Yes I am also concerned about the conflicting opinions!
Possibly the surgeon I have been using just doesn’t have enough experience and that is why? She had a surgery opening last week, but I declined and decided on getting a second opinion.

The surgeon that I am meeting with tomorrow is the one I had initially wanted (he was on sabbatical when this all started so I couldn’t see him) and he has lots of experience and is supposed to be the best.
Fingers crossed I made the right decision!