prunes daily.
So…have finally made the decision to go with Evenity, if approved.
Have not used anything in the past: anabolic or anti resorptive.
Thank you for ladies from Canada for mentioning CTX. It is available
in Vancouver (sorry I didn’t mark down names) P1NP and TBS is not available.
Neither is REMS. I got a CTX – which we pay out of pocket here, so is
Vit D out of pocket unless it’s requested by a specialist. And TBS is
not available either. My CTX was in the 500.
Would be glad to hear comments, or shared stories.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Osteoporosis & Bone Health Support Group.

@hopefullibrarian

Hi awfultruth,

Thank you for sharing this.
Just before I read your comment, I just so happened to be looking at the page on the Amgen site that the person in the Evenity Facebook group referred to: https://www.evenityproliahcp.com/evenity-to-prolia-transition

Like many of us on this forum, I'm considering what comes next for me post Evenity. The 12 months seems to be going pretty fast. I had my 9th injections almost 2 weeks ago. I'm trying to make sense of the research that's out there.

Unless I'm reading it wrong, on the chart you shared, it looks like BMD post Alendronate was the best. That's likely the result for patients who have only ever taken Alendronate. I'd like to read the full study, but it's behind a paywall. 🙁 Here's a link behind the paywall that I found for the study: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41574-018-0087-0

While I was searching for the chart online, it led me to something interesting that might be helpful for some of you. It's a summary from part of a 2018 meeting of the American Association of Clinical Endocrinology (AACE) International, Italian Chapter which compiles numerous studies on anabolic agents. It references the study containing the chart you provided as well as Dr. Ben Leder's research on combination and sequential therapies and many others. It brings together a lot of information in one place. For anyone who's interested, here's the link (the notes are in English): https://www.associazionemediciendocrinologi.it/images/eventi/congressi-nazionali/2018/relazioni/aace/2-bone/09_chiodini.pdf

Jump to this post

@hopefullibrarian Hi, I haven't digested your comment yet but here is a link to see the full version of the Advantages and Disadvantages .. paper.
https://sci-hub.st/10.1038/s41574-018-0087-0
sci-hub can be wonderful for older papers. At some point there was a crack down on their efforts to make these scientific papers available to everyone. Not sure what year that was but something like 2020. Before the crack down they had lots of journal papers that most of us could not access or afford to pay $30-$50 to read.

REPLY
@awfultruth

@gravity3 (and also @newenglandtransplant, @windyshores, and @normahorn) As you mention the Amgen - Prolia website does clearly state that a wait of 30 days plus or minus 7 days was used for the Frame study. "*In the FRAME study, Prolia® was initiated 1 month +/- 7 days from the last monthly dose of EVENITY®." So a period of 23-37 days was used.
From: https://www.evenityproliasa.com/evenity-to-prolia-transition

I tried yet again to find more info on how long after stopping Evenity before you go to the next med. I found no clear discussion of this. I looked at one or two studies that went beyond 1 year and had a follow up med after Evenity. Maybe I was just looking at the Frame study or the extension to it. Anyway I could not find a statement specifying a time period. What I did see is that there is an implication that a 1 month period after Evenity was used. The studies would specify months 1-12 and then 13-24 or endpoint 24 etc. If patients were taking the next med starting at any date other than the next month I believe it would have been specified because when you state months 1-24 it does imply that months 13-24 were on the follow up med. My unverified conclusion is that those studies were doing the next med at 1 month after the last Evenity shot.

That does not prove 1 month is ideal but it does show what we have data for. There may be no study data available for any other length of wait time?

And here's Amgen saying start follow up at 1 month.

Jump to this post

I remember feeling this way when I started on birth control and felt like a guinea pig ...
As I do now with osteoporosis meds.

REPLY
@maieva

I am 66 years old and have been on Reclast for two years with some improvement in my scores, although the second year my spine score went down. My endocrinologist at Mayo Clinic discussed Evenity and Tymlos and I think I am going to try Evenity since it is one year and convenient to go once a month to the clinic to get the injections. I had concerns about the black box warnings regarding heart attack and stroke, but she reassured me that she has not heard of anyone experiencing this. I also have an appointment with my cardiologist to see what he says before I start. I don’t know what else to do and yes, I’m very nervous about taking this drug, but I know it’s supposed to give me big gains in my spine where I need it the most. Any additional advice?

Jump to this post

My bone health specialist has recommended I start Evenity as I have osteoporosis & have had a spontaneous spine fracture.
I had bariatric surgery 18 years ago & suffer from malabsorption & despite taking 1,800 mg of liquid calcium citrate concurrently with 15,000 IU of liquid Vitamin D3 (split into 4 doses per day) & we can’t get my calcium levels up in the normal range. Evenity warnings specifically state not to administer to patients with low calcium levels so we keep trying by increasing calcium citrate & D3. I do not want to start Evenity until levels are normal. Has anyone else experienced this problem or can offer any advice? Thanks!

REPLY
@mancos

My bone health specialist has recommended I start Evenity as I have osteoporosis & have had a spontaneous spine fracture.
I had bariatric surgery 18 years ago & suffer from malabsorption & despite taking 1,800 mg of liquid calcium citrate concurrently with 15,000 IU of liquid Vitamin D3 (split into 4 doses per day) & we can’t get my calcium levels up in the normal range. Evenity warnings specifically state not to administer to patients with low calcium levels so we keep trying by increasing calcium citrate & D3. I do not want to start Evenity until levels are normal. Has anyone else experienced this problem or can offer any advice? Thanks!

Jump to this post

Wow that is a high dose of Vitamin D3 @manco! What is your current D3 level?

Maybe you could do Tymlos or Forteo since they raise calcium levels! At least for a few hours. Not sure what level is needed for those to work. What does your doctor say?

REPLY
@awfultruth

@hopefullibrarian Hi, I haven't digested your comment yet but here is a link to see the full version of the Advantages and Disadvantages .. paper.
https://sci-hub.st/10.1038/s41574-018-0087-0
sci-hub can be wonderful for older papers. At some point there was a crack down on their efforts to make these scientific papers available to everyone. Not sure what year that was but something like 2020. Before the crack down they had lots of journal papers that most of us could not access or afford to pay $30-$50 to read.

Jump to this post

awfultruth--This is awesome! Thank you so much. I have to bookmark that site.

REPLY
@hopefullibrarian

awfultruth--This is awesome! Thank you so much. I have to bookmark that site.

Jump to this post

@hopefullibrarian Hey, glad you liked that. I was really excited when I first found Sci Hub. I had been disappointed for years being unable to see papers and research I would see referenced but could not look at.
Note that the url will change at times. I'm not sure what goes on but I envision a network of computer free spirits who think research should be available to all - and then organizations and governments who don't like that work together to shut them down. And then they spring up somewhere else. Always called sci hub .... it seems. As for as I know they are now limited in that they can't add new work. That said I don't know the details so I could have some of this wrong.

REPLY
@windyshores

Wow that is a high dose of Vitamin D3 @manco! What is your current D3 level?

Maybe you could do Tymlos or Forteo since they raise calcium levels! At least for a few hours. Not sure what level is needed for those to work. What does your doctor say?

Jump to this post

I thought it was very high, too. Last Vit D-Hydroxy on 8/5/24 was 35 ng/mL (normal range), but calcium was 7.8 mg/dL on 8/5/24 (low). Last calcium on 10/4/24 was a bit higher at 8.1 mg/dL, so calcium level does seem to be improving. I had been taking 1,500 mg of liquid calcium citrate when it was 7.8, now with the increased 1,800 mg of calcium it’s up to 8.1 (getting closer).
Doctors recommend Evenity for me. I have an upcoming appointment & will ask them again about Tymlos & Forteo.
Thanks for your feedback & reply, I appreciate it!

REPLY
@windyshores

@06111945cc if I ever got to -1.5 or -1.0 I would not take meds. As I wrote above there is natural bone loss after menopause. But with scores like that I personally would try natural approaches.

I will only have those scores in my dreams!

Jump to this post

Dear windyshores,

I agree.

On the other hand. I’m fearful .

You make me question whether or not it’s true that we can’t maintain bones naturally.

You suggest that we can maintain bones naturally. How do we do that?

What is your proposed plan?

cc

REPLY
@06111945cc

Dear windyshores,

I agree.

On the other hand. I’m fearful .

You make me question whether or not it’s true that we can’t maintain bones naturally.

You suggest that we can maintain bones naturally. How do we do that?

What is your proposed plan?

cc

Jump to this post

Personally I believe we will continue to lose bone after menopause but we can slow that loss with diet, exercise, supplements and generally reducing inflammation. If we are not in danger of fracture and have scores that are in a better range. Keith McCormick first wrote "A Holistic Approach to Osteoporosis," and his more recent book "Great Bones" is encyclopedic. Margaret Martin at melioguide.com is helpful on exercise. Talk to your doctor but at -1.5 or -1.0 I would not medicate but monitor closely. I believe many docs are not medicating osteopenia these days.

REPLY
@mancos

I thought it was very high, too. Last Vit D-Hydroxy on 8/5/24 was 35 ng/mL (normal range), but calcium was 7.8 mg/dL on 8/5/24 (low). Last calcium on 10/4/24 was a bit higher at 8.1 mg/dL, so calcium level does seem to be improving. I had been taking 1,500 mg of liquid calcium citrate when it was 7.8, now with the increased 1,800 mg of calcium it’s up to 8.1 (getting closer).
Doctors recommend Evenity for me. I have an upcoming appointment & will ask them again about Tymlos & Forteo.
Thanks for your feedback & reply, I appreciate it!

Jump to this post

@mancos one other thing to think about: I read that Tymlos "eats D3" and I kept mine stable at 50 or so by upping my intake to 3,000 units/day. When I stopped Tymlos my level started to rise so I backed down to 1,000-2,000 units depending on the season. I don't wear sun screen!

I cannot believe you take 15,000 units and your level is 35. Do you take a liquid, or gummy, or pill?

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.