Controlling type 2 diabetes with diet alone

Posted by chesterc @chesterc, Dec 12, 2017

I live in the UK and have recently been diagnosed type 2 diabetic. I have yet to start testing but have made an attempt at diet.
What are the chances of my being able to control my levels with diet alone?
The Mayo Clinic Connect was my pick as I enjoyed my visit at Rochester in 1959.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Diabetes & Endocrine System Support Group.

@gravity3

Also. Glucosegoddess.com

Jump to this post

I just saw her interview on Youtube. What are your thoughts about her research?

REPLY
@unionizer

I just saw her interview on Youtube. What are your thoughts about her research?

Jump to this post

I saw her in an interview on Diary of a CEO on YouTube. I have not read her books or seen her other interviews. She is new to me. In that Interview she made consistent disclaimers about her own studies of groups. When she was referring to formal research by others she convinced me that she was seeking ways to illuminate the conclusions and present in ways that helped us understand the what and why's and offer simple and easily understandable steps (hooray) to use. I've seen and read materials that have addressed the glucose issue before. I found her approach appealed to me. But I don't have the background to really comment on your question. I really rambled. What do you think?.

REPLY
@unionizer

I just saw her interview on Youtube. What are your thoughts about her research?

Jump to this post

I'm sorry to say that with diabetes, as with almost every other chronic disease, there is no "magic bullet" or one and done way to get control. I am fortunately blessed to have been bypassed by diabetes so far, but have lung, heart, inflammatory and pain issues that clamor for my attention every single day.
Looking at the Glucose Goddess Website, she cited over a dozen research studies - NONE have her name on them, nor her product in them. Can you cite her research specifically, because I could not find any on Google or in Google Scholar.

It seems she is more of a medias sensation than a scientist -
https://www.washingtonpost.com/style/of-interest/2024/08/07/glucose-goddess-jessie-inchauspe/
Her "bio" as a biochemist? "She attended graduate school at Georgetown University, where she earned a master’s degree in biochemistry, and worked as a product lead at 23andMe (they sell gene testing kits)"

Keep in mind, any studies she talks about are very small, may or may not meet basic research criteria, and may not have been conducted on people with diabetes.

What do the health researchers say? "Priya Tew, a specialist dietitian from the United Kingdom, says the supplement is unregulated and untested. While there is some evidence for some of the individual herbs, these have not been tested as a mixed supplement.
The evidence we do have is very low grade; a lot of it is small-scale studies and short-term research. The supplement is making claims that have not been properly tested, and we do not know the long-term impact of taking this," she tells Healthnews."
(https://healthnews.com/news/you-dont-need-supplements-to-reduce-glucose-spikes/)

Better to follow the plan suggested by Cheryl (@cehunt57) who has lived with diabetes her whole life. Tedious? You bet, EVERY day, proper diet, exercise, monitor glucose and medicate as needed.

What is your current management routine?

REPLY

Thanks for sharing.

REPLY
@sueinmn

I'm sorry to say that with diabetes, as with almost every other chronic disease, there is no "magic bullet" or one and done way to get control. I am fortunately blessed to have been bypassed by diabetes so far, but have lung, heart, inflammatory and pain issues that clamor for my attention every single day.
Looking at the Glucose Goddess Website, she cited over a dozen research studies - NONE have her name on them, nor her product in them. Can you cite her research specifically, because I could not find any on Google or in Google Scholar.

It seems she is more of a medias sensation than a scientist -
https://www.washingtonpost.com/style/of-interest/2024/08/07/glucose-goddess-jessie-inchauspe/
Her "bio" as a biochemist? "She attended graduate school at Georgetown University, where she earned a master’s degree in biochemistry, and worked as a product lead at 23andMe (they sell gene testing kits)"

Keep in mind, any studies she talks about are very small, may or may not meet basic research criteria, and may not have been conducted on people with diabetes.

What do the health researchers say? "Priya Tew, a specialist dietitian from the United Kingdom, says the supplement is unregulated and untested. While there is some evidence for some of the individual herbs, these have not been tested as a mixed supplement.
The evidence we do have is very low grade; a lot of it is small-scale studies and short-term research. The supplement is making claims that have not been properly tested, and we do not know the long-term impact of taking this," she tells Healthnews."
(https://healthnews.com/news/you-dont-need-supplements-to-reduce-glucose-spikes/)

Better to follow the plan suggested by Cheryl (@cehunt57) who has lived with diabetes her whole life. Tedious? You bet, EVERY day, proper diet, exercise, monitor glucose and medicate as needed.

What is your current management routine?

Jump to this post

Thank you for your detailed investigation of the “pitch” and the lack scientific research to support it. Also for providing links to published critiques you referred to.

REPLY
@sueinmn

I'm sorry to say that with diabetes, as with almost every other chronic disease, there is no "magic bullet" or one and done way to get control. I am fortunately blessed to have been bypassed by diabetes so far, but have lung, heart, inflammatory and pain issues that clamor for my attention every single day.
Looking at the Glucose Goddess Website, she cited over a dozen research studies - NONE have her name on them, nor her product in them. Can you cite her research specifically, because I could not find any on Google or in Google Scholar.

It seems she is more of a medias sensation than a scientist -
https://www.washingtonpost.com/style/of-interest/2024/08/07/glucose-goddess-jessie-inchauspe/
Her "bio" as a biochemist? "She attended graduate school at Georgetown University, where she earned a master’s degree in biochemistry, and worked as a product lead at 23andMe (they sell gene testing kits)"

Keep in mind, any studies she talks about are very small, may or may not meet basic research criteria, and may not have been conducted on people with diabetes.

What do the health researchers say? "Priya Tew, a specialist dietitian from the United Kingdom, says the supplement is unregulated and untested. While there is some evidence for some of the individual herbs, these have not been tested as a mixed supplement.
The evidence we do have is very low grade; a lot of it is small-scale studies and short-term research. The supplement is making claims that have not been properly tested, and we do not know the long-term impact of taking this," she tells Healthnews."
(https://healthnews.com/news/you-dont-need-supplements-to-reduce-glucose-spikes/)

Better to follow the plan suggested by Cheryl (@cehunt57) who has lived with diabetes her whole life. Tedious? You bet, EVERY day, proper diet, exercise, monitor glucose and medicate as needed.

What is your current management routine?

Jump to this post

Thanks for the info Sue. Very helpful.

REPLY

The simple answer to that is yes one can do it but it requires self discipline and a steely resolve to succeed the first and foremost thing is to cut down on carbs and eat healthy you can find lots of information on the net as well as there are apps to help calculate the glycemic index and load of all types of food alternatively you can take the help of a nutritionist and have a diet plan made for yourself while doing that it’s equally important to buy a glucometer and monitor your blood sugar levels all the best

REPLY

Dr. Caryn Zinn on low carb.

REPLY
@sueinmn

I'm sorry to say that with diabetes, as with almost every other chronic disease, there is no "magic bullet" or one and done way to get control. I am fortunately blessed to have been bypassed by diabetes so far, but have lung, heart, inflammatory and pain issues that clamor for my attention every single day.
Looking at the Glucose Goddess Website, she cited over a dozen research studies - NONE have her name on them, nor her product in them. Can you cite her research specifically, because I could not find any on Google or in Google Scholar.

It seems she is more of a medias sensation than a scientist -
https://www.washingtonpost.com/style/of-interest/2024/08/07/glucose-goddess-jessie-inchauspe/
Her "bio" as a biochemist? "She attended graduate school at Georgetown University, where she earned a master’s degree in biochemistry, and worked as a product lead at 23andMe (they sell gene testing kits)"

Keep in mind, any studies she talks about are very small, may or may not meet basic research criteria, and may not have been conducted on people with diabetes.

What do the health researchers say? "Priya Tew, a specialist dietitian from the United Kingdom, says the supplement is unregulated and untested. While there is some evidence for some of the individual herbs, these have not been tested as a mixed supplement.
The evidence we do have is very low grade; a lot of it is small-scale studies and short-term research. The supplement is making claims that have not been properly tested, and we do not know the long-term impact of taking this," she tells Healthnews."
(https://healthnews.com/news/you-dont-need-supplements-to-reduce-glucose-spikes/)

Better to follow the plan suggested by Cheryl (@cehunt57) who has lived with diabetes her whole life. Tedious? You bet, EVERY day, proper diet, exercise, monitor glucose and medicate as needed.

What is your current management routine?

Jump to this post

What is the "proper diet" that you adhere to to manage your diabetes?

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.