Anyone dealing with Atypical Ductal Hyperplasia (ADH)?

Posted by EJ @elsajohnson, Aug 7, 2018

I am sorry if this is not the right forum. I know ADH is not cancer and this is a breast cancer forum, but I can't find another forum that may be more relevant.

I am wondering if there is anyone who is dealing with ADH or has been diagnosed with ADH that can share their experience. I was diagnosed a month ago. While I am relieved that I don't have cancer, I am confused with the radiology report that shows BI-RAD6 - surgical removal is recommended. I have seen a breast oncology surgeon and I don't think she took me seriously because I don't have cancer. It almost feels like I wasted her time seeing her because I don't have cancer. If ADH is no big deal, why BI-RAD 6 (which i understand is for biopsy proven malignancy). I also read up about ADH online and understand that with ADH, my risk for breast cancer is 4x. Should I not worry about it and just do annual check? Should i see another breast surgeon? Should I see an oncologist? Do I need genetic testing to better understand my risk? I feel like an impostor for even posting this on a breast cancer forum but I am genuinely confused and concerned. Any help will be greatly appreciated.

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Breast Cancer Support Group.

Profile picture for ckf1317 @ckf1317

I was actually considering posting similar questions on this forum but wasn't sure it would be the right place. They found microcalcifications in a routine mammogram 3 yrs ago, I was put on a schedule of having a mammogram every 6 mths, there had been no changes, so a year ago I was released to going back to a yearly mammo. I had the mammo beginning of July, they found new microcalcifications with a dense area near them, did an ultrasound the same day, and had an opening that day to do a core needle biopsy so I took it. Didn't want to wait. The local lab had to send the biopsy to Mayo to examine and the dx was ADH. The radiologist recommended a MRI of both breasts, to make sure there were no other areas of concern, before doing a surgical excision to remove the remaining area. He referred me to a surgeon who specializes in breast cancer surgery. I had the surgery 2 wks ago, they biopsied the tissue removed and found they got all of the ADH and no cancer cells were found. I was so thankful. I asked my surgeon about genetic testing, she referred me to a genetecist. I just had the appt with him 8/6 and was told even w/o doing the testing, based upon my personal history and mostly due to the ADH dx, my chance of breast cancer went up from 12%(avg risk for my age-47) to 41%. He explained based upon that % I will require follow ups every 6mths (which the Radiologist had already indicated in his report I should have follow up MRI in 6 mos) but it also opened up other options such as bilateral masectomy or medication to lessen the chance of further changes. I am pre-menopausal and my surgeon recommended against the drugs. I am wondering if anyone else has had ADH, but not cancer, and decided to have a preventative masectomy?

Jump to this post

@ckf1317

Hello, I highly recommend genetic testing! It is one of the best things I ever did and gave me more information and some peace of mind. I had DCIS stage zero and genetic testing showed negative for BRCA gene and I had no history in my family of breast cancer. My pathology March 2024 report after the lumpectomy showed margins were negative/clear, negative for residual ductal carcinoma in situ and showed some residual Atypia. Atypical cells are not cancer cells but a possible indicator you may or may not develop cancer in the future. The surgeon in her report noted there was no residual DCIS, as it was ALL was taken out during the biopsies. Doctors have very different opinions about how ADH and DCIS should be treated given that there are a lot of Factors to consider. I did a lot of my own research when I got the results of mammogram, ultrasound and breast MRI and consultation with my care team at Mayo. Please continue to ask questions and seek out information and research articles. I continue to get yearly mammogram and ultrasound and a Breast MRI with contrast. My recent post surgery reports done in 2024 and 2025 were normal. Although I am waiting the results of breast MRI for 2025. It is a test that gives you more information and some peace of mind along with genetic results. Good luck to you and hope things turn out well.

REPLY
Profile picture for rivergirl76 @rivergirl76

Yes..I had breast cancer 3 years ago in my left breast and went through radiation
Last week I went for my annual mamo and something showed so I had a breast biopsy a few days ago and was diagnosed with atypical ductile hyperplasia . It's in the same breast that I had cancer in. Have an appointment next week with my Oncologist. Any thing I can learn about this would be appreciated

Jump to this post

@rivergirl76, waiting for the appointment with your oncologist must've been hard. What did you find out? Next steps?

REPLY
Profile picture for winniekl @winniekl

I apologize if these have been discussed previously. Anyone has advice on effective preventative methods in addition to regular screening? Are you seeing effective results from stopping ADH and or benign reoccurrence with the preventative method you are using? I understand diet, exercise and stress play a big part. It sounds like some are experiencing reoccurrence regardless. I have 3 kids and the last one was from about 6 years ago. I breastfed all three for about 6 months. 4 years ago, l started experiencing pain on the side of my left breast. Mammograms didn’t find anything. Pain went away eventually. I also started taking birth control pills about 3 years ago and the breast pain came back on and off. Last year, l had dark reddish brown discharge. Mammogram and ultrasound didn’t find anything. Breast surgeon suggested MRI and it found a 7cm enhancement and a couple small masses in the outside of my left breast. Had core needle and they found ADH. Got an open biopsy done and got the masses removed. ocologist said l’m eligible for Tamoxifen but my calculated risk was 2.5% but there could be a chance getting uterus cancer from taking the meds, so l decided to go with monitoring route. I stopped taking birth control pills after the discharge happened. Last month l started seeing a caramel color discharge on my left breast but went away after a couple days. It came back this month and l’m also feeling quick pitch on the top of my left breast when l breath hard or stress the chest muscle sometimes. Going in for imaging tomorrow.

Jump to this post

@winniekl, I wanted to check in with you. Any results from imaging? How are you doing?

REPLY

Yes..I had breast cancer 3 years ago in my left breast and went through radiation
Last week I went for my annual mamo and something showed so I had a breast biopsy a few days ago and was diagnosed with atypical ductile hyperplasia . It's in the same breast that I had cancer in. Have an appointment next week with my Oncologist. Any thing I can learn about this would be appreciated

REPLY

I apologize if these have been discussed previously. Anyone has advice on effective preventative methods in addition to regular screening? Are you seeing effective results from stopping ADH and or benign reoccurrence with the preventative method you are using? I understand diet, exercise and stress play a big part. It sounds like some are experiencing reoccurrence regardless. I have 3 kids and the last one was from about 6 years ago. I breastfed all three for about 6 months. 4 years ago, l started experiencing pain on the side of my left breast. Mammograms didn’t find anything. Pain went away eventually. I also started taking birth control pills about 3 years ago and the breast pain came back on and off. Last year, l had dark reddish brown discharge. Mammogram and ultrasound didn’t find anything. Breast surgeon suggested MRI and it found a 7cm enhancement and a couple small masses in the outside of my left breast. Had core needle and they found ADH. Got an open biopsy done and got the masses removed. ocologist said l’m eligible for Tamoxifen but my calculated risk was 2.5% but there could be a chance getting uterus cancer from taking the meds, so l decided to go with monitoring route. I stopped taking birth control pills after the discharge happened. Last month l started seeing a caramel color discharge on my left breast but went away after a couple days. It came back this month and l’m also feeling quick pitch on the top of my left breast when l breath hard or stress the chest muscle sometimes. Going in for imaging tomorrow.

REPLY
Profile picture for ls108 @ls108

Thank you for your comment. It's easy to spiral after an ADH diagnosis and a good reminder that many many women don't end up with cancer. I'm personally opting for preventive screenings and may see another breast specialist to assess risks and get a second opinion. The medical community and organizations have good intentions but sometimes they seem to suck you into their system of overtreatment and don't offer realistic information about/minimize excisional surgeries. When the health care orgs do their part, they save lives, but ADH requires a nuanced risk-benefit analysis and more needs to be done to really educate the patient and avoid using a sledgehammer to crack a nut.

Jump to this post

"ADH requires a nuanced risk-benefit analysis and more needs to be done to really educate the patient and avoid using a sledgehammer to crack a nut."

Well said, @ls108!

How often do you get screened? Did you decide to seek a second opinion?

REPLY
Profile picture for kingmullen1 @kingmullen1

Hi: I had something similar. Mine was years of calcium calcification's on the Screening Mammo, then having to go back for a Diagnostic Mammo on the one breast. Last year had a Stereotactic Biopsy where 11 samples were taken. Came back ADH. A year later (this year,) I had an MRI and nothing showed up. Breast Surgeon still wants to do an excision. Having a 3D Mammo Cad tomorrow. If that is ok, I think I will cancel the Excision surgery.
Surprised knowone on this thread has mentioned the brutality of these breast Excisions/lumpectomies. It is shocking to me, at this point we haven't come closer to MIS (Laparoscopy etc.) for just simple verification of cancer. It all seems very extreme to me. It is the same surgery as a person I know that had a cancerous lump removed. I spoke to one Breast doctor who also uses a Robot in other surgery and she agreed with me. She said the problem lays with the FDA and that it has not been approved as "standard of care," treatment. So if she did it, and something happened....she would have difficulty with her Mal-practice insurance. As far as I'm concerned, it should be a half inch incision. Come on FDA. Some trials are completed and great success with MIS's, so lets move along.
I realize many of you on this forum ended up getting cancer and went on to much more extensive surgery. I would and did do the same with all my female plumbing, with a cancer diagnosis. But, hundreds of thousands of women get the ADH diagnosis and DO NOT end up with cancer. It is invasive surgery and it does carry risk. Requires recovery and possibility of infection.
I wish there was push back from the Breast Cancer Organizations and Doctors, to make the need for further surgical excision, less invasive.

Jump to this post

Thank you for your comment. It's easy to spiral after an ADH diagnosis and a good reminder that many many women don't end up with cancer. I'm personally opting for preventive screenings and may see another breast specialist to assess risks and get a second opinion. The medical community and organizations have good intentions but sometimes they seem to suck you into their system of overtreatment and don't offer realistic information about/minimize excisional surgeries. When the health care orgs do their part, they save lives, but ADH requires a nuanced risk-benefit analysis and more needs to be done to really educate the patient and avoid using a sledgehammer to crack a nut.

REPLY
Profile picture for debbie2721 @debbie2721

That sounds like the standard treatment. You will be screened often which is a good thing. I have the same diagnosis but I am past the child bearing age. I was given another drug first but had to stop because of terrible leg pain. You should do well and good luck.

Jump to this post

I am post menopause and had the same thing biopsy with ADH, and then a lumpectomy. I saw an oncologist and started Tamoxifen. I was on it for about six months at half dose but still had some of the side effects... weight gain, acne, joint pain.

I had to stop taking it for a few months because I needed surgery for a different issue.

A few months later I had a pelvic MRI done and had an enlarged ovary and thickened uterus. This is a small, low risk possible side effect of Tamoxifen. I ended up having a hysterectomy that revealed a polyp on my uterus that was hyperplasia. Luckily caught before it might have become cancer.

Again, the chances of that happening are low but something to consider discussing with your oncologist. I am going to try Raloxifene. It's not quite as effective as Tamoxifen but I have chosen not to take Tamoxifen again since I'm apparently sensitive to it.

There are many people who do very well on Tamoxifen.

Wishing you all the best!!

REPLY
Profile picture for krish77 @krish77

I was diagnosed with ADH back in June. My OB GYN was very concerned so I had a needle biopsy done. That is when I received diagnosis of ADH. So I was referred to General Surgeon for excisional biopsy. That surgery was done about a month and a half ago.
Fast forward to last OB appt, I will no longer be able to take any type of birth control as the estrogen can contribute to getting breast cancer. The surgeon went over results that diagnosis is still ADH and no cancer found (YAY!), but he recommended me seeing an oncologist to possibly start treatment with Tamoxifen. I have consultation with Oncologist on Monday.

Jump to this post

That sounds like the standard treatment. You will be screened often which is a good thing. I have the same diagnosis but I am past the child bearing age. I was given another drug first but had to stop because of terrible leg pain. You should do well and good luck.

REPLY

I was diagnosed with ADH back in June. My OB GYN was very concerned so I had a needle biopsy done. That is when I received diagnosis of ADH. So I was referred to General Surgeon for excisional biopsy. That surgery was done about a month and a half ago.
Fast forward to last OB appt, I will no longer be able to take any type of birth control as the estrogen can contribute to getting breast cancer. The surgeon went over results that diagnosis is still ADH and no cancer found (YAY!), but he recommended me seeing an oncologist to possibly start treatment with Tamoxifen. I have consultation with Oncologist on Monday.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.