I find that naproxen works better for my RA so you might try it and see how it compares to the ibuprofen for you. Rx strength naproxen is double the OTC dose and is twice a day, with food. Tylenol has no anti inflammatory effect but I find it helps with the dull achy pain rather than the joint pain.
Since everyone responds differently to the RA meds, it can take awhile to find the right one for you. I hope that happens quickly!