Anyone else had thyroid tissue regrowth after a total thyroidectomy?

Posted by avawein @avawein, Sep 12, 2021

Hi All. In 2004 I had a total thyroidectomy for nodules that were suddenly growing quite rapidly (non-cancerous). Two years ago I was diagnosed with a neuroendocrine tumor in my terminal ileum which was surgically removed. In the last month, they found two stable tumors in my liver but the CT scan and subsequent PET scan also showed what appears to be thyroid tissue (3+ cm long) in the left thyroid bed. My doctors showed skepticism that I had a total thyroidectomy but I have records to prove it. Has anyone else had thyroid tissue regrowth after a total thyroidectomy? I have a biopsy scheduled in two days. Thanks.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Thyroid Cancer Support Group.

I'm truly sorry you're going through this too. I had my thyroid out due to cancerous nodules. Biopsy was definitely an experience but after surgery I felt so much better. Was having swelling & swallowing issues before surgery. Was better after. I was placed with a speech therapist that helped me with swallowing & speaking. A true godsend! I suggest you ask your Dr about starting that. It'll give you more confidence over the situation. And relaxation techniques as well. Try doing breathing exercises & get outside if you can. Taking one day at a time & focusing on the good things in life is what gets me through. Good luck to you & let us know how things go. You are not alone! Reach out!
God bless!

REPLY
Profile picture for chastp @chastp

I had my thyroid totally removed in 2010. I’ve had GERD and have been on Prilosec for years and now Protonix. I’ve had a lot of heart burn and tickling in my throat etc. Now I’m finding out my thyroid seems to have regrown in the left side but also down to my sternum manubriim. I had a CT scan in October 2023 then my surgeon just suddenly left the practice. I got a needle aspiration biopsy and the specimen only contained blood. No tissue. So then I had to wait to see my new surgeon and he has now ordered a new CT scan for tomorrow. And then an interventional radiologist will do a biopsy using the CT to guide him. I’m actually quite scarred. It sounds like the surgery will be very invasive and difficult and since the surgeon saw a large 4CM mass in a difficult spot back in October he is very concerned it could be a worse scenario. My thorax is being pushed to the right because of the mass. When I had my thyroid removed they found a minimal carcinoma and I wondered why they didn’t follow up much closer because I have had the symptoms for a long time and been treated for GERDS when it’s something related to my thyroid regrowth. I haven’t been able to sleep much because it seems my throat is getting tighter and tighter and now I have congestion in my throat causing some panic moments. I tested for Covid and that was negative. I’ve lost my appetite because I ‘m worried I’ll choke. I will write more after I get results from tomorrows CT scan. Wish I was more hopeful.

Jump to this post

This is so hard! I am sorry you are going through this.
Hoping the new CT gives some direction. I know its frightening, but try to keep calm and relaxed. Stress will only increase your symptoms and anxiety. Try some deep breathing , breath in to count of 5 and out to count of 10.
Get some time in the sun and please at least drink protein shakes to keep your health up . Let us know how your CT goes.

REPLY
Profile picture for chastp @chastp

I had my thyroid totally removed in 2010. I’ve had GERD and have been on Prilosec for years and now Protonix. I’ve had a lot of heart burn and tickling in my throat etc. Now I’m finding out my thyroid seems to have regrown in the left side but also down to my sternum manubriim. I had a CT scan in October 2023 then my surgeon just suddenly left the practice. I got a needle aspiration biopsy and the specimen only contained blood. No tissue. So then I had to wait to see my new surgeon and he has now ordered a new CT scan for tomorrow. And then an interventional radiologist will do a biopsy using the CT to guide him. I’m actually quite scarred. It sounds like the surgery will be very invasive and difficult and since the surgeon saw a large 4CM mass in a difficult spot back in October he is very concerned it could be a worse scenario. My thorax is being pushed to the right because of the mass. When I had my thyroid removed they found a minimal carcinoma and I wondered why they didn’t follow up much closer because I have had the symptoms for a long time and been treated for GERDS when it’s something related to my thyroid regrowth. I haven’t been able to sleep much because it seems my throat is getting tighter and tighter and now I have congestion in my throat causing some panic moments. I tested for Covid and that was negative. I’ve lost my appetite because I ‘m worried I’ll choke. I will write more after I get results from tomorrows CT scan. Wish I was more hopeful.

Jump to this post

Wow! It is definitely a stressful situation! I would assume the GERD is acting up due to the stress of not really knowing what is going on and thinking some of the worse scenarios…..I have GERD too and it definitely reacts to stress! Some of your issues may be coincidental and not related to the growth so TRY not to get too worried about them; swallowing concerns might just be related to the GERD. Try not to worry too much about the radiologist scan with the needle biopsy…it’s the same as a regular FNA. I actually thought it was kind of cool…..the doctor is able to see where they put the needle to take the sample from…..it seems like a much more accurate way to due FNA! When I was being considered for RadioFrequency Ablation, the first needles for the FNA were filled with blood too; they just put the needle in a new location and did an additional test and then sent the material out for Affirma testing. I don’t know if Affirma testing is used on other areas or if it is just thyroid, however it is supposed to be a very good prediction for cancer. The waiting and not knowing is definitely tough! However, on a brighter note, the treatment options and surgical techniques have advanced significantly since your thyroidectomy was done, so you might have options you had never heard about. Radio-frequency Ablation, Cyberknife surgery, endoscopic surgery, etc….techniques and treatments have evolved, so once you find out what is going on, the treatment options might help to reduce the stress. Try to remain positive…scar tissue can really muck things up so you don’t want to assume the worse and get yourself all stressed out when it could be related to scar tissue. Sending positive thoughts your way! Good Luck!

REPLY

I had my thyroid totally removed in 2010. I’ve had GERD and have been on Prilosec for years and now Protonix. I’ve had a lot of heart burn and tickling in my throat etc. Now I’m finding out my thyroid seems to have regrown in the left side but also down to my sternum manubriim. I had a CT scan in October 2023 then my surgeon just suddenly left the practice. I got a needle aspiration biopsy and the specimen only contained blood. No tissue. So then I had to wait to see my new surgeon and he has now ordered a new CT scan for tomorrow. And then an interventional radiologist will do a biopsy using the CT to guide him. I’m actually quite scarred. It sounds like the surgery will be very invasive and difficult and since the surgeon saw a large 4CM mass in a difficult spot back in October he is very concerned it could be a worse scenario. My thorax is being pushed to the right because of the mass. When I had my thyroid removed they found a minimal carcinoma and I wondered why they didn’t follow up much closer because I have had the symptoms for a long time and been treated for GERDS when it’s something related to my thyroid regrowth. I haven’t been able to sleep much because it seems my throat is getting tighter and tighter and now I have congestion in my throat causing some panic moments. I tested for Covid and that was negative. I’ve lost my appetite because I ‘m worried I’ll choke. I will write more after I get results from tomorrows CT scan. Wish I was more hopeful.

REPLY
Profile picture for khd003 @khd003

I felt the same! When they first called (after a MRI) to tell me that I needed to follow up with my endocrinologist about a “mass on my thyroid” - I told them but I don’t have a thyroid! I couldn’t believe it had grown back. Felt like something from a sci-fi movie…and of course it had to grow back with multiple nodules again. 😣

Jump to this post

Can I ask what type your nodules show? (Assume you had biopsy)

REPLY
Profile picture for bevr @bevr

In 2000 I had a thyroid nodule that was growing pretty quickly. The endocrinologist said it was "precancerous" and needed to come out. My entire thyroid was removed. The surgeon said "we got it all", but I was never told definitively whether it was cancer or not. Since then I've been taking synthroid or levoxyl. My T4/T3 seemed OK and I was feeling OK, but I wasn't being followed for any sort of cancer. Last October I noticed a growth in my neck in the thyroid bed. The results of an ultrasound looked pretty scary, but two biopsies didn't detect anything. After surgery in January, the 3.5 cm lump was found to be solid Hurthle Cell Cancer. IRT last week showed a very small invasion in the neck area, and I'll find out if any of it was killed by the radiation in two days. I'm hoping against hope that the radiation worked, because HCC is very stubborn.

In my opinion, when my "thyroid grew back", the lump should have been removed immediately. If my thyroid was completely removed 20 years ago, what else could it be but cancer? Even if non-malignant, you don't want extra tissue hanging around. Additionally, HCC is difficult to detect vis biopsy. Whatever it was, I would have chosen to remove it. As a good friend of mine always says, "why fool around?"

Thanks for listening and good luck everyone!

Jump to this post

Do you mind who was your surgeon removing the lump? Thank you,

REPLY
Profile picture for ameliajones @ameliajones

In 2016 I had a complete thyroidectomy. By 2018, both lobes of my thyroid had grown back.

Jump to this post

Hi @ameliajones, was the growth non-cancerous? Did you have to have further treatment? How are you doing today?

REPLY

In 2016 I had a complete thyroidectomy. By 2018, both lobes of my thyroid had grown back.

REPLY
Profile picture for molly0102 @molly0102

Hi, IDK if you or any of the other commenters have received any clear answers to their concerns; but here is my experience. I had a complete thyroidectomy due to multiple cancerous tumors. A few years later I had symptoms of a reoccurrence. Doctor did not show much concern since all the typical thyroid levels post surgery and replacement hormones were normal. I sought a second opinion with “Dr. Google” 🙃. I found in rare cases a cancer reoccurrence can be missed if a Thyroid hormone ANTIBODY test is not also ordered. I demanded that blood test; and it was sky high. There is a special scan (I can’t recall what it is called - but it is definitely not a CT nor a sonogram, PET, nor MRI). The scan uses an iodine contrast to pick up thyroid cells, because that’s where microscopic cancer cells could have survived and regrow looking and behaving as a thyroid gland tissue would. My treatment was radiation. Since then I have not had another reoccurrence or regrowth. And now the antibody test is routine. I hope this helps give you some additional information to run by your doctors.

Jump to this post

First, I am a 52-year-young survivor of papillary ca of thyroid. Despite a total thyroidectomy in 7-72, some thyroid tissue has regrowth. But according to ultrasound, nothing malignant, so far. I'm grateful that my surgeon opted to do such a radical surgery, despite the after-effects of years of depression, anxiety, need to eat within a 6-8-hour fast period, periodic need to monitor dosage of Synthroid which changes during the aging process, as does the need to head off osteoporosis & bone breakage as a petite woman without a thyroid gland. Why am I grateful for such a radical surgery that took me 2 years to recover from just the initial after-effects in my late 20's? The total thyroidectomy taught me how to take care of myself on 3 fronts: physical, emotional, spiritual. The pain & suffering I experienced motivated me to stand up and speak up to medical practitioners who were more interested in their bottom line than in my health care. Exercise, nutrition, & self-advocacy became tools of health care that I practice daily to maintain wellness. Meditation, prayer, & support groups for family members of chronically ill patients have taught me how to be there for myself when others are not. I do not give away my trust to people, places, or overprescribed medications as I used to in my youth & middle age. That surgeon removed the source of cancer in my body, 52 years ago. That was a big loss & big gain at the same time. Without the pain & suffering that followed, I would not have changed from a victim to a victor, from a doormat to an abusive 1st husband to the tiger I am now who is learning how to be kinder & gentler with everyone, especially myself. Hope this helps you with the overall big picture of post thyroid surgery. My biggest accomplishment to date: Learning how to accept reality, advocate in partnership with trustworthy m.d.'s for holistic wellness, and pay my life experience forward to others in need. Welcome to the club of thyroid surgery survivors & thrives. Know that you too can heal yourself from cancer & many other chronic or life-long illnesses simply by taking care of yourself BEFORE you sacrifice your health, sanity, life itself for others who are out for themselves not you. If I am not for myself, who is for me? If I am only for myself, what am I? If I do not take action now, when will I ever take action? Hugs & healthy, happy New Year! Trudy

REPLY
Profile picture for khd003 @khd003

I’m having a very similar situation… I had a total thyroidectomy back in ‘99. My thyroid has grown back but not normal. It looks deformed and has grown back strangely. Unfortunately the nodules seem to be growing (per recent CT scan of my chest for another condition). I’m going for an ultrasound tomorrow. Hopefully I won’t need another surgery! 🙏

Jump to this post

Hi @khd003, I thought I'd check in. What did you learn at your ultrasound? Crossing my fingers that you don't need follow-up surgery. How are you doing?

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.