Gleason 7 (4+3) radiation, but ADT also? Over treatment?

Posted by zooblio6 @zooblio6, Dec 26, 2024

Hello,

I will be 80 next August and apart from newly diagnosed PC am in good overall health. I have a diagnosis of Gleason 7 (4+3) Grade 3, T2a with a five year PSA of 0.6. Six cores positive in the recent biopsy. No spread to the bones or organs as indicated by CT scans etc. I see my urologist on 7th January and am concerned that he will propose ADT in addition to the inevitable RT ( I suspect IRMT ).

The side effects concern me ( although I already have erectile dysfunction ) mostly those concern possible memory loss, bone and muscle loss and cardiovascular risk ( I have controlled high blood pressure ).

I have read several recent reports that indicate that ADT may represent overtreatment in older patients and the more so where the cancer grows more slowly. Quality of life is key for me and my wife.

Can anyone please give a measured/qualified overview please. Thank you.

David

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Prostate Cancer Support Group.

@heavyphil

So perhaps the addition of ADT earlier might have made a difference? But I think you’ve pointed out that the BRCA2 problem might have even eclipsed ADT and caused the cancer to come back anyway.
I guess today you would have gotten the triplet therapy regimen - that’s ADT combo plus chemo?
Still amazing to me that you have beaten this thing back for 17 years and are still standing strong….Happy New Year, Jeff, and thank you once again for all your help, knowledge and support!
Phil

Jump to this post

It really is 15 years not 17. I never had metastasis in the first eight years, So I don’t think chemo would’ve been in the picture even if they knew I had BRCA2. Only one Metastasis on the spine (L4) so far. Waiting for the pin to drop!!!

People are SO different in how their bodies react to PC. I don’t know if it helps but mentally I have not really been concerned about my PC getting worse. I don’t really think about it, Even when waiting for the results of my monthly PSA tests. Does mental attitude make a difference??? Nahhhhh!!

REPLY
@jeffmarc

Your timing for getting off ADT sounds just right. Just make sure to get those PSA tests no less than every three months.

I went from 4 abiraterone pills to 3 to try and improved brain fog issues. In 18 days, my PSA went from .2 to 1. I went right back on four pills. Just something to think about, Mine was never below .09 and you are able to get to .03, yours is essentially undetectable.

You don’t mention a decipher score. Is there any chance you could get one, That can tell you how aggressive your cancer is, more info than the Gleason score.

Have a great New Year.

Jump to this post

Thanks for your comments and I will ask about the decipher score which has not been mentioned to me by my care team.
Happy New Year to you as well!

REPLY
@jeffmarc

I had salvage radiation and no ADT. Took 2.5 years to come back, and I have BRCA2. Then I started ADT.

Jump to this post

So perhaps the addition of ADT earlier might have made a difference? But I think you’ve pointed out that the BRCA2 problem might have even eclipsed ADT and caused the cancer to come back anyway.
I guess today you would have gotten the triplet therapy regimen - that’s ADT combo plus chemo?
Still amazing to me that you have beaten this thing back for 17 years and are still standing strong….Happy New Year, Jeff, and thank you once again for all your help, knowledge and support!
Phil

REPLY

Thanks Jeff ,
I am a Prostate Cancer Advocate . I am pretty much up to date on the International Current & Emerging Treatments , many of which have been slow on the uptake by the FDA .
I plan to avoid ADT at all costs if possible . Sometimes the cure is worse than the disease . I have personal experience watching both my brothers-in-law . They were dignosed at stage 4 -- Both passed inside 2 years .
Ages 89 AND 86 . Both had listened to the BS theory : " You will die with cancer - Not from it" and had stopped getting their PSA .

REPLY
@heavyphil

I actually read this article when I first knew I would need salvage radiation. I consulted with an RO who totally agreed with the article, telling me that any PSA less than .7 did not need ADT, only radiation.
I then consulted with Sloan and they said I DID need ADT, which had been my feeling, in spite of the newer findings. I asked my urologist what he thought and he said that although the newer findings supported the idea of no ADT, 6 months on Orgovyx in an otherwise healthy or medically supervised patient “couldn’t hurt”.
My feeling was that my Gleason 4+3 unfavorable just might be a bit more aggressive than “Intermediate” might imply and even though my surgical pathology was negative, it STILL recurred. So I wanted to hit it as hard as I could so hopefully I could end this problem once and for all🤞

Jump to this post

I had salvage radiation and no ADT. Took 2.5 years to come back, and I have BRCA2. Then I started ADT.

REPLY
@clandeboye1

Jeff,
What age is your brother now ? What were his side effects ?
Thanks .
p.s. I am considering Monotherapy SBRT . I am coming 85 years young.

Jump to this post

He is 79

Side effects were hot flashes from being on ADT for six months, It lasted for a year after ADT was stopped. Use Orgovyx for the ADT drug and your testosterone will recover quickly. Ask your doctor if he thinks it’s appropriate for you.

He had problems peeing so he went on Flomax and that resolved it. He had that problem for about a year, on and off.

Your monotherapy option sounds just right, But I am not a doctor. I have not reviewed your medical scans and documentation so I don’t know exactly what’s going on. If it’s truly isolated to the prostate, then SBRT works great for most people. At your age you have many more years before prostate cancer becomes an issue, there are so many treatments.

REPLY

Your timing for getting off ADT sounds just right. Just make sure to get those PSA tests no less than every three months.

I went from 4 abiraterone pills to 3 to try and improved brain fog issues. In 18 days, my PSA went from .2 to 1. I went right back on four pills. Just something to think about, Mine was never below .09 and you are able to get to .03, yours is essentially undetectable.

You don’t mention a decipher score. Is there any chance you could get one, That can tell you how aggressive your cancer is, more info than the Gleason score.

Have a great New Year.

REPLY
@jeffmarc

For Gleason eight they recommend 18 months of ADT. You can stop sooner, ask your doctor what they think, but most people don’t do this unless they are undetectable for At least a few months.

If you do stop, get PSA test no less than every three months, At least for a while to make sure your cancer is not coming back.

Jump to this post

My prayer everyday is to get off of Orgovyx plus Abberaterone (plus Prednisone) to regain testosterone and quality of life.
I’m 68 with Gleason 8, stage 3 advanced,and baseline PSA of 7.0
I’m 9 months into ADT and 43 radiation treatments this past summer.
I’ve taken to heart from the start of ADT the crucially important need for daily resistance training and it has made a major difference for me.
Last PSA score in Nov was 0.03 so I’m hoping to string together maybe 3 more of those or better scores (9 months) and get off ADT earlier than the prescribed 24 months.
Thanks in advance for any thoughts/comments

REPLY
@jeffmarc

Everyone is different. There is no set answer we can give you as to whether or not that will be all you ever need for treatment. It is becoming more common to have a few SBRT sessions along with IMRT. The SBRT sessions concentrate on the prostate while IMRT Sessions Focus on the prostate bed.

My brother with a 4+3 had only five sessions of SBRT. No need to do the whole prostate bed since his cancer had not spread. He was 76 when this was done.

I am really puzzled by your comments about your PSA. You say it’s always been .6, Are you sure about that? If it’s that low, then you may need an FDG scan because you may not be producing PSMA either.

A CT scan cannot find all of the cancer in somebody’s body. A PSMA pet scan is a much better choice since it can actually see metastasis, which a CT scan cannot see. Can you get a PSMA pet scan Before doing radiation. That may not be enough, however, if you don’t produce PSMA either than you need an FDG scan.

Some more things to think about.

Jump to this post

Jeff,
What age is your brother now ? What were his side effects ?
Thanks .
p.s. I am considering Monotherapy SBRT . I am coming 85 years young.

REPLY
@itsaquarter23

I have similar concerns. In the following medical journal article (https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10949134/), the University of Michigan authors write, "Although improvements in biochemical failure might be important, we must not forget that non-prostate cancer deaths remain the dominant mode of death, and treatments can worsen other-cause mortality. For example, the addition of hormone therapy to salvage radiotherapy in patients with PSA less than 1.5 increased other-cause mortality and cardiac events. Thus, the poor correlation of biochemical failure-free survival with overall survival might also be due to treatment intensification resulting in worsened other-cause mortality without greater improvements in prostate cancer-specific mortality." Of course, every case is different. But the point the authors were making is that treatments like ADT take a toll of their own. I recommend reading that medical journal article in its entirety. You'll find it at the link that I provided.

Jump to this post

I actually read this article when I first knew I would need salvage radiation. I consulted with an RO who totally agreed with the article, telling me that any PSA less than .7 did not need ADT, only radiation.
I then consulted with Sloan and they said I DID need ADT, which had been my feeling, in spite of the newer findings. I asked my urologist what he thought and he said that although the newer findings supported the idea of no ADT, 6 months on Orgovyx in an otherwise healthy or medically supervised patient “couldn’t hurt”.
My feeling was that my Gleason 4+3 unfavorable just might be a bit more aggressive than “Intermediate” might imply and even though my surgical pathology was negative, it STILL recurred. So I wanted to hit it as hard as I could so hopefully I could end this problem once and for all🤞

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.