Hello Donna, People who have trouble producing sputum should not try to force it on their own. Rather they should be referred to a respiratory therapist for assistance. In addition to nebulizing saline, there are breathing and coughing techniques, positional drainage, percussion and devices that can be used to help.

Forceful, unproductive coughing can cause pain and irritation to lungs, throat, even ribs.

My current pulmonologist actually has an RT on her staff. My previous doc had an experienced RN to help. My friend in a smaller group practice was sent to the respiratory department of the local hospital.

Sue