How much weight lifting is required to build bone?

Posted by cahabagirl @cahabagirl, May 28, 2023

After a full year of weekly Osteostrong sessions, my T scores remained the same: spine -1.7, right hip -1.5, and left hip -1.3. While I’m glad that the scores were no worse, I decided that it wasn’t worth the expense. My physician told me that I can increase my bone density with weightlifting even at the age of 73. I am 5’7” and weigh 122 lbs.
So, I’ve joined a nice fitness center at a fraction of the cost and signed up for a personal trainer for 6 months.

At our first session, I told the trainer that I want to build bone, and I’m training twice a week. We started with low weights and he has me increase the weights each time. He told me that I am likely to see an increase in weight due to the building of muscles. I admit that after only 5 sessions, I like the changes I’m seeing but I don’t want to look like a bodybuilder and certainly don’t want to have to buy a new wardrobe.
My question is how does one determine how much weight will build bone? I assume that amount would vary depending on each person’s physique. If so, how does one calculate that?

Interested in more discussions like this? Go to the Osteoporosis & Bone Health Support Group.

@foxy23

I am 73 yr and started bio identical hormones compounded specifically for me for 15 yrs. Even though my doctors wanted me off I stayed on because I had no hot flashes, no vagina dryness and my skin looked great. When I was 67 yrs I was dx with stage 1 breast cancer…estrogen dependent. My oncologist believes strongly that it was the HRT.
There isn’t breast cancer in my family, I don’t smoke and not overweight.
Perhaps if one gets off after 5 yrs, they would have the benefit but maybe not the scare.

Jump to this post

I was on a low dose HRT for 2 years immediately following menopause because at the time I had osteopenia (never had menopause symptoms). After the 2nd year I developed breast precancer (required surgery and now have ugly scars) and had to stop HRT because doctor said it can be a cause of cancer. I had no risk factors, no one in family with breast cancer, never smoked, not overweight. I am sorry I ever took HRT.

REPLY
@sarahstuart

As an Art History Student at one time, I have no credentials to answer your question. However, I have lifted weights, but hand surgery has me out of the gym. Yes, it will help your bones, improve your posture, and give you real confidence. Go for it and you body will thank you in little ways like no more stumbles.

Jump to this post

Thank you! I’ve been working out with a trainer now for a few months. I feel great and I’m hopeful that I’m building bone.

REPLY
@vgkime

Both the COMB study and MOTS studies on positive bone building with Strontium appear to be legitimate clinical trials and not done by a company who were selling their supplements. I would love your feedback and Margaret Martin's and Dr. McCormick's after looking at the these clinical trials. They used Strontium Citrate plus K2m7 , D and other micronutrients . According to these studies strontium affects the trabecular bone in a positive way.

Jump to this post

REPLY
@violetangel1111

I was on a low dose HRT for 2 years immediately following menopause because at the time I had osteopenia (never had menopause symptoms). After the 2nd year I developed breast precancer (required surgery and now have ugly scars) and had to stop HRT because doctor said it can be a cause of cancer. I had no risk factors, no one in family with breast cancer, never smoked, not overweight. I am sorry I ever took HRT.

Jump to this post

All women are at risk for breast cancer. The majority have no real risk factors. I certainly don't know what caused it but it may or may not have been the HRT. I have been told the breast cancer is there 10 years before it can be detected.

REPLY

From another mmcchesney | @kathleen1314 | Sep 6, 2020
In reply to @clarkedu "I am actively and urgently in the process of deciding which osteoporosis treatment I want to..." + (show)

Strontium citrate is an earth mineral similar to calcium. The body seems to use it in bone similar to the way it uses calcium. Research has shown that strontium seems to turn on calcium receptors in the body.
Some on this site have said that strontium produces false readings and that bone is not healthier as you use strontium. Research has not shown that to be the case. Instead research shows that strontium produces bone that is less likely to fracture and bone mineralization is kept. Research also shows that the dxa read may be as high as 10% too high because strontium is a heavier mineral. This is called the dxa skew, but as long as the dxa skews upward the actual number is not as important since many things may skew a dxa number including different dxa machines.

BoneLady has a good blog that shows current research and comparisons.
http://strontiumforbones.blogspot.com/2017/02/mots-and-comb-study-comparison.html
Here are some postings on Inspire with research for strontium
https://www.inspire.com/groups/national-osteoporosis-foundation/discussion/2011-report-that-strontium-is-17-times-as-effective-as-alendronate/
https://www.inspire.com/groups/national-osteoporosis-foundation/discussion/strontium-used-in-bone-tissue-remodeling/
https://www.inspire.com/groups/national-osteoporosis-foundation/discussion/strontium-does-it-prevent-fractures-research-articles-personal-stories/
I hope that this may be helpful as you research your options.
ember:

REPLY
@vgkime

Both the COMB study and MOTS studies on positive bone building with Strontium appear to be legitimate clinical trials and not done by a company who were selling their supplements. I would love your feedback and Margaret Martin's and Dr. McCormick's after looking at the these clinical trials. They used Strontium Citrate plus K2m7 , D and other micronutrients . According to these studies strontium affects the trabecular bone in a positive way.

Jump to this post

Hi @vgkime, Dr. Doug Lucas, a retired orthopedic surgeon now specializing in bone health has a number of videos on YouTube. He has this interesting discussion on strontium, is it a missing supplement to reverse osteoporosis or supplement to avoid at all costs:

https://duckduckgo.com/?q=Dr+Doug+Lucas+Strontium&atb=v314-1&t=chromentp&iax=videos&ia=videos&iai=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dl11S7vpXzOU
REPLY

Teri, thank you for the link. I like his approach, and found the information to be helpful. Love that he discussed the MOTS and COMB studies and the link of micronutrients working synergistically with Strontium Citrate.

REPLY
@fearfracture

From what I’ve read, there are doctors who think it’s safe to stay on HRT for life. The problem w/ HRT was w/ synthetic hormones, now bioidentical HRT is available and considered safe. https://mitchellmed.com/synthetic-vs-bioidentical-hormone-replacement-therapy/

If I were going through menopause today, I would start bioidentical HRT immediately. My problem is that I’ve been post-menopausal for over 2 decades and I don’t want to start something that will cause another health problem. At the moment, I’m leaning towards trying a very low dose HRT but I haven’t decided yet. If anyone reading this started HRT more than 10 yrs after menopause, I would love to hear about your experience.

Jump to this post

I started a low dose of only estrogen therapy last month. I had a hysterectomy and was on the patch for 30 years. When I had knee replacement 6 yrs ago the surgeon recommended removal of the patch due to potential blood clots. Very sorry I did cause now recently diagnosed with severe osteoporosis. I went to my o gun and she prescribed low dose of estrogen. I now exercise, bone strength ing, weights and walk 1/2 hour each day. I am choosing not to take any medication for treatment. I know a low dose won’t rebuild bones, but hopefully maintain them. Keep me posted as to what u decide to do.

REPLY
@vgkime

From another mmcchesney | @kathleen1314 | Sep 6, 2020
In reply to @clarkedu "I am actively and urgently in the process of deciding which osteoporosis treatment I want to..." + (show)

Strontium citrate is an earth mineral similar to calcium. The body seems to use it in bone similar to the way it uses calcium. Research has shown that strontium seems to turn on calcium receptors in the body.
Some on this site have said that strontium produces false readings and that bone is not healthier as you use strontium. Research has not shown that to be the case. Instead research shows that strontium produces bone that is less likely to fracture and bone mineralization is kept. Research also shows that the dxa read may be as high as 10% too high because strontium is a heavier mineral. This is called the dxa skew, but as long as the dxa skews upward the actual number is not as important since many things may skew a dxa number including different dxa machines.

BoneLady has a good blog that shows current research and comparisons.
http://strontiumforbones.blogspot.com/2017/02/mots-and-comb-study-comparison.html
Here are some postings on Inspire with research for strontium
https://www.inspire.com/groups/national-osteoporosis-foundation/discussion/2011-report-that-strontium-is-17-times-as-effective-as-alendronate/
https://www.inspire.com/groups/national-osteoporosis-foundation/discussion/strontium-used-in-bone-tissue-remodeling/
https://www.inspire.com/groups/national-osteoporosis-foundation/discussion/strontium-does-it-prevent-fractures-research-articles-personal-stories/
I hope that this may be helpful as you research your options.
ember:

Jump to this post

Thank you! I’ve been looking for this information.

REPLY
@vgkime

Teri, thank you for the link. I like his approach, and found the information to be helpful. Love that he discussed the MOTS and COMB studies and the link of micronutrients working synergistically with Strontium Citrate.

Jump to this post

I think he has a measured approach. He has a number of videos about osteoporosis, and they are very interesting. I'm glad it was helpful.

REPLY
Please sign in or register to post a reply.