← Return to Mastectomy instead of lumpectomy

Discussion

Mastectomy instead of lumpectomy

Breast Cancer | Last Active: Oct 24, 2023 | Replies (32)

Comment receiving replies
@janisbrede

When I said I wanted mastectomy over the recommended lumpectomy the doctors said that a mastectomy is a major surgery and probably not necessary. My thought was that I am the fittest and youngest I'm ever going to be NOW so do the invasive hard surgery now not 10 years down the line. They said mastectomy does not increase survival rate, which doesn't make sense to me. My thoughts are get rid of as many cells as possible in surgery and those cells won't come back to haunt me. Obviously, they could have already traveled elsewhere in the body but those in my chest are gone!

Jump to this post


Replies to "When I said I wanted mastectomy over the recommended lumpectomy the doctors said that a mastectomy..."

There is research showing that mastectomy can increase survival but they say there isn't enough data yet so they follow protocol. I have lobular carcinoma with bone only mets diagnosed de novo. Chemotherapy doesn't work for lobular as it does in the cdk4/6 studies for ductal so for me, mastectmy to reduce tumor burden makes sense. But it's difficult to find a surgeon who will step outside that box.