@isaish53n5 you're doing great with all this. I loved your description of being the star of the team. Good attitude! It sounds like your team is really on top of things. I only chose the mastecomy because of my BRCA2+ status. Listen to your doctor's advice, but don't hesitate to get that second opinion if unsure.

If your question is purely a cosmetic issue then it seems like missing 2" is better than all of it. I would think a lumpectomy would leave less of a scar than a mastectomy.