Mastectomy and breast reconstruction pros and cons?

Posted by kruzin @kruzin, Jul 8, 2018

Being treated for breast cancer, having a mastectomy and was wondering what people did for reconstruction?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Breast Cancer Support Group.

I wanted to add I had a 5cm tumor that turned out to be Her2+. I went with implants, my same size. The surgery? I am honestly telling you that the pain blocker they used gave me little to no pain at all. I had Norco for 3 days and then took Tylenol. I had my fallopian tubes and ovaries out at the first surgery. My middle hurt. Not by breast. I had the tumor side removed then the left side 11 months later.
Research. I have met a number of women who went flat and are very happy. I have barbie boobs as the BRCA2 I carry meant any breast tissue could be dangerous if left behind.
kayonson- My younger sister removed her ovaries and fallopian tubes 2 months after me. She has Brca2. Our older sister did not want the genetic test and still has not had it nearly 2.5 years since i was diagnosed. Last July, Ovarian Cancer stage 2. She is a vaccine and drug denier. To me she almost agrees to the 3 additional rounds of chemo and a pill they want her to take. She talked to my younger sister and did not say that. It is a person choice for sure. I do not know what your older sister said when it came back, but a 3rd time would have been tough.

REPLY
@lambchoptina2

I am a breast cancer survivor x2 twenty years apart. After the first mastectomy I elected to have my surgeon to leave a flap so I can have more time to think about an implant and more surgeries to follow. I wore a prosthesis for 16 years and though it was a bit heavy at that time, years passed and they got lighter. By means I am not saying they wear comfortable not a constant reminder of my cancer experience everyday when I took off my bra or showered. After my divorce I decided it was time to get the implant and they also reconstructed my good breast so in my mid 50’s I looked and felt pretty good. The doctor was talented and did a tattoo for me of my Ariola and nipple area. I was in heaven with both breast looking and feeling comfortable. He had enough flap so the implant fit perfectly and there was no need for an expander to stretch the skin before an implant could be inserted. A few years later I developed stage 3 breast cancer in the good redesigned breast. At that time I designed to go ahead and have then implant the expander at the same time as the mastectomy was being done. The theory.is that they expand the expander slowly every few weeks until they have enough skin to do the final implant. Unfortunately I had gotten mastitis in the breast cavity with the expander and was in the hospital fifth iv antibiotics for a few weeks trying to get the infection under control or I would lose the expander and any chance of having reconstruction. I guess I was lucky and I healed from the infection and about 7 months later I had the implant surgery. I can’t tell you enough about complications and so because there was no bottom ledge after the mastectomy my new implant failed and slipped down. After waiting months we did the surgery again using a mesh to hold the implant in place. Well the mesh stretch out and once again the breast dropped. I waited u til I found a different doctor in Palm Beach who had experience with this problem and reassured me it would not happen again. And so several years after several surgeries I took my last chance now in my early 60’s and had the implant done once again. What ever this doctor did worked! His name is Dr Lickstein. And although I did not get this breast tattooed I can now wear a normal bra and look in the mirror and see my warrior spirit. It takes strength, and it takes support so when you make this decision please hear my story and know that getting an implant can be complicated. Don’t let anyone tell you it’s easy because it is not physically nor emotionally easy to undergo surgeries. I also had 6 months of Chemotherapy while having the expander in. I pray every day that this cancer will not return. I am grateful one day at a time. Good luck sisters and brothers out there reading my story. I hope it helps someone. Tina

Jump to this post

Hello was the second cancer in the original breast that had cancer or on in the unaffected one

REPLY

I am a breast cancer survivor x2 twenty years apart. After the first mastectomy I elected to have my surgeon to leave a flap so I can have more time to think about an implant and more surgeries to follow. I wore a prosthesis for 16 years and though it was a bit heavy at that time, years passed and they got lighter. By means I am not saying they wear comfortable not a constant reminder of my cancer experience everyday when I took off my bra or showered. After my divorce I decided it was time to get the implant and they also reconstructed my good breast so in my mid 50’s I looked and felt pretty good. The doctor was talented and did a tattoo for me of my Ariola and nipple area. I was in heaven with both breast looking and feeling comfortable. He had enough flap so the implant fit perfectly and there was no need for an expander to stretch the skin before an implant could be inserted. A few years later I developed stage 3 breast cancer in the good redesigned breast. At that time I designed to go ahead and have then implant the expander at the same time as the mastectomy was being done. The theory.is that they expand the expander slowly every few weeks until they have enough skin to do the final implant. Unfortunately I had gotten mastitis in the breast cavity with the expander and was in the hospital fifth iv antibiotics for a few weeks trying to get the infection under control or I would lose the expander and any chance of having reconstruction. I guess I was lucky and I healed from the infection and about 7 months later I had the implant surgery. I can’t tell you enough about complications and so because there was no bottom ledge after the mastectomy my new implant failed and slipped down. After waiting months we did the surgery again using a mesh to hold the implant in place. Well the mesh stretch out and once again the breast dropped. I waited u til I found a different doctor in Palm Beach who had experience with this problem and reassured me it would not happen again. And so several years after several surgeries I took my last chance now in my early 60’s and had the implant done once again. What ever this doctor did worked! His name is Dr Lickstein. And although I did not get this breast tattooed I can now wear a normal bra and look in the mirror and see my warrior spirit. It takes strength, and it takes support so when you make this decision please hear my story and know that getting an implant can be complicated. Don’t let anyone tell you it’s easy because it is not physically nor emotionally easy to undergo surgeries. I also had 6 months of Chemotherapy while having the expander in. I pray every day that this cancer will not return. I am grateful one day at a time. Good luck sisters and brothers out there reading my story. I hope it helps someone. Tina

REPLY

@cowgirl0713 I am new to this too and navigating my way. I have an appointment with the surgeon today. This thread is very helpful to hear from others who are in the same journey.

REPLY
@tborengasser

Newly diagnosed invasive cell carcinoma grade 3. My tumor is 5 mm. I am trying to decide if I should go with implants or the flap procedure. Any help on recovery times for both as I’m so scared about pain control and healing times. Leaning toward a double mastectomy.

Jump to this post

@tborengasser, welcome. Fellow new member @cowgirl0713 is weighing the same options. You may wish to join others talking about implants vs flap here:
– Mastectomy and breast reconstruction pros and cons? https://connect.mayoclinic.org/comment/957172/

REPLY
@cowgirl0713

@colleenyoung1
I’m noticing that the latest entries available are mostly from January of this year? That’s ALOT of months with no recent activity…? Is this normal? Am I in a currently active group? Please advise, and thank you. ☺️

Jump to this post

@cowgirl0713, I hope you also saw the recent posts over the last 3 days offering your tips and support. Start reading here: https://connect.mayoclinic.org/comment/958845/

There are hundreds of posts made daily to Mayo Clinic Connect, many of them in the Breast Cancer support group. You are most definitely in the current active group. See here: https://connect.mayoclinic.org/group/breast-cancer/

One of the things I also like about this site is the good advice remains good advice. Sometimes the tips, information and support members shared months and years ago still ring true today, including facing tough choices in reconstruction with breast cancer.

You might also appreciate these videos from Mayo Clinic experts.
- Videos about Breast Cancer Surgery from Mayo Experts
https://connect.mayoclinic.org/discussion/videos-about-breast-cancer-surgery-from-mayo-experts/

REPLY
@colleenyoung

@jdh65, As you probably already know, fat grafting (or autologous fat transfer) is a new breast reconstruction technique. Because fat grafting is so new, no large clinical studies have been done on the procedure. The studies that have been done involve fewer than 100 women and the average follow-up time is less than 4 years.

I believe @boathouse @kwyskiel @jboisjolie @celica have had fat grafting reconstruction done or considered it.

JDH, what factors are you considering as you make your decision?

Jump to this post

@colleenyoung1
I’m noticing that the latest entries available are mostly from January of this year? That’s ALOT of months with no recent activity…? Is this normal? Am I in a currently active group? Please advise, and thank you. ☺️

REPLY

Newly diagnosed invasive cell carcinoma grade 3. My tumor is 5 mm. I am trying to decide if I should go with implants or the flap procedure. Any help on recovery times for both as I’m so scared about pain control and healing times. Leaning toward a double mastectomy.

REPLY
@cowgirl0713

Just at the VERY beginning of my journey and interested in any info on the pros and cons of DIEP vs Implants. Overwhelmed, scared and SO MUCH to process.

Jump to this post

@cowgirl0713, I can imagine you're overwhelmed with all the information and decision making. You got helpful responses from several members.

Have you been able to make a decision? How are you doing?

REPLY

I'm thinking that sounds like a VERY good option for you, considering your family history. I will have the DIEP procedure in 2 weeks. My appointment with the oncology surgeon is today, I have my plastic surgeon all ready to go.
I've read it's super painful and that a pain block is the way to go. Also a pain pump to go home with. Not sure of the proper names...
Anyhow. I responded really well to the chemo with HER2+. What type of cancer do you have ?
Also I can't imagine that this new procedure has not gone through larger studies. Crazy! I'm going to look in to that for sure.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.