← Return to Seeking advice on treatment options

Discussion

Seeking advice on treatment options

Prostate Cancer | Last Active: Oct 6, 2023 | Replies (35)

Comment receiving replies
@spino

This graph has been created by someone advocating a particular kind of treatment. I looked at the intermediate graph. How does it manage to use facts to advocate preferences? It's pretty simple, really. First, you decide how to group the data. You do this even though you may know that the data being grouped does not correspond across types of treatment. Then you decide how to present the data. The use of the ellipses helps to emphasize the positive presentation of the preferred treatment.
Bear in mind that this is just the opinion of one non-clinical observer. It does not mean that the data presented is not useful and I may be completely overlooking meaningful reasons why this portrayal might be appropriate.

Jump to this post


Replies to "This graph has been created by someone advocating a particular kind of treatment. I looked at..."

I agree about those ellipses. It's, better to review the source material. When was the study done? How many cases? Specifics of the treatment e.g. where and by whom was surgery done? Charactaristics of the population e.g. Gleason scores etc.?

When I probed more deeply, I decided to ignore the comparison ellipses. It looks authoritative, but as spino says, it is biased IMO.